The document particularly emphasizes that shelters should adhere to the policy of education, probation and salvation.
Twenty years have passed, has the original intention of setting up a shelter been realized?
20 14 February, when the reporter saw Zhang Qingshi, she was in a small shop in a deep alley. A pink light came on in the shop, and she returned to her original job. For her, the shelter was just a nightmare episode and didn't change her life track.
She said that the shelter didn't make her feel the sunshine and virtue, but only left her the impression that she was "expressionless like a puppet when standing guard, speechless like a fool when sitting in a military posture, and crowded together like an animal when sleeping". On the contrary, she believes that the evil of human nature is magnified because a large number of prostitutes gather together.
Zhang Qing said that most women in this industry are sensitive, inferior and irritable. After entering the shelter, they seem to magnify the evil in human nature. "Good people swallow their voices here, and bad people are in power."
Zhang Qing believes that the main reason for the ineffectiveness of the shelter is the wrong method of discipline. "Why do you manage us by managing prisoners?"
Most of the people in the shelter are low-level sex workers. "Young and beautiful people are rarely put here. They earn more or have connections, so they can go out by themselves. " Zhang Qing said that many people are actually forced into this industry by life.
Zhang Qing used to be a masseur. After divorcing her husband, she went out to work alone, hoping to earn more money for her children and parents. She works 10 hours a day and can get up to 3000 yuan a month. Except for rent and meals, all the money is sent back to my hometown.
Due to years of massage and overwork, her fingers developed rheumatoid arthritis and her knuckles began to deform. Every time she massages someone, she feels distressed. A few years ago, a sister in a massage parlor advised her, "Why don't you help people masturbate?"
It costs 30 yuan to play once, which is equivalent to the money she earned after two hours of massage. After comparison, she chose to enter this business. Gradually, I began to accept more business.
They often rent a small house of 10 square meters in the depths of bungalows or alleys, put up a small sign of "foot bath" or "pedicure" at the door, and light a pink light to turn it on.
They mainly accept migrant workers or the elderly, and the cost ranges from 30 to 70 at a time, "equivalent to two Jin of pork or four Jin of apples".
Many massage women have complete families, and their husbands know about it. "There is no way at home, so I just want to work for a while and build a new house for my family." Sister Lan, who is in her forties, said that after she was taken to the shelter, her husband told her family, "I came in through pyramid schemes."
Some husbands didn't know about it until their wives were caught. After Li Li's husband learned, he just told the child that his mother had lost her mobile phone and could not call home.
When Lili was released from prison, her husband came to pick him up. Li Li asked him, "Do you hate me?" Husband hugged her and began to cry. He knows that his family is in trouble, and his wife will do the job. He only hates himself for being useless.
Zhu Lieyu believes that money prostitution is an "illegal act without direct victims". Under normal circumstances, it will not have a direct and significant impact on others and society, and it will be punished by restricting personal freedom for six months to two years, which is obviously manifested in the excessive supply of punishment, which cannot reflect the equivalence between punishment and behavior.
For example, Zhu Lieyu said that according to the provisions of China's current criminal law, even intentional injury that constitutes a criminal offence, if it only causes minor injuries to others, generally only needs to be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of less than three years, criminal detention or control, but in practice, it is often sentenced to probation.
"Is it true that two immoral men and women use money as a medium to conduct hidden sex transactions, and the social harm will exceed the criminal act of intentionally hurting others' bodies? "