First, academic misconduct is not washed, and practical achievements are not black.
No one has only one side, although as a research dog in the direction of immunity, 53 fake articles have made his scientific research texture no longer pure. Needless to say, he is inevitably negligent in managing several laboratories. This is illogical. Since he can't manage his own laboratory, don't open so many. If he does, he will say that he can't do it. You can't let one person take all the good things. Academically, I really didn't wash it. I don't know if the person who said this has done scientific research, but I refuse to accept your call to repeat your representative works. See if you can repeat it.
However, his contribution to Nankai, his practical work for students and the outstanding development of an industry are all obvious to all. Since the country attaches great importance to promoting him, either his comprehensive ability is far better than the stain, or his background is unimaginable, I prefer to believe that the former accounts for a larger proportion. A brave general will not be allowed to lead troops to fight just because his published poems have been plagiarized. Therefore, the world is not black and white. Once there is a mistake, it will be useful for life. Therefore, people who think this way either watch too many silly and sweet TV dramas or students will not graduate.
President Cao has done a very good job in Nankai, and everyone has a reputation. All the alumni in my circle of friends are talking about it, but unfortunately he didn't do it again in Nankai. Why? Because Cao Pai has ideas, plans and execution, he has done a lot of things in Nankai in recent five years. In addition to solving the urgent needs of students, his main achievements are discipline construction and talent introduction. It's really good.
Xiaocao's personal laboratory was concluded by the state, but it was not considered as academic misconduct and plagiarism. His papers have been distributed so much that no one has heard that their conclusions have been questioned. Unlike Han Chunyu, it cannot be repeated. Of course, there are also some misuse of pictures. This is also because his laboratory management is not strict enough. Of course, he is also responsible. But he's really strong enough. I see that he and his team are still publishing papers, and they are top international magazines. This shows that he is really good, really good in his field.
Someone pointed out that about qigong. I think this is the limitation of the times. In the 1990s, I watched a TV series "Zhang Shiyu Baosheng" on Hebei Satellite TV, which was about his special functions. Think about what it was like in those days. It is said that Qian Xuesen has also studied psychic powers, but no one thinks there is something wrong with him. People still have to look at the mainstream. Cao school has these experiences, and he has also reflected. Didn't we believe in the grain yield of 10 thousand Jin per mu in the early 1960 s? In short, as an alumnus of Nankai University, I must admit that Cao School has done a good job as a principal in recent years. He has a new job now. Although they are peers, they should be reused. I hope he will make new achievements in his new post.
Second, I have lived in Nankai under Xiaocao for four years. Here are some personal experiences:
1. The hardware of the school has been greatly improved. The year I took office, all the dormitories in the school were equipped with air conditioning. In the year when I left office, the whole school dormitory was replaced with a four-person bed and a table. Centennial celebration, school renovation, wasteland changing into a park, upgrading of Haibing Building and Boling Building in Yifu Building, construction of Jinnan Centennial Lecture Hall in No.4 canteen of Balitai, road renovation and renovation of southwest village (Balitai has been greatly improved since I 18).
2. Medicine has developed rapidly. Professor Cao, as an academician with many resources, is committed to the development of Nankai medicine (the Institute of Physical Education is jealous). Tianjin No.1 Middle School was registered as an affiliated hospital, and cooperated with Tianjin Medical University and Tianjin People's Hospital to set up a national first-class clinical medical undergraduate specialty construction point ophthalmology and transplantation medicine Institute (not double-class, according to opinions). Nankai medicine has been poor and weak for a long time, which is very unfavorable for undergraduate enrollment. Cao School has vigorously developed medicine and effectively alleviated this problem.
3. The influence of basic disciplines has been further enhanced. Chemistry won the first prize in natural science, and the Institute of Mathematics has dug up many outstanding talents in recent years. It's really rare for basic subjects to have such achievements under the background of small poverty in Nankai (only the Institute of Physical Education has always been the same). Innovation of undergraduate training system. Large-scale training, a variety of special classes in Boling class emerge one after another. The undergraduate course is the best opportunity for all-round development. I really envy my junior students for having such a good policy. In a word, as an ordinary undergraduate, I have witnessed Nankai getting better and better in the past four years, and I sincerely thank Cao School for its contribution to Nankai in recent years.
There are actually many people praising Cao Xuetao on the Internet. I guess most of them are the voices of vested interests in Nankai. Some people say that we can't deny Cao Xuetao's ability just because of his academic fraud. This sentence is true, but because of his academic fraud, we should deprive him of all academic-related positions. The first thing to do is to win his titles of academician and president. But how do we do it? Not only did he not win his position, but he was constantly promoted in the bureaucracy. The Cao Xuetao incident is the embodiment of the mainstream values in China today. On the way to power, no matter how dirty. With power, he can manipulate public opinion, and a higher-level promoter and a group of dreamers have given him sweetness. We are all counterfeiters in the same boat, so we can only cover for each other.
If a deputy director of the Health and Health Commission can be a university president in the forefront of the "985" among many deputy directors, I believe many people will think that it is a promotion, although it is a deputy ministerial level. If such a university president can go to the central bank as a deputy governor, it is also a promotion. On the other hand, Nankai comes and goes, and you will experience it yourself.
How much influence did Cao's problem paper have on his major scientific discoveries? As one of the great names in the field of immunology, Cao is a rare member of the editorial board of Cell magazine, and his achievements in the field of immunology have been recognized by international academic circles. An interviewee said that Cao's important academic findings were repeated; Moreover, with such a big news, no peers have come forward to say that Cao's important discovery is fraud. This shows that Cao's important achievements are reliable.
In a word, I think if Cao Can learns from the problem, it should be affirmed. Maybe it's because I especially hate people who talk like dead ducks and fool people like fools, so Cao is willing to face his own problems and win some good feelings from me, so he wrote this answer. As for Cao Weijian, I can only say that there is a leader above or that I value him. I hope Cao will live up to his mission.