Ge (Professor of Fudan University): "Whether Mr. Wen is a' master of Chinese studies' is actually not a problem at all, because he has never been regarded as a' master' by scholars or academic circles in China, nor has he been recognized as a person."
Qian Liqun (Professor Peking University): "Forgive my ignorance, but I haven't seen this book in Peking University Library (that is," A New Interpretation of Lu Xun's Old Poems "written by Wen) ... It seems that there is no such person's name among previous generations of Lu Xun research experts?"
Guo Jianxun (Professor of Hunan University): "Wen Huaisha has no academic papers, so it can be said that he has no position in the research field."
Sang Bing (Professor, Sun Yat-sen University): "In the academic context since the Republic of China, there is no place for literature."
Xu Jinru (Ph.D., Sun Yat-sen University): "Wen's' Zhengqinghe' is nonsense."
Chen Siyi (writer, former deputy editor-in-chief of Outlook Weekly of Xinhua News Agency): "He has no position in the field of Chu Ci at all. He has never written anything academic, research or textual research. He just translated Chu Ci into modern Chinese. His translation was not very good either. The media called him "the first person of Chu Ci", which was actually a task assigned by People's Literature Publishing House in that year, and was assigned to Qu Yuan Ji, which was a mess. He has no academic works, and his "Four Civilizations" is not an academic work. "
Huang Linggeng (Vice President of Qu Yuan Society of China and Professor of Zhejiang Normal University): "Wherever the article goes, there are always a few cliches about' Chinese studies', which are nothing new. Scholars in academic circles will know how good he is. "
Qian Zhongshu (a famous scholar): "Wen Zi is great."
Hu Yaobang: "Sao's new look, I've heard a lot about you."
Zhang Xianliang (a famous writer): "I don't know if Wen is a master of Chinese studies, but his knowledge is at least much greater than mine."
Xu Jialu (Professor of Beijing Normal University): "Wen doesn't claim to be a master of Chinese studies, but if you want to say that you can't call him a master without many works, I don't think so. It depends on how much knowledge you have ... Wen is always my teacher, and he will always be my teacher."
Fan Ceng (Professor, Nankai University): "I used to go to the toilet when I was young, but I rushed for more than forty years. Fan Sheng is lucky to have a teacher. Wen Lao is fortunate to have a disciple. "
Wang Xuezhong (a famous calligrapher): "Look at today's calligraphers, I love the simplicity and massiness."
Xie Yun (a famous painter and calligrapher): "Wen Lao is a hermit in academic circles, and his calligraphy is better than ancient rites ... Wen Lao is familiar with the rhyme of poetry, and he is also familiar with the melody, either low and suffocating, or euphemistically high-pitched, masculine and feminine, reciting wonderful rhyme and entering samadhi."
Zhao Que (advocate of the new national style): "His series of measures (referring to reviving Hanfu and compiling the Four Civilizations) make me have to be regarded as the spiritual leader of the Chinese cultural revival movement!"
Qian (ci writers, a famous poet): "Wen is a man of God. A man of God, an extraordinary man. This mainly means that his appearance, behavior and skills are unattainable. "
Simplicity (Scholar): "This 100-year-old writer named Wen has created countless literary legends all his life. He is a master of poetry, books, literature and history. He is innocent of the name of Wen, but as a man who walks the world in his name, there is no room for a grain of sand in his eyes." He opened up three schools of Confucianism, Buddhism and Taoism with the words' Zhengqinghe' and explained the true meaning of oriental philosophy. "
"Master of Chinese Studies" and "Master of Chu Ci"?
"Master of Chinese Studies", "Pioneer of Qu Yuan's Research in New China" and "Leader of Chu Ci" are the titles given by the media, but in the article, it is questioned that "it is difficult to find an academic monograph by rummaging through libraries and online old bookstores, so we have to give up the idea of studying his knowledge." Wen's most important academic achievement seems to be the Collection of Qu Yuan compiled and published in 1960s and 1950s, followed by the publication of Nine Songs.
Mr. Shu Wu, who worked with Wen in his early years, wrote: "Gu, Wang, Zhang, Wen, Li, Shu and Huang, including Mr. Wen, the organizer of Qu Yuan Ji, were not hired as experts, but were assigned editing tasks as editors of our society. In chronological order, each of them can be said to be the first person to organize a book in New China, but this' first' does not contain value meaning at all, not the meaning of pioneers, founders and founders. " He also said, "These books have been published one after another. Except for four novels, there is actually only a thin one. Annotations are very simple and popular. It was popular at that time and not academic. " Wen commented on Qu Yuan's Collected Works, but he was criticized by other experts. "Teacher Wen smashed the pot like this as soon as he took the shot, and then he was transferred from the People's Literature Publishing House." Shu Wei said.
His other book, Interpretation of Nine Songs, was criticized by all parties that year. It is said that the translation of Li Yimang's essay is "very incoherent, with only one sentence translated, and the whole sentence is not taken care of, and even the word in one sentence is out of line. In some places, the translator does not understand the original text deeply. " Li Ruqing criticized the modern translation of essays: "It must also be pointed out that some grammars are not fluent ..."