Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Graduation thesis - Jia peacock's thesis
Jia peacock's thesis
There are five people I like best in a Dream of Red Mansions, three jade: Baoyu and Daiyu, Qingwen and You Sanjie. Let's talk about Miaoyu and Qingwen after a long time, and finally make a comparison.

The most beautiful and talented Miaoyu: Cao Xueqin described Miaoyu as "beautiful in temperament, richer in talent than fairy" in his twelve poems "Hard to forget on earth". It can be seen that Miaoyu is an absolute temperament beauty. In red inkstone's comment on writing, her name is Miao Qing, which shows this woman's position in red inkstone's heart. In the fat version of 10, there is such a comment: Miaoyu is too clean in a remote place. I want to persuade Guazhou Ferry to punish him, don't be sad, surrender to Yu Meiren and don't die. This is completely different from the performance and ending of Miaoyu in the last forty chapters of Senior Two Xu. Gao E's sequel said that Miaoyu liked Baoyu, but she was uneasy about Buddhism, but she moved her mind outside the world of mortals and was finally captured by robbers. This sequel has obvious problems. Miaoyu is the only non-noble woman who ranks sixth among the twelve women in Jinling. If she has no role in the story, and her personality and temperament are not obviously superior to other women, what is the reason for her joining the official? Miaoyu is really an example of Gao E destroying Cao Xueqin's Dream of Red Mansions, which is not credible. According to the comment on writing in Jing Cang Ben, Miaoyu should finally risk going home to Guazhou Ferry to save someone (probably Baoyu and Xiangyun) and sacrifice herself. Miaoyu gives most people the impression that she is Leng Yan's appearance, keeps a distance from most people, is not too close to anyone, and is inexplicably conceited. He seems to be an annoying heartless person, but it is this kind of person who has unlimited energy in his heart and even sacrifices himself for others. Being thousands of miles away from others is more about protecting yourself. Because her heart is too clean to hold this dirty world, the world naturally can't hold her. The so-called "people who don't know how tall are more jealous, and people who are too clean in the world are too jealous." A person who lives in a dirty world, unwilling to associate with it, can only seal himself in his own world to avoid being hurt. Miaoyu people are respectable and pitiful, but everyone has the instinct to seek recognition. This is why she emphasizes her taste, even to the point of inhumanity. Her dislike of granny Liu is really a manifestation of her inner lack of identity. Some people hate her for it, but I feel sad for it.

There should be a poll in a dream of red mansions. Whoever has the worst popularity must be this arrogant wonderful jade. However, the author Cao Xueqin's highest evaluation of Miaoyu is "good temperament, talent is better than fairy". She not only entered the twelve women in Jinling, but also ranked sixth. Miaoyu is a domestic nun after all, but she is not arrogant. Her first debut was to make tea for Grandmother Jia and give it to Daiyu Baochai. She regards Daiyu and others as her friends, and does not flatter Jia blindly because of her high status. This is a wonderful jade, not burdened by secular status, and believes in equality between people. In her view, there are only friends who are confidants, and secular people who have no confidants. There are no dignitaries, no untouchables, her thoughts are too advanced and her behavior is too out of line. Even today, her behavior is out of line today, not to mention in the society at that time, when you and others. Others don't think it's a social problem, just think it's your problem. Miaoyu is facing this. For ordinary people, we usually encounter this situation by changing ourselves and letting our water chestnut slowly wear away in life. But Miaoyu is different from others. She still sticks to her original self and never changes. Even if others hate her, this person is definitely worthy of Clivia. But she is not a person with a strong heart, and the confrontation with the secular makes her very tired. Very hurt, people's sense of self-protection made her subconsciously take the way to protect herself, that is, talk less to others and make fewer friends. This attitude makes others think that she is a person who keeps people away, so it is difficult for her to get social recognition. People are a kind of life that they want to recognize. Miaoyu often emphasizes her own taste and does not hesitate to do something out of line, such as throwing the quilt that Grandma Liu has drunk tea. For example, Lin Daiyu is a layman. But she's not aggressive. She is essentially a noble clivia. In fact, her heart is cleaner than anyone else, and this lonely character is more sacrificial than secular people. I was really moved by this orchid when he saved Baoyu, who was like himself. Such a beautiful woman with unique temperament is so outstanding in literary talent. Thinking about this, you will still care about her loneliness. No wonder Baoyu respects her so much. In Cao Xueqin's mind, Miaoyu is a temperament beauty with outstanding knowledge and the highest benchmark of morality and humanity. Even if she has flaws, her beauty is so dazzling! Such a noble girl is worth entering 12.

Miao Yu's verdict: if you want to be clean, you will never be clean, and the clouds may not be empty. Poor jade, fell into the mud

& lt& lt The world is unbearable >>: Temperament is blue, talent is better than fairy. There is little natural loneliness. What do you mean by eating meat? See you again. But I don't know that people who are too tall are more likely to be jealous, and so are people who are too clean. It's a pity that the people in Dengqing Ancient Temple will get old and decline, and the red chamber will be beautiful. In the end, I was totally ashamed and went against their wishes. Why, the prince sighed.

Qingwen: "My heart is higher than the sky, and I am inferior" is Qingwen's greatest loveliness, and "Yong Qingwen" is her label. At the age of ten, he was bought by Lai Da as a servant girl, a slave, and later respected Jia Wei as a gift, but he was not servile at all. In such a hierarchical feudal ethical society, her status is very low. But Qingwen doesn't sell herself short, trying to keep her personality intact. Her frankness and recklessness are aimed at everyone: Baoyu, Daiyu and Xiren. Objectively speaking, she is really not a good girl. She never put herself in the position of a slave. Even if Baoyu is asked to love herself, she is on the same level of "people", neither supercilious nor humble, gentle and smooth, so she will use it again. People who live for their hearts can't help but be moved now. Her heart belongs to Baoyu, but she doesn't indulge Baoyu like xiren. She exchanged her heart for Baoyu's infatuation "Shouyao was born of slander, and he was full of affection." This is the end of the lovely Qingwen. The pursuit of freedom of mind and equality of personality made her offend all the villains, which led to her being driven out of Jia's family by Mrs. Wang and dying of poverty and illness. Relatives are indifferent, only Baoyu cares about her. Yong Qingwen's courage and spiritual temperament make people feel respectable, and "romantic dexterity" makes us see her cuteness. Qingwen is shrewd and sharp, and xiren is secretly promised as Baoyu's concubine by Mrs. Wang. Although the author doesn't explicitly say Qingwen's jealousy, it is obvious from Qingwen's words that she is envious and jealous. Qingwen dares to love, hate and scold, and speaks quickly. Some words came from Qingwen without the author's introduction. When she fell off the fan and contradicted Baoyu, the attacker persuaded her, and Qingwen even sarcastically replied, "Since ancient times, you have served my grandfather alone. We have never served him before, because you served him very well and only got a heartfelt foot yesterday. " "ouch! You are the only one in this room who misses him, and we have all lived in vain? " Just a few examples. Some things only Qingwen dares to do, such as tearing a fan to make her daughter laugh, such as bravely mending peacock hair when she is sick. For example, wearing a light coat to scare people in winter nights, a naughty, clever and willful beauty image has really won the love of many readers. Dear and lovely Qingwen, do you like it? Although I also like the bouncing auspicious clouds, there will be laughter as soon as I get there, but after thinking about it, I still think Qingwen is the cutest.

Both of them are dissatisfied with the secular, of course, their dissatisfaction with the secular may not be exactly the same. Miaoyu does not cooperate with the secular world, liberates her soul and establishes a world of her own in her inner world. Qingwen fought against the secular world like a hero, and finally sacrificed for the beauty she pursued.