In Water Margin, Zhang Qinglian beat 15 people to Liangshan, but careful readers found that only 13 people. Is it Shi Naian's own miscalculation? What's going on here? Who are the military commanders who were beaten? Let's talk about how many people Zhang Qing hit through the plot description of the war in Water Margin.
According to the four plots described in the original work, they are as follows:
First, Yan Qing's psychological activities
Yan Qing, who was unprepared for the prodigal son, saw it at the gate of the array and thought: I was beaten by him here in a row 15 generals. ?
Second, Dongchang satrap's psychological activities
The prefect of the city saw Zhang Qing hit a fifteen-member general at the water margin. Although King Gong and Ding Desun both lost, he also won this Liu Tang.
Third, Song Jiang's speech.
Song Jiang, Lu Junyi and Wu Yong said again:? It is said that King Liang of the Five Dynasties did not move in Sun, and even beat General Tang of 36. Today, Zhang Qing didn't have time, and even hit me with a general of 15. Although he is not under this person, he should be a valiant soldier! ?
Fourth, hymns:
Zhang Qingshen's hand closes the sky, and then he can climb rocks in the dark. Fifteen people were damaged and limped to Liangshan.
Of the above four descriptions, there are two explicitly mentioned times, right? Zhang Qing in this battle? Even hit 15 people, as in Yan Qing? Movie time? With sung river? Have no time today? And ... and ... The sun stopped moving? . After we confirm that we hit fifteen people in a row, we have to count which fifteen people we hit.
0 1, Xu Ning, Golden Gunner-Prince turned over and dismounted at dawn.
02, Kim Hu Mao-Yan Shun-punched boring armor goggles, clanged and left.
03. delicious! Hit Han Tao in the nose. I saw blood flowing in parallel and fled back to this array.
04, Tianmu meeting Peng Qi-put your hand in the middle of Peng Qi's cheek. I lost my three-pointed double-edged knife and ran back to the array.
05, ugly county Ma Xuanzan-in the middle of Xuanzan's mouth, turn over and fall.
06, Shuang Bian Huyanzhuo-When he saw a stone flying, he whipped it every once in a while, but the stone hit his wrist. If he had waited a little earlier, he would not have been able to move Strafe back to this array.
07. Liu Tang, the red-haired ghost, Liu Tang, was scanning the other side of the door with a ponytail, and his eyes were full of flowers. He was knocked down by Zhang Qing with only one stone.
08. Yang Zhi, a green-faced beast, hit his helmet with a bang. Yang Zhidan was terrified out of her wits and fell headlong into the saddle.
Lei Heng, a tiger with wings-I looked up and got a stone on my forehead.
10, bearded man Zhu Tong-another stone hit his neck.
1 1, Guan Sheng, broadsword-I quickly cut the knife, and it was hitting the blade, and it was blazing. Guan Sheng speeding, back.
12, double guns graze Dong Ping-the stone on his ear. Dong Ping came back later.
13, depth charge Suochao-get out of the way, hit the face, bleed profusely, and return to the array with an axe.
Count, hey, how can it be 13 people? Are Yan Qing, Sung River, Satrap and Master Shi all wrong?
The teacher taught us to say. Read it carefully? In fact, the answer lies in a key word. Fight? Even? Fight? Fifteen generals. ? Fight? I guess you can say that? War? 、? Fight? Instead of. Hurt? 、? Hurt? 、? Stoned? . At this point, even hitting 15 generals can be interpreted as hitting 15 generals.
Then let's see, besides the 13 people mentioned above, who else appeared in this battle?
1, Xu Ning fell, Gong Wang and Ding Desun came to arrest people, and Guo Sheng came out to save people.
2, Dong Ping, SuoChao and ZQQ, Gong Wang, Ding Desun scuffle, and Lv Fang, Guo Sheng, Lin Chong, Huarong Road.
But if you count Lv Fang, Guo Sheng, Lin Chong and Huarong Road, then there are seventeen people and two more, and there is still no solution.
Look at the contribution of these four people. Lin Chong and Hua Rong captured Gong Wang, while Lv Fang and Guo Sheng captured Ding Desun. So, does this mean that these four people did not directly fight with ZQQ? Let's look at the battle description again:? Four generals, Lin Chong, Hua Rong, Lv Fang and Guo Sheng, each made two spears and two halberds, struggling to save Dong Ping and Suochao. ZQQ saw that it was not the head, abandoned Dong Ping and ran into the array. ?
At this point, it can be seen that these four people have a division of labor. According to the description order, Lin Chong and Hua Rong should save Dong Ping, and Lv Fang and Guo Sheng should save Suochao. In the first three paragraphs, it is known that Ding Desun and Gong Wang fought against Suochao:
1, Suo Chao saw it in Songjiang array and turned his axe to come to the rescue. Facing the Duke Wang and Ding Desun, they rode out together and stopped Suo Chao.
2, SuoChao, Gong Wang, Ding De Sun San horse, get into a ball.
3. Suo Chao left Gong Wang and Ding Desun behind and rushed into the battle.
Well, obviously, Lv Fang and Guo Sheng saved Suochao, so they can't compete with Zhang Qing. Only Lin Chong and Hua Rong can assist Dong Ping in this game. This is another proof, which is described in the original text? ZQQ saw that it was not the head, abandoned Dong Ping, and raced into the array? . At this time, Lv Fang and Guo Sheng stopped Gong Wang and Ding Desun, so it was Lin Chong and Huarong Road who came to save Dong Ping. With Lin Chong and Huarong Road, isn't it just a fifteen-member general?
However, I know some friends will still ask questions. Didn't you write that Zhang Qing wounded Lin Chong and Huarong Road?
A: Guan Sheng (bumped into a knife), Yan Shun (bumped into goggles), Yang Zhi (bumped into a helmet) and Dong Ping (walked by with his neck stuck) were not injured.
Q: How did Lin Chong and Huarong Road get such a big impact?
A: Guan Sheng is not weak either. Of course, I personally infer that perhaps Master Shi didn't write the scene of their struggle with ZQQ separately in order to preserve the glorious image of Lin Chong and Hua Rongdao.