How terrible is anonymous peer review?
Let's first look at the system of organizing expert group review: in fact, to put it bluntly, it is anonymous submission, and the review tutor doesn't know who the author of the paper is, and the students don't know who the review tutor is. Colleges and universities in general, especially graduate schools, will have relevant regulations for blind evaluation of dissertations on a regular basis, and most of them will randomly select a certain number of theses for blind evaluation. The blind evaluation system is to send dissertations without the author's name to experts who can't know the author for evaluation, so the score should be the most objective. The proportion of blind examination of master's thesis in different schools is different, generally between 30% and 50%. Doctoral dissertations are all blind, and of course there are those who can't graduate. Especially good schools pay more attention to the quality of postgraduate training. The graduate department will notify the degree evaluation sub-committee, tutors and graduate students to defend the thesis. If the thesis is considered unqualified, the graduate department will inform the graduate students and their tutors to revise the thesis; If the graduate students themselves and their tutors disagree with the results of the blind test, they can fill in the Application Form for Review and apply for review. Generally speaking, since it is a blind test, the other teacher doesn't know your author's name and instructor's name. Generally speaking, teachers don't check on-the-job papers. As we all know, they came for the degree of water, and they almost missed it, unless the paper was really poor. However, the blind test failed and there was a second chance. Take the time to revise according to the relevant suggestions, so that the teacher in charge of submitting for review can quickly send it back to other teachers for review, as long as the opinions submitted by other teachers pass.