Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Educational Knowledge - Does the improvement of teenagers' quality mainly depend on family or school training?
Does the improvement of teenagers' quality mainly depend on family or school training?
1 debate (main debate)

As we all know, school is a good place to teach and educate people. All of you here have no school education. The debate we are having now is a unique quality evaluation, which vividly reflects the school education. School education is the main body, family education is the foundation and social education is the support, which is the general cognition of the whole society on the educational function. It can be said that the majority of teenagers are blooming flowers on campus today, and tomorrow will be the pillars of the motherland.

Throughout the ages, the development of education has been branded with the footprints of schools. The prosperous families of 3,000 disciples of Confucius, private schools of all sizes under the feudal civil service system, and four famous academies in history have all accumulated the essence of Chinese culture! Now, we are singing "The Story of Spring" and striding into a new era, and our school education presents a colorful new scene. The innocent smiling faces of kindergarten children, the blue sky in primary schools, the pure and colorful flower season in middle schools, and the enthusiasm, beauty, youth and vitality in universities. ...

How unforgettable school life is. Can you forget? We can't forget it, so every step of education development reveals that school education is the cradle of cultivating a new generation. No matter how the society develops, how the process of civilization accelerates and how the world merges, the purpose of education is to cultivate students' good habits, interest in learning and healthy spirit. The core of quality education is: 1, to cultivate students' learning and self-care ability; 2. Cultivate students' language and thinking ability; 3. Cultivate students' practical ability and innovative ability; 4. Cultivate students' ability to cope with physical and mental health.

Our country has implemented nine-year compulsory education, built so many hope primary schools, expanded the enrollment of universities, and then expanded the enrollment of high schools, allowing private schools, continuing education and training centers and training courses to develop like mushrooms after rain. What are the reasons? It goes without saying that it is to constantly improve the quality of the vast number of young people, and then comprehensively improve the quality of the nation! After China's accession to the WTO, the international community has put forward more severe challenges to us. Faced with such a huge educational project of about 200 million students, family education like Songsha simply cannot undertake this solemn mission. Therefore, our view is that the improvement of teenagers' quality mainly depends on school education, and it must depend on school education. Because: 1, the teaching facilities, environment and system of the school are complete; 2. The school has professionally trained human soul engineers, that is, teachers; 3. The school has mature school rules and regulations and student codes; 4. The school has a rigorous, diligent and progressive style of study; There are many group activities and competitions in the school.

These are incomparable to family education. Ask another debater, which one of us didn't grow up in the sound of books on campus? Which one didn't grow up in the national anthem of raising the national flag on the playground? Which one didn't succeed under the teacher's inculcation? The campus is beautiful, just like that song, our campus is like a garden, and the beautiful flowers are really bright. La la la la la, we laughed like flowers. thank you

2 debate

I admit, the other debater spoke brilliantly, but I have a true story here, so you might as well listen to it. There is a primary school student, every time his mother peeled the eggs before taking them to school to eat, every day. It happened that one day mom forgot to peel the shell in a hurry and stuffed the egg into the child's schoolbag, which was in big trouble! At school, the child began to look around and couldn't help crying. The teacher rushed over and asked what was wrong. The child pinched his nose for a long time before answering: "How can I eat this egg without sewing!" "

This is a prominent example of the misunderstanding of family education. At present, there are many only children in our family, who are spoiled. Some children are simply little emperors and lawless. We can often see grandparents, parents bullied by the little emperor, helpless. This phenomenon is very common. Can such family education be realized?

Looking back at history, although there are many old sayings about Meng Mu's neighbor's choice, her mother-in-law's tattoo, Lu Fangweng's "Xiuzi" and so on, such as "lead by example", "fish begins to stink at the head" and "plant trees in ten years, educate people in a hundred years", the development of today's society is far from the same. With the high development of science and technology, the living standard has been greatly improved, and the social. Parents are helpless and powerless whether they are forced by life or pursuing their careers. They are either spoiled, violent, extreme, laissez-faire, or on a whim, or encourage them to pull out the seedlings, or the blind touch the elephant, or rush to see a doctor ... You didn't hear, three are short of one son, and mahjong sounds are endless; If you don't see me, just press it hard. You are eager for success.

"I woke up in this beautiful spring morning and heard Hu everywhere; Come and play mahjong at night, and you will know how much you win or lose. " This is an ancient poem revised by a primary school student in Guilin. A good ancient poem has been changed beyond recognition. What does this mean? Can the improvement of teenagers' quality depend on such family education?

I also have a little joke here. Once in class, the teacher had a labor problem and assigned tasks to A, B and C, while Ding was fine, so the teacher asked the students, "What tasks should Ding be assigned?" Just listen to the students' unanimous answer: "wake up!" " Angry and funny, the teacher is just dull.

Excuse me, another debater, what does "counting up" (the term used to play cards) mean? I won't explain it here, because everyone understands it.

All these explain the bad situation of our family education now. The society is complex, and the fragmented, obedient and misunderstood family education can't bear the responsibility of improving the quality of teenagers, which is related to the prosperity of the motherland and the rejuvenation of the nation. Although family education is also very important, school education will always be the undeniable mainstream. The improvement of teenagers' quality mainly depends on school education. thank you

3 debate

I want to ask another debater, can a paper pot boil water? It's hard to answer, so let Xiao Zhang tell you. In a fun activity, I saw Xiao Zhang showing off to his classmates with a thick piece of paper in his hand: "It's my turn to perform in today's fun class, and the paper pot boils water."

"Ah, brag!" The students were booed.

Zhang walked to the podium regardless of everything, made a paper pot in no hurry, filled it with water, and burned it on an alcohol lamp. While burning, Xiao Zhang suggested not to let the flames lick the paper above the water. Soon, the water was bubbling; After a while, the water boiled, and Xiao Zhang quickly put an egg in the paper pot, and the classroom suddenly became lively. So, Xiao Zhang took the opportunity to tell the students about the ignition point of the material, the conditions of burning, and the reasons why the paper pot could not burn. He also told a story about a ghost fire, which scared the students to laugh! At this time, the eggs are ripe, and the students are scrambling to taste the eggs cooked in paper pots. ...

The so-called ignition point is the temperature at which a substance spontaneously ignites without being close to a flame. The ignition point of paper is 183℃. The condition of material combustion is that the air (oxygen) reaches a sufficient temperature, that is, the ignition point, also known as the ignition point. Water can only burn to the boiling temperature of 100℃ in an open container, and the water with considerable heat capacity boiled in an open paper pot absorbs the excess heat of the paper, so that the burning point of the paper in the submerged part reaches 250℃. So, the water is boiled and the paper is safe.

Make teaching interesting, apply what you have learned and create infinity. This is the charm of interesting quality education hosted by students in turn in schools, which is only a part of colorful quality education in schools. Ask your opponent, does family education have such a wonderful atmosphere and effect?

Students in the campus, in the class collective, help each other, you chase after me, grow up happily, they have pure communication, naive call; They have deep friendship and beautiful yearning; They have a healthy pursuit and lofty ideals. ...

Therefore, we believe that family education is like a frog in a well, with too many limitations, while school education is a vast world in which you can roam freely.

As we all know, quality is a broad concept, involving all aspects, but one thing is clear: the essence of any quality is knowledge. The growth of teenagers is first and foremost a process of acquiring knowledge. People say that wisdom creates wealth, and where wisdom comes from is only rich knowledge. Knowledge is not acquired overnight, but by diligent accumulation bit by bit. "Ten years of cold window" is the truth. Therefore, school education is the main way for teenagers to acquire knowledge and improve their quality. Think about it, can children do without reading now? No, and parents are eager to study hard and go to a famous school, even if the tuition is high. What does this mean? Debate members are still studying at school. Why? School is a good place to study, and school is the cradle of teenagers' growth. thank you

4 Debate (concluding remarks)

Quality education in China was put forward in 1980s. The so-called quality is not simple knowledge, but that part of knowledge that can stay in people and be transformed into their own abilities. We admit that family education has its important historical position, and there are many well-known stories. Parents play an irreplaceable role in children's enlightenment education. If you live with the lame, you will learn to limp. Like father, like son, knowing a son is like a father. We also know that in the early days of reform and opening up, due to the coexistence of planned economy and market economy, a group of nouveau riche who have never read a book and can only make a living, and so on. However, with the gradual improvement of the socialist market economy, especially after joining the WTO, those nouveau riche have been almost ruthlessly eliminated, leaving only a small number who know how to go to school for further study. Exam-oriented education with many disadvantages is out of date, but quality education must not give up exams. Examination is not an end, but a standard to measure talents. Society is a big family and society is a big school. In fact, school education is everywhere. All kinds of education and training and self-study by one's own ability are extensions of school education, because self-study ability is also learned from school. Quality education in 2 1 century should cultivate students' new horizons, new concepts, new knowledge structure, new ability (comprehensive ability) and new thinking. This is beyond the scope of family education. With the vigorous development of online education, tutoring and learning and teaching are integrated, but teenagers have poor self-control and are easy to indulge in online games, which is a difficult problem for learning and teaching. But there is no doubt that the main body of online education is still school education.

We appreciate the wonderful performance of the opposing debater today and believe that the opposing debater will be a good parent in the future. But at the same time, remind each other not to let their children drop out of school in the future. No matter how good a tutor is, it can't replace school education. It doesn't matter whether we win or lose today's debate. What is important is how do we combine counseling with learning and teaching? How to complement each other? How to unite and prosper? This is our real purpose. The reason why we think that the improvement of teenagers' quality mainly depends on school education is based on the following strong arguments:

First, judging from the birth of education, human beings lived in groups in primitive society. The children don't know who their father is and have no family at all. Only the elders teach the younger generation some survival skills. Education appears in the form of groups. So education belongs to public education as soon as it comes into being, not family education.

Secondly, from the perspective of the development of education, family education was once in an important position because of the deep-rooted concepts of "being an official by studying", "being an official by studying well", "glorifying one's ancestors and glorifying one's ancestors". However, with the development of education today, the modernization of education has made school education the main body, which is obvious to all.

Third, judging from the conversation of national leaders, Vice Premier Li Lanqing said at the national exchange meeting on quality education experience: "The implementation of quality education in schools is to cultivate students' noble moral character, physical and mental health, rich knowledge, expertise, open mind and strong practical ability, and learn to be a man, learn to seek knowledge, learn to work, learn to create, learn to live, learn to keep fit and learn to appreciate beauty ... The instructions of national leaders fundamentally define quality education as school education.

Fourth, from the perspective of laws and regulations, Article 3 of the Compulsory Education Law 1986 promulgated by the state stipulates that compulsory education must implement the national education policy and strive to improve the quality, so that children and adolescents can develop in an all-round way in terms of morality, intelligence and physique, and lay the foundation for improving the quality of the whole nation and cultivating ideal, moral, educated and disciplined talents for socialist construction. 65438-0993 "The Outline of Education Reform and Development in China" points out in Article 7 that basic education is the basic project to improve the quality of the people. This fully shows that national laws clearly stipulate that quality education is the fundamental task of school education.

Fifthly, judging from the current situation of folk cognition and education, the concepts of "teachers make excellent students", "famous teachers make excellent students", "the three must learn from each other's strengths", good schools, good tutors and first-class universities have been deeply rooted in parents' minds, and quality education has become the top priority of school education. It can be said that today's school education is in the ascendant and full of charm, which provides the most complete for the vigorous growth of teenagers.

All these strongly prove that school education is the key to improve the quality of young people. We also admit that the quality of family education affects children's life, but this does not mean that family education can override school education. On the contrary, family education can only achieve the expected goal if it is supplemented by school education. If family is the cell of education, then school is the blood of education; If tutoring is moonlight, then learning to teach is the eternal dawn; If family education is a warm harbor, then learning and teaching is a battlefield of hope; If tutoring is running shoes, then learning to teach is the wings of flying. ...

With the intensification of international competition after China's entry into WTO, and the arrival of knowledge economy and information age, how to cultivate compound talents with international competitiveness and how to cultivate people who can succeed in all walks of life in China has posed a more severe challenge to us. Comrade Deng Xiaoping, the mentor of the reform, pointed out the direction for us: education should start with dolls; Education should face science, the world and the future.

In 2008, the Beijing Olympic Games, the Shanghai World Trade Expo in 20/KOOC-0/0, the Nanning ASEAN Trade Expo (held every year/KOOC-0/65438+/KOOC-0/0), and the success of shenzhou spaceship V manned space flight made us happy. We have reason to believe that our school education will be able to shoulder the solemn mission entrusted by the times and write a more brilliant new chapter.