Fu Xinian and Fu Yannian, two-bedroom grandchildren of Fu Zengxiang, the chief education officer of the Republic of China, fought for a huge inheritance, and Fu Yannian lost the case. Fu Yannian and other four people only got notes, classics and other cultural relics 10. After sentencing, the judge analyzed the reasons for sentencing. However, the word "difficult" is the first word throughout, and Fu Yannian said that he would appeal.
Fu Zengxiang had three sons and two daughters when he was born, but only two sons remained in his later years, the eldest son Fu Zhongmo and the third son Fu. Fu died before Fu Zengxiang, leaving four men and two women, namely Fu Songnian, Fu Haonian and Fu Yannian. After Fu Zengxiang's death, Fu Zhongmo, Fu's eldest son, took charge of the property and remained a big family. 1966 during the cultural revolution, tens of thousands of cultural relics were stolen. 197 1 year, the state began to gradually return the Fu family's property. 1974, Fu Zhongmo died, and Fu's property was in the charge of Fu Zhongmo's eldest son Fu Xinian. 1March 22, 985, Fu Xinian presided over the division of property. Seven people from two rooms attended and signed an agreement, but Fu Yannian did not attend all the rooms. In this regard, Fu Yannian proposed that the agreement was invalid. Since then, the children of the eldest son and the third son have been arguing about how to divide cultural relics for nearly ten years.
After the court of first instance ruled that Fu Yannian and other four people obtained cultural relics such as notes and classics 10, Fu Yannian and others appealed.
During the trial, the two sides disputed over 900 pieces of ancient jade: Fu Yannian thought these jade belonged to grandpa Fu Zengxiang's collection, while Fu Xinian claimed it was his father's private collection. In either case, the court thinks that there is no direct evidence to prove that both parties can only be more effective than whose evidence. Fu Yannian used Fu Zengxiang Diary and other works to prove that jade was collected by grandpa, and speculated that Fu Xinian's father had no ability and behavior to collect ancient jade. Fu Xinian suggested that the ancient jade before the 1985 agreement had been returned by the court, but Fu Yannian never raised any objection, proving that the ancient jade was his father's personal collection. In contrast, the court held that Fu Xinian's evidence was superior.
Therefore, the court ruled that only the Buddha statue 1 statue, Chongzhen suicide note 1 Zhang, Lotus Sutra 7, continuing education mirror 1 face, etc. 10, which can be identified as Fu Zengxiang's collection, were distributed to Fu Yannian and other four people.
After the verdict in this case, the judge said that Fu Zengxiang had been dead for half a century. During this period, the two sides divided, donated and sold the property many times. "The court has done a lot of necessary investigation and verification work, but it still cannot completely restore the original appearance of history." The judge also held that the litigation time had exceeded the maximum limitation of 20 years, so the appellant Fu Yannian and others could not get legal support.