1. Innovation: Did the paper put forward new ideas, theories or methods, and expanded or revised the existing knowledge?
2. Importance: Is the research question of the paper important and has practical significance? Can you provide new ideas or methods for the research in related fields?
3. Rigidity: Is the research method scientific and rigorous, and is the data and analysis accurate and reliable?
4. Reproducibility: Can the research results of this paper be replicated and verified by other researchers?
5. Influence: The number of citations and influence factors after the publication of the paper can reflect its academic value. High citation times and high impact factors usually mean that papers have high academic influence.
6. Practicality: For some applied research, can the research results of this paper be directly applied to solve practical problems?
7. Academic contribution: Does the paper contribute to the academic knowledge system? Has a new theoretical framework or model been proposed?
8. Academic norms: Does the paper conform to academic norms, such as plagiarism and tampering with data?