From three aspects: topic selection, argumentation and literary talent.

-Whether the selected topic meets the needs of objective situation, social reality and work priorities, whether it is targeted, whether it has grasped key contradictions or cut to the chase;

-whether there are original and novel viewpoints, angles and arguments to solve social contradictions or people's ideological doubts;

-whether the title of the article is accurate and attractive;

-what are the characteristics and experiences of reasoning, what effective methods have been used, and whether they are calm and convincing, making people listen and listen;

-whether there are obvious features or innovations in structure, language and diction, and whether the writing style is novel, vivid and smooth;

Second, the basic way to evaluate works

1, key comments

A work is comprehensively weighed from the above five aspects, especially from the three aspects of topic selection, argument and literary talent, and the main characteristics are summarized through analysis for comment and analysis. The practice and scope of evaluation can be evaluated from several aspects, or it can focus on one aspect and give consideration to other aspects, or it can sum up the characteristics of a heart and string it together from several aspects.

For example:

In recent years, the spirit of women's volleyball has been widely publicized in China. ..... It is gratifying that Yangcheng Evening News will be published in the next edition immediately ... His characteristics are as follows: (The first is an overview of the whole incident)

First, it is news and timeliness, which embodies the characteristics of news commentary. ..... Only by immediately cooperating with public opinion can it be effective, and it can be said that it can guide public opinion. (The selected topic conforms to the objective situation, social reality and the needs of key work)

The second is to see profundity in simplicity. Articles about the spirit of women's volleyball are not uncommon, but how to write new ideas really needs some effort. Based on this incident, the author discusses virtual reality from fact to truth. From point to face, from individual to general, from phenomenon to essence, the author jumped out of the general circle of discussing success or failure, but developed and targeted ... This discussion method of discussing reality with virtual facts helps comments to flash out a certain ideological and theoretical color in simple things. (with original and novel viewpoints, angles and arguments)

The third is to have an equal dialogue with readers and give full play to the role of reasoning. ..... The advantages of adopting conversational reasoning, on the one hand, can appear in an equal posture and produce a good reasoning atmosphere; On the other hand, it is also convenient to guide readers to think independently and experience the thinking process from perceptual knowledge to rational knowledge with the author. What are the characteristics and experiences in reasoning?

Short comments also have some shortcomings: in addition, ...

2. Comparative analysis.

Connect two works with the same theme and make a comparative analysis. By comparing the two texts, the advantages and disadvantages are self-presented. Or discuss the characteristics and requirements of different styles.

For example:

First of all, judging from the title, Mind Your Mouth can be said to be humorous and polite. Compared with the title of the last article "Shame on Spitting", it is kind and witty. The tone and attitude of the discussion is not domineering, but the seriousness of equal conversation. We don't talk about vague and well-known truth, but put facts, situations and data, speak with facts ... and then talk about the importance of the problem from point to surface ... to achieve the purpose of combining the virtual with the real and showing the truth in images.

Subsequently, the article hit the nail on the head: rice understands that the root of the disease lies in some people's bad habits. So, how can we change the bad habit of spitting uncivilized? So naturally, the "prescription" for treating bad habits was put forward ... These analyses and suggestions were put in place and well-founded, and in a few words, the voices of the readers were expressed.

Through the comparative analysis of the two articles, we can draw some useful notes and methods:

One is ...

The second is to enhance the news. Be good at using news facts as the starting point of argument ...

Third, the style and style of writing should be popular, humorous and cordial, and strive to be colloquial.

Fourth, in writing attitude, don't be arrogant, put yourself in the other's shoes, get along with the readers and be persuasive. ...

3. Thematic evaluation

Make a research evaluation of a person's works or a certain kind of works related to the same content, and combine several articles to concentrate on one aspect.

Examples of common flat and parallel sentences:

A/ as far as arguments are concerned:

This theory is novel and sharp ... the analysis is accurate and thorough ... dialectical unity, divided into two.

B/ discuss features:

Metaphorical argument, skillfully using rhetorical devices such as rhetorical questions and parallelism ... dig deep into the point, satirize it to the point ... from individual phenomena to the essence of things ... discuss the reality, from point to surface ... reduce the absurd magical use ... targeted, to the point ... The argument is novel and thought-provoking ... Criticize the current drawbacks and prescribe the right medicine.

C/ as far as literary talent is concerned:

The true feelings are revealed, the literary talent is dazzling ... attractive epigrams come from the heart ... sharp, provocative and reasonable ... satire in humorous images ... concise words ... combination of narration and discussion ... approachable and obviously carefree writing ... lively and sharp writing, clear love and hate, no hesitation ... rigorous logic, clear hierarchy, appropriate boundaries and language.

D/ title:

Novel and eye-catching, accurate and ingenious, very attractive. ...