The reporter found the master's thesis "Kant's View of Moral Freedom" published by the graduate students majoring in ethics in the Department of Philosophy of Nanjing Normal University in May 2008 and the master's thesis "An Analysis of Kant's Theory of Moral Freedom" published by the graduate students majoring in foreign philosophy in the Department of Philosophy of Hubei University in May 2065438+2004. The reporter found that some of the contents of the two papers are basically the same. The master's thesis was published six years earlier than that of Gao.
The contents of the two papers are basically the same, and the content of the high paper is on the left.
Abstract of Tao Tao's Papers in 2008
20 14 high summary
For example, Tao Tao wrote in the first paragraph of the third part of his thesis "Freedom in Practice": Freedom, as a transcendental concept, has been given the possibility of its existence in Critique of Pure Reason, but it has not been proved. At the same time, "if we can find some reasons to prove that this attribute actually belongs to the will of human beings and the will of all rational beings, then this not only shows that pure rationality can be practiced, but also shows that only pure rationality, not rationality limited by experience, can be unconditionally practiced." In other words, if we prove that the attribute of freedom belongs to human will, then the practical application of pure reason can also be proved.
The first paragraph of "freedom of practice" in Gao Lun's article is like this: freedom, as a transcendental concept, has been given the possibility of existence in pure rational criticism, but it has not been proved to be "true" exactly. At the same time, "if we can find some reasons to prove that this attribute actually belongs to the will of human beings and also belongs to the will of all rational beings, then this not only shows that pure reason can be practiced, but also shows that there is only pure reason! Rather than rationality limited by experience, it is unconditionally practiced. " This sentence means that if we prove that the attribute of freedom belongs to human will, then the practical application of pure reason can be confirmed.
The contents of these two paragraphs are basically the same, but Gao slightly revised some expressions in his paper.
In addition, the acknowledgment content in the master's degree thesis is also suspected of plagiarizing the postscript content in the thesis on a large scale.
For example, Tao Tao wrote in the postscript of his master's degree thesis: … I believe that "freedom" does not create life, but gives life meaning. The pursuit of the meaning of life is the reason why I choose ethics major. Choosing "freedom" as the theme of my graduation thesis is my attempt to enter the ethics hall ... I love this thesis as much as Pygmalion loves his statue. Pygmalion can turn the statue into a beloved beauty as long as he asks God for help. And I can finish this article, but I can't do without too much selfless support ... Kant once said, "I give myself a pre-defined track to keep going." I will enter my process, and nothing can stop me from continuing. "He was 22 years old that year.
Gao wrote in his paper: ... I believe that "freedom" is not to create life, but to give life meaning. The pursuit of the meaning of life is the reason why I choose ethics major. Choosing "freedom" as the theme of my graduation thesis is my attempt to enter the ethics hall ... I love this thesis as much as Pygmalion loves his statue. Pygmalion can turn the statue into a beloved beauty as long as he asks God for help. And I can finish this article, but I can't do without too much selfless support ... Kant once said: "I gave myself a pre-defined track to keep going." I will enter my process and nothing can stop me from continuing. " He was 22 years old that year.
According to the above two paragraphs, we can find that the content is almost identical. Even Gao's major is foreign philosophy, and his research direction is the graduate students of German classical philosophy. In the thanks, he also turned the major into "ethics".
The reporter called the office of the School of Philosophy and Graduate School of Hubei University respectively, and the other party said that they would contact the reporter after verifying that the high thesis was suspected of plagiarism.