The article points out: "Yuan Shao has a good family background, complete experience, rich academic background and handsome appearance, but as historians say, he is indecisive and ambitious." Guo Jia thinks that Yuan Shao's theory is "be resourceful but not broken, gather talents without using them, smell them but not accept them, and hundred schools of thought contends, but the quantity is small but not big". This person is generous and humble on the surface, but actually cares about resentment; Fame spreads widely, and talents can be recruited, but talents will not be used well; I love to seek wisdom, but my ears are soft, I listen to the east and the west, wavering, even if I have a good plan, I will not use it, and I have no control. To sum up, Yuan Shao is a villain, not a great man. Huang Chuangxia said that this portrayal, compared with Ma Ying Jiu, feels very familiar. "
Wonderful words.
Teacher Chen also mentioned in the article that "people who engage in politics should be a little careless or a little rogue", which also made me applaud. The leaders who claim to be pan-blue but not pan-green just lack the intense atmosphere of grass-roots rebellion, and truly penetrate the hearts and minds of Taiwan Province Province, which is already the * * * knowledge of Taiwan Province Province observers.
As a result, I went home to visit the Three Kingdoms and found some fashionable books about the Three Kingdoms. I read it out of control, and simply turned Mr. Chen's wonderful article into a dog's tail, looking forward to Mr. Chen's going to sea.
However, I think it is not the most accurate to describe Kyle by Yuan Shao.
Recently, Professor Yi Zhongtian's evaluation of Liu Biao in the Three Kingdoms caused a sensation in China because of his conviction of Cao Cao, which is closely related to my feelings for Ma Ying IX.
When I read that if Cao Cao is a "lovely adulterer", then Liu Biao gives the impression that he is a "beautiful straw bag", I almost beat my thigh red.
Exactly, 100% accurate description. Even if you don't say it, observers who often watch the situation in the Taiwan Strait will instinctively feel this description, which is very suitable for some leaders of the pan-blue camp.
If you use Mr. Chen Zibo's evaluation that "a politician should be somewhat careless", Yuan Shao's careless temperament far exceeds Liu Biao's. At least we remember that when Yuan Shao and Cao Cao were young, they also did the absurd thing of robbing other people's brides. As a result, Yuan Shao fell into a thorn and couldn't move. Later, Cao Cao used his quick wits and shouted, "Here comes the thief!" As a result, Yuan Shao jumped out with all his strength in a hurry.
Playing with an adulterer in troubled times, incredibly dare to rob the bride together. Yuan Shao was not a good man and a good woman since he was a child. And Liu Biao is also the "emperor's room" and looks handsome. "It is more than eight feet long and has a beautiful appearance."
According to Professor Yi, Liu Biao is still very capable of governing Jingzhou. Fifteen thieves (rich bandits) were beheaded, which also prevented Sun Jian from marching into Jingzhou. After that, he formed an alliance with Zhang Xiu, and after stabilizing Jingzhou, he opened up some territories. "Caring for the people, training scholars, and calmly protecting themselves" is his first life goal.
As a result, a bunch of literati in the Central Plains went to Jingzhou to beg. And Liu Biao is also very kind to these people. At that time, Jingzhou became a "university town", and even Zhuge Liang lived in Jingzhou. It is conceivable that Jingzhou had a strong humanistic atmosphere at that time.
Liu Biao is not as arrogant as Yuan Shao. His strategy is to close the door and live his own life if he can't beat it anyway.
Unfortunately, Liu Biao has no ambition since then, and he lacks the measure of tolerance. He had a bad relationship with the ambitious Liu Bei, and even tried to plot against Liu Bei for a time. As a result, Liu Bei rode a deer and horse and jumped over Tanxi to escape, pushing away an important force that could have formed an alliance.
This is a vivid costume version of the relationship between Ma Ying IX and Wang Jinping, the leader of the local faction of the Kuomintang.
Liu Biao's successor is also a soft skin. After Liu Qi's infighting, he went to Liu Bei. Before seeing Cao Caolai, Liu Cong surrendered and listened. Now look at the fighting capacity of the new generation of aristocratic children of the Kuomintang, and that's all.
However, a weak leader occupied a strategic position that Cao, Liu and Sun all envied for a long time. Liu Biao occupied Jingzhou, and Mark occupied the position of chairman of the Kuomintang and numerous party properties inherited from his ancestors. As a result, it is conceivable that Jingzhou of Liu Biao was borrowed by Liu Bei and never returned; Mark's political legacy was also sold by himself.
Therefore, the historian Mr. He Ziquan said that if Cao Cao was a "capable minister who ruled the world and a traitor in troubled times", then Liu Biao was a "virtuous minister who ruled the world and a mediocre person in troubled times".
Liu Biao was born and made wrong in the era of competing for the world, and Mark was born and made wrong in Taiwan Province Province, where the political battlefield was filled with smoke and everything was done.
A colleague said, "If Mark was born in Singapore, he would become a minister." . My heart is full of sadness.