Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Graduation thesis - How to evaluate scientific papers
How to evaluate scientific papers
Comprehensive evaluation should be made from the following aspects:

First, the topic selection of academic papers

The topic selection of academic papers is the first step and the beginning of research, which directly affects the value of research topics and the quality of papers. Therefore, it depends on whether the topic of "enhancing company value through spin-off" has a sense of the times. In addition, too big a topic will directly affect the quality of the paper.

Second, the research level of academic papers.

The research level of academic papers can be explained from the following five aspects.

1, originality of research level of academic papers. Every academic paper is the result of creative intellectual labor by the author on the basis of previous research results. The paper should make breakthroughs and innovations in both viewpoints and methods. See if the academic core of the article belongs to the explanation of independent research results. Originality is an important moral criterion for evaluating academic works and the lifeline of academic papers. The research should be original in similar research, and the author should be the main or at least the general participant of the results.

2. The rigidity of the research level demonstration of academic papers. Any academic viewpoint is based on strict argumentation. Generally speaking, the research of any academic paper is a research process of combining theory with practice, and both theoretical research and summary of practical experience are based on rationality. Therefore, whether the research and demonstration of academic papers are rigorous or not directly affects the quality of academic papers.

3. Academic papers study the standardization of horizontal language. The linguistic features of academic papers should be rigorous sentence patterns, standardized writing, accurate terminology and appropriate details. Especially terms and details. As an excellent academic paper, the basic concepts of its research methods are strictly defined from connotation to extension, which is reflected in the strict definition of the meaning of terms.

4. Whether the research direction and orientation of academic papers are consistent. Every academic paper has its own strict academic direction. Even papers belonging to the same academic direction may have different emphases, but they generally rely on them. These are the criteria for evaluating the merits of an academic paper.

5. Novelty and innovation are indispensable elements for the academic level of scientific papers. Some articles eloquently introduce their own "achievements", but never mention the achievements and level of others in this research field, and what aspects of this research have been improved and unique, which has caused the fatal regret of "no comparability". This novelty and innovation can be shown in the preface, results and analysis and references, and the indicators should be as detailed and quantitative as possible.

Third, the research methods of academic papers

The research method can be used as one of the criteria for investigating and evaluating the research results, which can facilitate the investigation and research of similar problems. If the research method is vague and the explanation is vague, it may cause others to question your materials and ultimately affect the evaluation of the quality of the paper. The research methods of academic papers should consider the following questions.

1. research methods which method or methods should be used to study the target object?

2. Induce, summarize and analyze the information and data brought by the adopted methods, and conduct theoretical study.