What are the opinion templates of paper reviewers?

1. Does the title of the paper conform to the scope of the journal?

2. Does the paper have clear research questions and objectives?

3. Is the research method of the paper appropriate?

4. Is the data collection and analysis of the paper accurate?

5. Is the argument of the paper sufficient and the conclusion reasonable?

6. Is the structure of the paper clear and the logic coherent?

7. Is the language expression of the paper clear, and is there any grammatical or spelling mistakes?

8. How innovative and original is the paper?

9. Is the citation of relevant research appropriate?

10. Can the authors clearly explain their methods and results?

1 1. Can the authors clearly discuss the limitations of their research?

12. Can the author suggest possible directions for future research?

13. Has the author solved all the questions and suggestions raised by the reviewers?

14. Are the authors qualified for this research (for example, do they have the necessary qualifications and experience)?

15. Did the author follow the submission guidelines of the journal?

16. Other possible problems and suggestions.