Blind evaluation refers to a system of organizing expert group evaluation, that is, anonymous submission, which means that the evaluation tutor does not know who the author of the paper is. In this way, the false positive rate of scores is low, which is generally used in college marking.
The blind evaluation system is to send dissertations without the author's name to experts who can't know the author for evaluation, so the score should be the most objective. Colleges and universities in general, especially graduate schools, have relevant regulations on blind examination of papers on a regular basis, and most of them randomly select a certain number of papers for blind examination.
Extended data:
Requirements of blind test work
(a) blind reviewers are all borne by peer experts outside the school, and graduate department is responsible for extracting them from the expert database.
(2) In order to ensure the normal work of blind inspection of dissertations, all master students who apply for dissertation defense must submit dissertations 30 days in advance, and doctoral students 45 days in advance (except in winter and summer vacations).
(three) to participate in the blind examination of papers, it is necessary to organize the defense work after the results of the blind examination are determined, and the results of the blind examination should be used as the basis for the qualification of defense and the evaluation of papers.
(four) review papers are generally not returned.
Blind test result processing
(1) The opinions of papers submitted for review are all withdrawn, and the review opinions are valid. If full recovery is not possible, the lost copy must be submitted for review.
(II) Due to special circumstances, if it is not possible to withdraw all the papers submitted in time, graduate department can decide whether to let the graduate students defend their papers first according to the withdrawn evaluation opinions, and then determine the handling opinions of the defense according to the number of empty albums recovered and the evaluation opinions.
(3) If one vote is rejected in the double-blind evaluation of doctoral dissertations, two reviewers will be added for a second interview; If negative opinions appear again, the paper will be judged as unqualified. If two votes are rejected, the paper will be judged unqualified. The master's degree thesis is subject to blind examination and one-vote veto system.
(4) graduate department informed the degree evaluation sub-committee, tutors and graduate students to defend their papers. If the thesis is considered unqualified, the graduate department will inform the graduate students and their tutors to revise the thesis; If the graduate students themselves and their tutors disagree with the results of the blind test, they can fill in the Application Form for Review and apply for a review.
(5) After receiving the Application Form for Review, the Sub-committee on Responsibility Assessment shall organize relevant experts or members of the Sub-committee to comment on the dissertations and blind evaluation opinions that have been blindly rated as unqualified. If you agree with the results of blind evaluation, you should instruct the instructor to guide the graduate students to carefully revise their dissertations within the prescribed time limit. The blind trial fee shall be borne by the tutor or graduate student.
(6) The revision period for the dissertations that fail the blind evaluation shall not exceed two years for doctors and one year for masters. The revised dissertation still needs to participate in double-blind review, and in principle, it will be re-reviewed by the original reviewer. If the paper is rejected again, the author's degree application qualification will be cancelled.
(7) Where the graduate dissertations brought by tutors are blindly rated as unqualified dissertations, they must participate in the next round of double-blind evaluation or appraisal at their own expense, and at the same time increase the proportion of double-blind evaluation in their disciplines.
(eight) if there are two graduate tutors (different sessions)
If there are unqualified dissertations in blind inspection, enrollment will be restricted within two years. If two people in a session are blindly examined as unqualified papers, their tutor qualifications will be cancelled.
(9) If two graduate students in two disciplines are blindly judged as unqualified dissertations, the discipline shall give a warning, rectify and reduce the enrollment plan.
Baidu encyclopedia-blind trial