Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Resume - Is Xue Baochai in a Dream of Red Mansions the one with the best ending? How to treat the ending of Jia family?
Is Xue Baochai in a Dream of Red Mansions the one with the best ending? How to treat the ending of Jia family?
Judging from her judgment that "it's a pity to stop work in the fifth time in A Dream of Red Mansions", Xue Bao, as the heroine tied with Lin Daiyu in A Dream of Red Mansions, has a bad ending. Judging from Gao E's sequel and the research of many Redology researchers, her ending is nothing more than two kinds:

The first ending is that Gao E's sequel said: In order to celebrate Baoyu's happiness, she dressed as Lin Daiyu and married Jia Baoyu. Lin Daiyu burned the manuscript and died. Although Jia Baoyu eventually became a monk, she left her blood behind, that is, she gave birth to a son named Jia Gui, and later she was called "Gui Lan Qi Fang" with Jia Lan, which revived the Jia family.

This ending is not tragic for Xue Baochai. She despises Baoyu's progress and often exhorts him. Baoyu hates her "stopping". If the ending is really like this, she can train her son according to her own wishes and let her son realize his long-cherished wish of "going to heaven". As a flashy feudal morality, Baochai has a happy ending.

The second ending: Baochai finally married Baoyu, but after Lin Daiyu died. Baoyu was already "dying". Although he doesn't want to marry Baochai, he doesn't have a perfect marriage, let alone a son. At first, Baochai got Baoyu, but every time she got no heart, she always lived alone.

Later, Jia Baoyu simply became a monk, and Baochai had nothing. How hard she was hit, so she should have died in the end. The ending is not tragic.

I agree with the second ending. According to Cao Gong's layout: "A thousand red holes in the sky, Wan Yan shares the same sorrow", the ending should be a great tragedy. After Jiafu was overthrown, the people attached to it, especially the daughters, had a tragic ending. Both Lin Daiyu, who is rebellious, and Xue Baochai, who obeys feudal ethics, are doomed to be sacrificed.

As for Jia Baoyu, both Gao E and other experts think that he finally became a monk. Because there is a prophecy in front, "He who sees through will escape into an empty net; It's like eating birds and throwing them into the forest. It's so clean to land on a piece of white land! " Jia Baoyu's words about becoming a monk are also mentioned in many places in the book.

After the downfall of Jiafu, Jia, who grew up in luxury, experienced where you would go. The world was frozen and human feelings were warm and cold, and finally he saw through the world of mortals and fled into an empty net.