Song Wu's positive characters are mainly Jingyang Gangda, helping the poor, refusing the temptation of his sister-in-law and killing his brother. But if we put this matter in the background of his words and deeds and personality, the image of the protagonist will be greatly reduced. Based on the analysis of Song Wu's deeds and related evaluations in Song Jiang's "Praise of Thirty-six People", "Water Margin" and "Jin Ping Mei", can the positive character design still hold water?
The evaluation of Song Wu in Song Jiang Thirty-six Zans in the Southern Song Dynasty is that "debauchery is more important than murder". From the clues of the positive description of Song Wu in Water Margin and Jin Ping Mei, we can also see that Song Wu is a bully and ruthless villain. The evaluation of "More Killing" is that Song Wu often hurts people's lives. When he appears, he fights with people and goes to Chai Jin's house to hide things. The book does not explain the cause of the injury, which can be regarded as his daily life. Once you hurt someone, you run for your life without saying anything, which means that it is not self-defense, and it is hard enough to start, and you have no consideration for your situation. Whether he wanted to pay for his life or lose money, Song Wu got into trouble and let his only brother take the blame.
There are many descriptions of "debauchery and wealth" in Song Wu's "Drunkenness is not about wine, drunkenness is not about wine, and drunkenness is on the side of the road". In Shi Naian's works, eating large pieces of meat and drinking in a big bowl is a Jianghu spirit, but in the eyes of normal people, he is just an alcoholic and has nothing to do with heroes. Song Wu has a bad temper, and the store kindly advised him not to drink too much, but he almost bumped into someone, which shows that his style is overbearing.
Some people will say that Song Wu is not greedy for money, and the bounty after killing the tiger is not given to the Orion, leaving nothing behind. Don't you know that the means of sparing money and lavishing gold and silver are Jianghu means to buy people's hearts and try to save face? People in rivers and lakes, don't treat their own industries well, don't love money, and drink the northwest wind? Large-scale distribution of gold, unexpectedly, is the so-called heroic behavior. Song Wu doesn't want to be paid, but he is greedy for fame and fortune. Mafia eldest brother which one is not arrogant, righteousness first, but privately arrogant, don't rob money. Therefore, Song Wu is greedy for money.
Alcohol, money, gas, murder. Do you have any colors? Of course there is! Heroes in the Water Margin are all heroes who have been castrated artificially. They can't have a daughter-in-law and love beauty. The short-legged tiger robbed Gao Liu's wife, and was satirized by Song Jiang and others as "lewd, non-heroic behavior", which shows its hypocrisy. Big brother is a wife like clothes, and brothers like brothers. Even if a woman is worthless, she can't live without clothes. Therefore, Song Wu had many bad habits when he was young, and lewdness was one of them.
In Water Margin, Song Wu's famous appearance twice showed his heroism, but he accidentally missed the clue of flirting with women. First of all, on the way from Song Wu to Mengzhou, Sun Erniang opened a pork steamed stuffed bun joint in the Cross Slope Hotel. Theoretically, it is ok for Song Wu to break the trick and remind everyone to pay attention, but Song Wu won't say anything when he sees Sun Erniang. He will pretend to be knocked down after everyone is turned over by drugs.
Sun Erniang came to mention him, so he took the opportunity to hijack him. At this time, Sun Erniang only wore thin clothes, and her coat was just a tube top. According to Song Wu's power of fighting tigers, he can knock the parties down with one punch, but Song Wu has many small moves. First, hold Sun Erniang with both hands, and ErNian's nakedness is caught in her leg. The language is obscene and obscene. If Zhang Qing hadn't appeared in the vegetable garden in time, the consequences would have been unimaginable.
Second, after he was sent to Mengzhou, he beat Jiang Menshen as drunk as a fiddler in order to help people get the hotel back. The cause of this incident is a bit like a gang fight for territory. Song Wu, who was stabbed with Mengzhou, never repented, and made friends with people who were "re-educated through labor" everywhere, forming gangs to help people look after the venue. When Song Wu arrived at Happy Forest Hotel, he found that Jiang Menshen was not at home and his wife was the only one who looked after the hotel, so he became obscene and frivolous.
Regardless of whether Song Wu's behavior is pornographic or not, it is obviously not a heroic act. Jianghu children are worse than wives and children. There's nothing wrong with coming and hitting a son. Why are you flirting with somebody else's daughter-in-law? As you can see, Song Wu is a recidivist, and he is worthless under the banner of hero.
It was an accident that Song Wu Jingyanggang killed the tiger. Half of them woke up after drinking, just to save face. If they really let him fight tigers for the people, Song Wu may not have the courage. Even the local ruffians will feel good about themselves if they suddenly bully others and do earth-shattering things. The imperial court did not want to give it to Orion in public, but said that he would be promoted to the head of the infantry and kneel down to thank him.
A famous and favorable "official position" is far more attractive than a brave and good fighter. Originally, I didn't mention going back to yanggu county to find my brother. I didn't ask the consequences of Wu Da's involvement in Song Wu's wounding case. It's hard to wander around the streets of Qinghe County all day and drink with people regularly. I met Wu Dacai in the street and went home to live, which led to the seduction of Pan Jinlian.
Song Wu, as a gangster, and Song Wu, as a hero, are faced with different choices according to the character of "it is more important to kill people with wine, money and wealth". After being a sister-in-law, being a hero for just a few days will arouse people's criticism; It's a pity to refuse to be a sister-in-law, but I'm afraid such a beautiful woman will have something to do with others. Song Wu, who was in the rivers and lakes, had an idea at that time-temporarily refused and slowly pondered.
Pack your bags and move (I had to help the county magistrate run a long distance, so I have to pack my bags), and let my elder brother Wu Da go home early every day and close the door to prevent others from entering the house. At this time, Song Wu was already a man in the city, and no one dared to provoke Wu Da. Close the door to see my sister-in-law for fear of retaliation? Obviously not, I'm afraid someone will cut me off!
Ximen Qing beheaded Hu, killed Wu Da, married Pan Jinlian, took revenge for killing the wrong person and sent him to Mengzhou. After Ximen Qing's death, Song Wu easily took revenge, but he insisted on marrying Pan Jinlian. The wedding night is called "bloody wedding". Let's not mention the killing process. Is Song Wu really avenging his brother? Revenge should be comforted in the spirit of heaven, and so should the surviving orphans. Song Wuming killed Pan Jinlian, but abandoned his niece Yinger whose parents died. He also scraped all the gold, silver, jewelry and clothes at home, and only said to the young children, "My child, I can't take care of you." What kind of revenge is this?
With Song Wu's ability, he can flirt with Sun Erniang, get drunk and beat Jiang Menshen, and drink in a big bowl to mix rivers and lakes. Why can't he come back and kill Ximen Qing? Maybe after the last meeting, I knew I couldn't mess with it. Song Wu bullied the weak and feared the hard, and only when people died did he dare to retaliate. The so-called killing sister-in-law and offering sacrifices to her brother is just poor Pan Jinlian's ulterior motives. The real purpose of Song Wu is to marry Pan Jinlian's wedding. What happened before the wedding night, it is estimated that only Pan Jinlian, who was beheaded naked, knows!
From this analysis, Song Wuren set up a collapsed and real hammer! !