According to the relevant information, it depends on what kind of enterprise you are in. If you are in a state-owned enterprise, the doctoral degree is still very popular. Within the system, the doctoral degree is quite arrogant, especially in state-owned enterprises. Many doctors can easily enter middle management positions in state-owned enterprises. But for private enterprises, regardless of your educational background, the social value you can create is 1, and the products you can't make are probably nothing.