Recently, a large number of "real estate brokerage companies" are extremely active in the talent market. They attract many applicants with ultra-low recruitment conditions and relatively generous salary. Candidates all have the same experience: the interview is easy to pass; If you pass the interview, you must pay the training fee; After the training, either the contracted company suddenly disappeared, or they were assigned to other companies for trial work, and finally they could not get a formal job.

Since mid-February, our reporter "applied" for "Beijing ATV Huatian Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd." (hereinafter referred to as ATV Huatian) and investigated the inside story of this company's recruitment.

Pass three interviews in an hour.

Every interview, the "examiner" will repeatedly emphasize the importance of participating in the training.

65438+February 16 pm 1 30, the reporter participated in the recruitment of ATV Huatian under a pseudonym. The interview place is Room 408, Jin Woo Furniture City, northeast corner of Anzhen Bridge. The staff said that this is the personnel department of ATV Huatianer Branch.

Room 408 is less than 100 square meter, with only three rooms, one living room, one administrative office and one human resources office. There are two tables and three sofas in the hall. There are several large file boxes on the desk, which are covered with dust. There is only one desk, two chairs and no computer in both offices.

The reporter filled out a rough resume and answered a simple question before he was able to start the interview.

It was a female staff member who tried the reporter for the first time. The reporter said that she didn't bring a copy of her ID card and proof of education. She didn't say anything.

Then she began to quickly introduce the basic situation of ATV Huatian to reporters by endorsement-ATV Huatian was formerly known as Zhongtian Henderson Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd. and was later acquired by Shandong ATV Group. It has 23 branches in Beijing, headquartered in the ATV Building in Liuliqiao, mainly engaged in real estate brokerage activities. She asked reporters to receive training in real estate brokerage after passing the interview. The training period is 3 days, and the tuition fee is 300 yuan. She said that after passing the exam, she can try it out in different departments of the company, and the company will refund the training fee in full when she is paid after a one-month trial period.

The reporter said that she only wanted to apply for the position of administrative assistant, but she said that even administrative personnel need to know something about real estate agents and need training.

The reporter said that he wanted to attend the training as soon as possible. Five minutes later, Miss Liu from the Human Resources Office interviewed the reporter directly. The content of the second interview is similar to that of the first one. After introducing the basic situation of the company again, Miss Liu also emphasized the importance of training to reporters. The reporter quickly passed the second interview.

Finally, an interview with Shi Lei, the manager. Shi Lei's entire interview process lasted less than 65,438+00 minutes. He hardly asked reporters about his personal situation from beginning to end, and still stressed that new employees need to attend training first. Later, he told reporters that he could find Miss Liu to sign an employment agreement.

The total time of the three interviews is about one hour.

After signing the agreement, Miss Liu gave the reporter a letter of introduction, asking the reporter to attend a three-day real estate knowledge training in a training school called Golden Chaoyang.

Read for half an hour and pass the exam.

The content of the exam is very simple, and it is all in the focus of the exam. The reporter only listened to the class for one day, and passed the exam after reading the key points half an hour before the exam.

12 16 in the afternoon, the reporter came to Golden Chaoyang Training School, which is located about 200 meters east of Jintai Road, Chaoyang North Road. After paying the training fee in 360 yuan and the information fee in 48 yuan, a middle-aged lady told the reporter that the training was shortened to two days, 17 and 19, about five hours a day, and the exam was on the 20th.

The training textbook is a set of "Real Estate Brokerage Related Business Knowledge", 200 pages, taught by Teacher Ma; Another 74-page Practical Handbook for Real Estate Marketing Representatives is taught by Mr. Wei. These two teachers are about thirty or forty years old, and both claim to have long-term experience in real estate companies.

There are 25 students in this training class. Two of them are from ATV Huatian, and the others are new employees from real estate agencies such as Wancheng Jiahua, Universal ATV, Rong Tai Hengxin and Tian Hong Brokerage. Teacher Ma said that the training school signed agreements with more than 40 real estate companies to train new employees.

The reporter asked other students to know that everyone's interview process is similar. No matter what background or position you apply for, you will easily pass the interview and be asked to participate in the training.

During the two-day training, the two teachers mainly taught the content of the textbook and drew test sites on the textbook before the exam. The reporter successfully passed the exam.

After paying the 20 yuan fee, Golden Chaoyang Training School issued a certificate of completion to the reporter. The training school said that the state does not recognize this certificate, the main purpose is to prove to the company that employees have received training in the basic knowledge of real estate.

Be transferred to another company for no reason

According to the business manager, Metropolitan Land and ATV Huatian are two different companies, but many similar companies including these two companies have cooperative relations.

On the afternoon of February 27th, 65438, when the reporter returned to ATV Huatian with the certificate of completion, the staff here were still calling the candidates to come here for an interview.

At the first time, the female staff of the reporter asked the reporter to take the agreement and proof to the "Manager Li" in Room 2304, Baihuan Jiayuan 18 Building, and said that it was a branch of ATV Huatian.

In the afternoon, the reporter found Room 2304, Building No.8, Baihuan Jiayuan/KLOC-0 in Shuangjing, but the sign of "Urban Land Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd." (hereinafter referred to as Urban Land) was hung outside the door of this room. The company covers an area of about 100 square meter, including a general manager office and a personnel office. There are five or six tables in the living room, and there are no computers on them.

A personnel manager who claimed to be Shang received the reporter. He didn't even read the reporter's training certificate. After taking away the employment agreement signed by the reporter and ATV Huatian, the reporter is required to pay the training fee 1 10 yuan (including the work license fee 10 yuan). He promised that 1 10 yuan's training fee would be fully refunded when he was paid after one month's probation. The so-called probation period, first of all, is a week of market research, then a week of telephone communication with customers, and then give reporters a batch of housing, and start the actual operation of housing leasing.

The business manager said that the reporter was arranged by ATV Huatian to conduct practical business training in urban real estate. After the one-month probation period expires, he will make an assessment report according to the performance of the whistleblower, and he can become a full member after passing the assessment. After becoming a full member, you can freely choose to go back to ATV Huatian to work or stay in urban real estate.

The company refused to refund the training fee.

Regarding the failure to return to ATV Huatian for trial training as agreed, Shi Lei explained that he was also temporarily arranged by the head office, but if the applicant didn't want to go, it would be a unilateral breach of contract and he would have to pay liquidated damages to 300 yuan.

On the morning of February 28th, 65438, the reporter asked to see a copy of the business license of urban land, but the business manager said no. The reporter suggested that he could go to the head office. He only told the reporter that Chengdi Head Office was in Pengrun Home in Caihuying, and did not tell the reporter the specific house number.

The reporter asked the business manager to quit the training and demanded a refund of the training fee 1 10 yuan. The reason is that ATV Huatian violated the employment agreement and assigned the reporter to another company, and Metropolitan Land could not even issue the most basic legal certificate.

However, the business manager said that the reporter signed an employment agreement with ATV Huatian and had to negotiate with ATV Huatian first. 1 10 yuan paid by the reporter is the internal training fee of urban land, and no receipt will be issued according to the internal regulations of the company. The reporter asked which rule was specific, and he also said that he could not tell the reporter. Subsequently, the reporter returned to ATV Huatianer Branch and asked ATV Huatian why he assigned employees to other companies for trial, because he claimed to have 23 branches. In this regard, its manager Shi Lei said that 23 branches are still under construction.

Many classmates were cheated, too.

The students who participated in the training with reporters had different experiences, but the results were the same. None of them found a job.

A trainee who signed a contract with Tian Hong's agent resigned after being assigned by the company to try out in other companies, and failed to get back the training fee. The company divided her into two companies, one in Caihuying Pengrun Home and the other near Shuangjing.

A student who signed a contract with Wancheng Jiahua said that after he passed the exam, he heard that Wancheng Jiahua Company had disappeared before he got the certificate. After investigation, the reporter found that the place where the student went to Wancheng Jiahua for an interview was the place where Wancheng Jiahua was registered in the industrial and commercial department, and now there is no one there.

The experience of other contracted students is also the same. Either the contracted company disappeared, or it was assigned by the company to other companies for trial, and finally it didn't get a formal job.

On the afternoon of February 28th, 65438, another reporter of this newspaper formally interviewed Shi Lei, HR manager of ATV Huatianer Branch. Shi Lei immediately offered to refund part of the training fee.

ATV Huatian's predecessor was suspected of fraud, so far he has not obtained brokerage qualification.

What kind of company is ATV Huatian? What kind of company was his predecessor, Zhongtian Henderson Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd.? Can this kind of qualification training organized by the company be recognized by the state? Can the company charge training fees? While the reporter made an unannounced visit to the inside story of ATV Huatian's recruitment, he also launched an investigation on the above issues.

The chaotic and changeable recruitment history

Since May this year, the recruitment information of Zhongtian Henderson and ATV Huatian has frequently appeared on websites and newspapers, and their office locations are constantly changing.

According to the staff of ATV Huatian No.2 Branch, the predecessor of ATV Huatian was Beijing Zhongtian Henderson Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd. But since May this year, the recruitment information of Zhongtian Henderson and ATV Huatian has frequently appeared on websites and newspapers, and the office locations are constantly changing.

In May this year 10, the recruitment information of Zhongtian Henderson appeared in Beijing Talent Market News. The interview place is Room 2 109, ATV Building, South Square, West Railway Station.

On June 7th, the recruitment information of Zhongtian Henderson published in Beijing Talent Market News showed that the interview place of the company had been changed to Room 4 16 of Jin Woo Furniture City. On July 29th, the recruitment information of Zhongtian Henderson appeared in Beijing Talent Market. The interview took place in Room 4 16 of Jin Woo Furniture City, and I haven't seen the recruitment information of Zhongtian Henderson since.

The name of ATV Huatian began to appear in June. On June 20th, the recruitment information of ATV Huatian appeared in the media such as boutique shopping guide. The interviews were conducted in Room 2 109 of ATV Building, Room 4 16 of Jin Woo Furniture City and Room 622 of apartment building of Chongwenmen New World Shopping Mall.

In the news of Beijing talent market on July 1, the recruitment information of ATV Huatian and Zhongtian Henderson appeared at the same time. Among them, ATV Huatian interviewed in Room 2 109 of ATV Building and Room 1 of Century Home Building located at the east gate of the Olympic Sports Center.

On July 14, the recruitment information of ATV Huatian appeared on the website (www.naalee.com) there. The interview places are in Room 2 109 of ATV Building and Building 9 19C of Century Home.

On June 5438+ 10 this year, the recruitment information of ATV Huatian appeared on websites such as pigeon classification information network (www.dovelist.com). The recruitment deadline is 65438+1 October 24th, and the interview place is Building1,East Gate Century Home, Olympic Sports Center, Asian Games Village.

Since August 23rd, ATV Huatian's interview location is mostly in Room 408, Jin Woo Furniture City. So far, the company's recruitment information still appears on many recruitment websites.

Regarding the frequent change of recruitment location, Zhang, the legal representative of Beijing Zhongtian Henderson Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd. and the renamed boss of ATV Huatian, explained that he had never organized any recruitment and had never seen the recruitment information, whether it was Zhongtian Henderson or ATV Huatian.

False recruitment information

In 2004, Zhongtian Henderson received many complaints about alleged fraud, and its brokerage qualification is currently being filed by the Construction Committee. After Zhongtian Henderson changed its name to ATV Huatian in May this year, it applied to transfer the qualification of Zhongtian Henderson to ATV Huatian, but the Construction Committee did not approve it.

The reporter inquired from the industrial and commercial department that Zhongtian Henderson was registered in June 2004 1. The legal representative is Zhang, with a registered capital of 500,000 yuan. The registered address of the company is Room 2 109, ATV Building, South Square, Fengtai District. Zhongtianheng changed its name to ATV Huatian Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd. after going through relevant formalities this year, and its legal representative is still Zhang.

However, since June this year, ATV Huatian introduced herself in the recruitment information released by many media such as Zhaopin.com(www.zhaopin.com): ATV Huatian Company was established on April 8, 1995 with a registered capital of "1000000 RMB". ATV Huatian Real Estate is a subsidiary of ATV Group, with real estate brokerage as the leading industry ... and has become one of the most powerful real estate brokerage companies in China. ATV Huatian has more than 20 branches and a number of on-site sales offices in major cities in this city. At present, the company has nearly 1,000 employees, including 30 registered real estate agents, over 0/00 real estate agents, 55 real estate planners, 38 market evaluators and researchers, and 83 professional brokers 183, with a bachelor's degree accounting for 50%.

When the reporter participated in the interview as a candidate, the staff of ATV Huatianer Branch also told the reporter that ATV Huatian was formerly known as Zhongtian Henderson Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd. and was later acquired by Shandong ATV Group, with 23 branches in Beijing.

Mr. Han, head of the office of Shandong ATV Group, clearly told reporters that Shandong ATV Group has nothing to do with Beijing ATV Huatian. "At the end of 2003, our group was renamed" Hongcheng "Group. The group has no branch in Beijing, and there is no branch engaged in real estate. "

When the reporter inquired about the qualification of Beijing real estate agency on Beijing real estate transaction management online, he found that there was only the qualification record of Zhongtian Henderson in the system, but no information of ATV Huatian. ATV Huatian's predecessor, Zhongtian Henderson, has only five registered real estate agents.

At the same time, Mr. Zhou, a staff member of the Marketing Department of Fengtai District Construction Committee, told the reporter that due to many complaints about fraud in 2004, Zhongtian Henderson's brokerage qualification is currently being handled by the Construction Committee. After Zhongtian Henderson changed its name to ATV Huatian in May this year, it applied to transfer its qualification to ATV Huatian, but the Construction Committee did not approve it.

It can be seen that the recruitment information released by ATV Huatian in Zhaopin.com, such as "ATV Huatian Real Estate belongs to ATV Group" and "There are more than 20 branches and many on-site sales departments", is completely false.

The general branch does not recognize each other.

Zhang, the boss of ATV Huatian, said that he knew there was a branch, but it was no longer under his control. He doesn't know the person in charge of the branch, and he doesn't know what business the branch is engaged in at present.

On the afternoon of 28th, when the reporter asked Shi Lei, the HR manager of ATV Huatianer Branch, about the above recruitment doubts, Shi Lei changed his mind and said, "Our head office is ATV Huatian, and we just moved to Daxing a month ago." Shi Lei said that the recruitment of the second branch has only been going on for a week, and more than 50 people have been recruited so far, and the recruitment work is about to end. Our company is definitely a legally qualified real estate agency. Our registration number in the Construction Committee is 258 1. This number is the record number of Zhongtian Henderson in the Construction Committee.

After inquiring about Beijing Real Estate Transaction Management Network, the reporter found that the real estate brokerage companies such as Wancheng Jiahua, Universal ATV, Rong Tai Hengxin and Tian Hong, which were recruited together with ATV Huatian and trained in Golden Chaoyang, were not qualified as real estate brokers.

The reporter asked Shi Lei to provide the address of the head office and the contact information of the person in charge, but Shi Lei said he didn't have the phone number of the person in charge. He said that the address of the head office is not the ATV building registered by industry and commerce, but moved to the east of Hongxing District1500m in Daxing Yizhuang Development Zone more than a month ago, and he himself has never been there.

According to the filing data of the industrial and commercial department, ATV Huatian Real Estate Agency Co., Ltd. registered a branch office on April 2, 2008, with the address of "Room 408, opposite to No.7, North Third Ring Road, Dongcheng District", that is, Room 408, Jin Woo Furniture City. The head of this branch is Wu Hongsheng.

Zhang said that he knew that ATV Huatian had a branch, but that branch was not under his control. He doesn't know the person in charge of the branch, and he doesn't know what business the branch is engaged in at present.

The authoritative organization answers questions.

Beijing Municipal Construction Committee: Relevant training organized by real estate companies or other training institutions will not be recognized by the industry.

Beijing Labor and Social Security Bureau: The unit can't charge any fees to the candidates when recruiting employees.

Luo Hongjing, director of the Housing Leasing Division of Beijing Construction Committee, said that the qualification examination for real estate appraisers and real estate brokers in China is organized by the Ministry of Personnel and held once a year. Those who pass can obtain the qualification certificate issued by the institute.

In addition, the Beijing Municipal Construction Committee also entrusts the Association of Real Estate Agents to organize such examinations every year, which is slightly less difficult than the national examination. Those who pass the examination can also receive the qualification certificate approved by Beijing Industrial and Commercial Department and Construction Committee. "The relevant training organized by real estate companies or other training institutions will not be recognized by the industry. Applicants should improve their ability to distinguish. " Luo Hongjing said.

The staff of the telephone consultation center of Beijing Labor and Social Security Bureau said that when recruiting employees, the unit can't charge any fees to the candidates. "Training, registration, physical examination, mortgage, deposit, deposit, clothing and other items can not be used as a reason to charge candidates, even if it means reimbursement in the future. In short, the recruiter cannot charge a penny to the applicant during the recruitment period. " The staff member said that the regulations in this respect can be found in the Notice of Beijing Municipal Labor Bureau on Forwarding the Ministry of Labor on Prohibiting Employers from Charging Employees in Violation of Regulations (Document No.442 [1995]). The staff member said that if the applicant finds that the recruiting unit has the above behavior, he should complain to the labor inspection brigade in his district.