Graduation Design Review 1 Tutor Review
XXX's paper "Design of Digital FM Transmitter" has successfully completed the research task specified in the task book. This paper mainly uses digital signal processing (DSP) and direct digital frequency synthesis (DDS) technology to realize the design of digital FM transmitter. This design is completed by two students, who are mainly responsible for the design of the system in DSP. The translation of foreign language materials is acceptable, the paper format is basically standardized, the discussion is basically accurate, the expected requirements are met, and the requirements for the defense of bachelor's degree thesis are met.
Allow students to take part in graduation thesis defense.
Opinions of the National Defense Commission
The defense team reviewed XXX's paper "Design of Digital FM Transmitter", and thought that the topic of this paper had certain research value, and the design of the system in DSP was basically reasonable. The author has a certain ability to read the reference materials, basically completed the contents stipulated in the graduation thesis task book, and can answer the questions correctly when defending.
After discussion by the defense group, the defense score is rated as medium.
Graduation design review 2 1. Lecturer's comments:
During the graduation project (thesis), students' working attitude (correct/average), thesis work (serious effort/relative effort/average), thesis workload (large/medium/small), thesis difficulty (large/medium/small), mastering the basic theory and professional knowledge of the subject (solid/good/average), and strong ability to analyze and solve problems (.
2. The auditor's opinion:
This student's graduation project (thesis) topic selection (appropriate/relatively appropriate/general). In the graduation project (thesis) work, the student (a large number/extensive) read domestic and foreign references, (proposed/developed/made) (experimental scheme/device/experiment), and got the result (), which shows that the student has (strong/strong/general) comprehensive analysis and independent hands-on ability. Paper organization (clear/unclear), writing (fluent/basically fluent/not fluent), charts (normative/non-normative), well completed/completed/unfinished) graduation project (paper) task, (able/able/unable) to participate in graduation project (paper) defense.
3. Comprehensive comments:
(1) Excellent:
Graduation design (thesis) is completed, and all tasks are completed as scheduled; The scheme selection is correct, the demonstration is sufficient, the main problems in the design are deeply analyzed, the solution is reasonable, and there are independent opinions; Be able to use theory and professional knowledge to solve problems in design. The paper is clear, accurate and fully discussed; You can answer the questions raised by the members satisfactorily in your defense.
(2) Good:
Graduation design (thesis) is completed, and all tasks are completed as scheduled; The scheme selection is correct, the demonstration is good, the main problems in the design are deeply analyzed, the solution is reasonable, and there are certain opinions; Can better use theory and professional knowledge to solve problems in design. The paper is organized clearly, calculated accurately, discussed correctly, and answered correctly and comprehensively.
(3) Medium:
The whole process of graduation design (thesis) is good, and I can abide by discipline; The design content is complete, and the content specified in the task book can be completed on schedule; The scheme selection is basically correct, and the related problems in the design can be basically solved by using the theory learned and the data provided on the spot. The demonstration is general, with certain analytical ability to the main problems or topics in the design, reasonable solutions, and certain ability to work independently; The written materials are clear and the arguments are correct, but there are some mistakes or unclear expressions in the discussion. The chart is complete, but the quality is average, or there are minor flaws; The answer in the defense is basically correct, but the analysis is not deep enough.
(4) by:
The whole process of graduation design (thesis) is general, and I can abide by discipline; Basically complete the content of the design task, but it is not complete enough; There is no principled error in scheme selection and main technical measures, the arguments and arguments are basically established, and the calculation, analysis and design are basically correct. Written materials are fluent, but the discussion is not appropriate and clear enough; The quality of the chart is not high, with some mistakes, but it basically meets the engineering requirements; There are no mistakes in principle when answering questions, and basically the main questions can be answered.
(5) Failure:
The whole process of graduation design (thesis) is poor and lacks discipline; The content of the design task has not been completed; There are principled errors in scheme selection and main technical measures, major errors in calculation and chart, lack of independent working ability in design process, and graduation design can not meet the minimum requirements; Can't answer the main questions raised or answer the main questions with principled errors.
Graduation design review 3 1. In the five-minute presentation, the student introduced the main content and structure of the paper, as well as the research conducted for it, which showed that he had a certain understanding of the research issues. The video design is beautiful, but it doesn't meet the professional requirements. It will be better to design the implementation process from the perspective of computer science.
2. With the help of statistical analysis software, it is of great significance to provide theoretical support for xxx.
The student fluently stated the theoretical and practical significance of writing this paper. The website design process is very standardized, but there is little connection between entities and concepts. The whole design should meet the requirements of the computer as much as possible.
9. This paper embodies the author's solid theoretical foundation, systematic professional knowledge and good scientific research ability in this subject. It meets the requirements of master's degree thesis, and it is suggested to arrange a defense.
10, students state clearly and answer questions fluently. Although the paper has a good idea and certain research value, the framework and content are huge, which requires strong independent research ability, and the title of the paper and the client login server module need to be slightly modified. Students are well prepared, complete in presentation, clear in thesis conception, good in professional foundation and good in time. That is, there is demand in the paper but there is a lack of demand analysis, and the answers to some defense questions are not clear, and the graphic representation is not standardized.
1 1. The writing of the thesis conforms to the standards of graduate thesis, and the academic level is good, which reflects the results of two years' study and can enter the defense procedure.
12, fully prepared for defense, able to answer the teacher's questions in detail, able to repeatedly discuss and study the difficulties encountered in the design process to find a better solution, and good professional skills. It would be better if the static web page can be made dynamic by combining professional improvement, but the deficiency is that the description of the table in the database is not quite right, and I hope it can be improved.
13. During the defense, students can skillfully state the main contents of the paper within the specified time, with clear organization, obvious innovation, quick response when answering questions, accurate expression, skilled system demonstration and high professional quality. After deliberation by the defense Committee, it was agreed that his performance was excellent.
14. The research results of this paper show that the research on xxxx has strong practical value and maneuverability, which fully reflects the author's comprehensive understanding of xxxx, and has experience, analysis, thinking and suggestions on xxxx practice.
15, students use dreamweave and access database technology to design Ganzi tourism website. The design is fresh and beautiful, the main questions are answered accurately, and the basic concepts are clear. I want to correct the database storage problem in the file.