Most periodicals are published without certificates. Certificates are of little significance to the authors of published papers. The publication of their articles is the best proof, and no certificate is needed at all. Moreover, in the process of applying for a professional title, the author does not need to submit a certificate. The most important thing is to search the page of the article and the page where the article is published. When applying for a professional title, just submit two copies of these pages. There are few requirements for certificates in this respect. Some authors mistakenly believe that.
If you want to evaluate the professional title, the paper must be published first. If you don't see the publication, you can't prove that the paper was published successfully. Secondly, you may not be able to evaluate the title after reading the publication. Some units are very strict about this, and the paper must be found in the corresponding database before it can be evaluated. Therefore, the evaluation of the topic of the paper must be published.
Seeing the publication means that the contribution of the paper is hired and published by the magazine, which means that everyone can see it, which means that the paper is published successfully. However, publication does not mean success. Papers can be published in newspapers, online platforms, collections of essays, etc., except for periodicals and magazines. Our professional titles generally only recognize periodicals published regularly. So we usually think that the issue of your paper has been printed.
Is the employment notice of the thesis topic useful? If the paper is not published, even if you have an employment notice, you have no valid evidence to prove that the paper was published successfully, and the unit will not recognize it until it sees the real thing. When evaluating professional titles, most units are required to provide periodical samples published in papers and data collected in databases. Because some people may be opportunistic, forge papers, or use other people's papers, even if they see the published sample, the unit can't be sure that the paper was written by the applicant himself. Therefore, database authentication has been added, and applicants must submit proof of database inclusion when submitting materials.