1, the first review link after the article is submitted is the first review, which is almost completed by magazine editors, who will browse the article roughly. At this time, the comments are just a simple browsing, so the article will not be read carefully. Editors mainly look at whether there are any problems in the basic writing of articles.
For example, whether the structure, logic and main research direction of the article are consistent with the journal, and whether it involves sensitive topics or words, as long as they pass the preliminary examination, there is no problem.
2. Review, also known as external review, is completed by external reviewers. External comments mainly look at the research content of the article. Because it involves something in the professional field, it must be done by experts in this specialty. It should be noted that some publications need the authors to recommend their own reviewers, and generally there will be 3-4 reviewers. If all experts agree to the review, they can pass the external review.
3. Final review. Final review is the final review of articles by the editor-in-chief of the magazine. This link is much more likely to pass the external audit. The editor-in-chief will conduct a comprehensive review of the article. This link is not to say that there is no chance of rejection, but it is lower than the external review.
The above three review links are the three reviews and three schools after the article is submitted. The process is not complicated, but it will take some time to pass. Therefore, we must make preparations for the publication of the paper as soon as possible. For more questions about the paper review, please consult the online editing of the topic station.
Review method
In reading methods, we should do some preparatory work according to the specific situation (such as consulting necessary reference books and checking whether there are similar books or translations, etc.). ), but also check the writing outline agreed by the publishing house and the translator, focusing on the materials and arguments cited by the author.
In addition, we should also pay attention to the preface and postscript of the manuscript. To prevent being bound by the manuscript when reading, so as to pay too much attention to some minor problems of the manuscript.
If there are different opinions on the evaluation of a draft, the final opinion and decision shall prevail in principle. For some complicated manuscripts, decisions can be made through collective discussion in a certain form of meeting.
Some manuscripts with special or special contents can also invite experts or relevant units outside the society to review the manuscript. External audit opinions, especially the handling methods of manuscripts, generally still need to be put forward by the responsible editor, and the editor-in-chief will make the final decision.
All aspects of peer review, including processes and methods, are thorough and rigorous, thus ensuring the quality of articles and guiding the correct direction of China's cultural knowledge.
The above content source: Baidu Encyclopedia-Summary