At the beginning of the new year, follow a package? Teacher's sense of nobility? And then what? Teacher Niang's beauty? what's up Wonderful words? After the brush screen, another core journal, Banker, became popular again. According to media reports, a paper published in the core journal "Glacier Frozen Soil" is mostly touted? Teacher's sense of nobility? And then what? Teacher Niang's beauty? The tutor mentioned in the paper is the editor-in-chief of the magazine. In this regard, CCTV commented? Find out how much special funds have been wasted by this shameless miracle. . There is another wave of unrest. A few days ago, some scholars found that the editor-in-chief of Banker magazine opened it. Father-son condom? Column, publishing his own calligraphy and his son's articles, there have been dozens of articles so far. After the incident was exposed, public opinion criticized it. Can core journals be reduced to editor-in-chief and father-son? At present, Shanxi Academy of Social Sciences, the superior unit in charge of Banker magazine, responded that it would carry out a comprehensive rectification of the magazine and deal with the editor-in-chief Wang accordingly.
Second, the views of all parties.
China Education News: Only when everyone cares about the academic pastoral, can we hope to create an academic ecology that is clean and upright, learning from each other and positive. Everyone puts social responsibility in the first place, practices socialist core values, and is the pursuer and disseminator of truth, goodness and beauty. Only in this way can academic research be more innovative, away from impatience, impatience, impetuousness and utilitarianism, and then form an excellent style of study that advocates fine works, is rigorous in academic research, and pays attention to honesty and responsibility, and fundamentally develops and strengthens China's cultural and educational undertakings.
Beijing Youth Daily: Are core periodicals published irregularly? Bullshit newspaper, father and son? , it will inevitably affect the authority and credibility of the evaluation of core journals, which is also a kind of harm to the core journals and their evaluation mechanism itself.
China Youth Daily: At present, core journals that have loopholes in peer review mechanism or lack the strength to maintain the ability and requirements of running journals should be established only by their internal self-discipline? Self-correction, self-examination and self-correction? The mechanism is almost to seek fish from the edge of the tree, so it is difficult to play a practical role. Want to change some core journals? Price drop? In addition to establishing a scientific, perfect and comprehensive evaluation system, we should also introduce the responsibility of third-party evaluation, supervision and management.
Light. Com: These wonderful articles have turned national academic journals into tools for personal gain, desecrated academic dignity, corrupted academic atmosphere and lost the basic academic bottom line. Only serious accountability and implementation? System maintenance upgrade? Only by strictly selecting manuscripts and reviewing manuscripts, giving full play to the academic communication function of academic journals, and putting an end to all kinds of chaos such as abuse of power for personal gain and academic corruption, can we find back the proper appearance, credibility and dignity of core journals.
Third, in-depth analysis
(1) publishing of core journals? Flattery? The teacher's article reflects the existing problems:
1. Journals for promotion? Impact factor? On the track of academic competition? Shortcut? .
2. The ecological abnormality of academic evaluation: the promotion of university teachers' professional titles and postgraduate awards take publishing papers as an important evaluation index, which leads to an increase in the overall demand of university teachers and students for publishing papers, while some publications follow suit and set up arbitrary sections, which not only charge high page fees, but also meet the actual needs of teachers and students.
4. Some researchers lack academic ethics.
(2) Some measures can be taken to solve the problem of improper publication of core journals:
1. Introduce academic journals? Peer review? Or? Anonymous comments? And other evaluation mechanisms to maintain a fair and just academic atmosphere.
2. Establish a scientific, perfect and comprehensive evaluation system, and introduce third-party evaluation, supervision and management responsibilities.
4. Strengthen supervision and strictly examine and approve the publication and selection of academic journals, especially core journals. If the operators fail to strictly abide by the relevant laws and regulations, they can revoke their serial numbers and establish an exit mechanism for core journals; We should also select some excellent academic journals and give corresponding rewards to encourage more academic journals to develop with high quality. Fourth, refer to the article.
Maintain the core position of core journals
Core journals are the main journals of a certain discipline. Generally speaking, it refers to a professional periodical with a large amount of professional information and high quality, which can represent the development level of professional disciplines and is valued by readers of this discipline. In such a publication, unexpectedly published a flattering article? Teacher's sense of nobility? And then what? Teacher Niang's beauty? The core publication "Glacier Frozen Soil" is the only periodical-level journal in the research field of ice, snow, frozen soil and cryosphere in China, which has aroused heated public opinion. Before the controversy subsided, another core journal was on fire: Wang, editor-in-chief of Banker magazine, opened it? Father-son condom? Column, publishing his own calligraphy and his son's articles, there have been dozens of articles so far. His son was only 10 years old when he first published essays and poems in The Banker. It's embarrassing to have such a big surprise.
To strengthen the construction of academic journals and improve the academic level of domestic professional journals, we need to clarify our own nature first. Since it is an academic journal, we should establish and adhere to the principle of peer review that modern academic journals should have. For those trade journals and popular science books that do not meet academic standards, it is not appropriate to let them hold the title of core academic journals. As the main platform for publishing academic achievements, academic journals are more pure, and academic undertakings can develop fairly and efficiently. Authors and editors should put science and seriousness first, be responsible for every manuscript, every project and every fund, and strive to make authoritative journal papers more credible? Public products? . Academic misconduct such as plagiarism and smuggling should be cleaned up and punished in time. At the same time, vigorously developing education can not be separated from the support of all sectors of society, which requires better cooperation between families and schools, and also requires relevant departments to strengthen supervision and do a good job of supervision between industries.
? I love my teacher, and I love truth more. ? Hundreds of years before BC, the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle told the world not to worship authority in the process of pursuing truth. It is said that before the avalanche, no snowflake was innocent, and unhealthy trends should not be allowed to destroy the academic trend, nor should one's own interests violate the fine traditions of China's cultural and educational undertakings.
(Source: Guangming. Com, China Education News, People's Daily)