Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Educational Knowledge - Suffering is not worthy of praise —— Rereading The Ugly Duckling
Suffering is not worthy of praise —— Rereading The Ugly Duckling
? In the process of reviewing the ugly duckling's wandering, the questions of "what" and "how" were set to relieve the nervous brain before, that is, "Who did the ugly duckling meet along the way? How did they treat him? " This is a process of getting children back to the text.

? Happily, a child suggested that two male geese see the ugly duckling and say, "You are ugly and cute, and even I can't help liking you." You should be a migratory bird ... ". Does the goose think the ugly duckling is ugly? Sun Ruyi said that this is actually a kind of sarcasm, a deeper irony. By the way, several children with a wide range of knowledge gave you the concept of "migratory birds".

? Later, when the ugly duckling was taken home by the farmers and the children wanted to play with him, he was scared like a bird and ran around in panic, making the house a mess. When all the ridicule, alienation and satire are put on a person, it is difficult for him or her to distinguish good from evil. Therefore, when the movie "Fanghua" said that "a person who is not treated well in life can best identify kindness and know how to cherish kindness", I doubted its sincerity.

? Of course, the ugly duckling eventually turned into a white swan. But as Andersen said, "It doesn't matter if you were born in a duck farm as long as you have been in a swan egg" (translated by Ye Junjian)?

? How to discuss this sentence? I think the key is how to set the problem. I asked them, "Does the ugly duckling's mother love him?" Some people say that it doesn't matter whether someone else takes swan eggs or not. But if mother swan deliberately lays her eggs in mother duck's nest, then the mother is too irresponsible. Others say that it will be too tired for mother swan to lay a big egg for others to hatch, but mother swan loves him. I asked him, then our mother gave birth to us so hard that she gave us up to someone else, okay? Everyone shook their heads.

? Some people say that Mother Swan loves him, because she has to let her children go through these ridicule and hardships, so that he can become the most beautiful swan.

? Indeed, the ugly duckling became the most beautiful swan. After wandering and being laughed at, he became humble and gentle. But can it be considered that "suffering makes an ugly duckling"? In our consistent education, praising suffering is not only a safe topic, but also a political correctness. Even in the face of some educational problems, they deliberately create "frustration education" and "hardship education", as if children were scared to study hard and dare not understand. This is exactly the same as the popular simple and rude logic-"the country is difficult to prosper."

Obviously, if the ugly duckling feels sad, escapes and feels sorry for himself under the ridicule of others, then he will still become a swan, but that is only a natural attribute. On the contrary, what we want to learn is the idea of "swimming" that he keeps looking for, and the idea of "love" and "flying to them" that he can't explain clearly when he sees other swans.

At the end of the story, the ugly duckling recognized those beautiful animals and felt "unspeakable sadness". "I want to fly to them, to these noble birds! But they will kill me, because I am too ugly to go near them. However, it doesn't matter! Being killed by them is much better than being bitten by a duck, pecked by a chicken, and kicked by a maid who looks after a chicken farm. " . Therefore, it is beauty, the constant pursuit of beauty, not suffering, which makes the ugly duckling.

? If there are other stories, the best is that mother swan is also looking for her children.