After watching Dead Poets Society, I saw Dead Poets Society on the New Year's Eve and thought it was a very good movie, which was worth seeing. But I don't understand why this film is widely recommended to front-line teachers as an educational film. Are you learning from Mr. Keating? Teacher Keating's teaching method is really novel and worth learning, but he used good teaching methods and taught inappropriate subjects and inappropriate objects.
Frankly speaking, Mr. Keating should be responsible for the tragic ending of the film. Teacher Keating should be a successful teacher if he teaches some courses on performing arts or how to write, but his students will go to Yale and Harvard, and they will become the future social elites of dentists or lawyers. For these students, this obvious enthusiasm is dangerous.
Will Lu Xun be mentioned here again? Dark room? Proposition, isn't it more cruel for people who stay in darkrooms to wake up and can't open them? Lu Xun did not give an answer to this, perhaps this is a difficult problem that everyone can't guess. Similarly, Lu Xun is also very opposed to young students marching in the streets to avoid being used as cannon fodder by some forces. I agree with that. Sometimes the truth seems unreasonable, but it is actually correct.
What does Mr. Keating play? Wake up? Such a role, but when his students were expelled, committed suicide, and even later he was expelled, he could do nothing but watch the tragedy happen. Finally stand on the table and yell? My captain! ? Dear students, the result will also be fired, if this must be the case in real life.
I think Mr. Keating succeeded in inspiring students' passion, but he didn't tell them how to control it. For these young students, perhaps it is more important to control their passion and let it work within a reasonable and legal scope.
Reflection on Dead Poets Society II. Dead Poets Society's reaction occurred in Vermont in the middle of last century? Wilton Preparatory College? One of them? A bloody collision between traditional education and anti-traditional education? Events. The first half of this educational film is full of comedy elements and the second half is full of tragedy. The screenplay is based on the author Thomas? Schumann is in Montgomery? Based on the real experience of Bell College, a preparatory school for boys in Nashville, Tennessee.
The film kicked off at the festive opening ceremony. As a preparatory school with a glorious tradition, Wilton Preparatory College has welcomed another batch? Raw materials for college students? Fortunately, it also won the favor of Mr. Keating, who has a brand-new educational concept.
This school with a good enrollment rate was decided at the beginning? Conservative tradition? What is even more frightening is that the students who have been poisoned by cramming education for many years have willingly become its slaves! Countless students gave in to the current educational model, gave up the subjective initiative of thinking, and finally threw all the rights to ask questions into the trash can! Are you willing to limit your vision to textbooks for the so-called scores? An acre of land is divided into three parts? In fact, although they can see the beautiful sky when they leave the classroom, they prefer to observe other people's leftovers in illustrations? Good idea? .
We can't deny that there are some contents in standard textbooks that can stand the test of time, but knowledge is an abstract thinking, and it is not just a poor and unique expression! In Mr. Keating's first class, he explained this idea perfectly to get rid of students' doubts about? Authoritative textbook content? Afraid of superstition, he asked the students to tear up the preface.
This is a great progress. This kind of behavior will force these poor people first? Robots? Saved from the shallow well of the textbook. Even if this goes against the general environment of the school and even the whole society, why do the right things always hide?
Invite students to the podium and understand the problem from a lofty perspective. Temptation? They set up a club of ancient poets, purified their confused hearts with the most beautiful and unpretentious words, and encouraged Nell, who obeyed his father in everything, to be himself for his actor's dream. Men who focus on their dreams are the cutest.
Finally, Mr. Keating's efforts were richly rewarded. A flash of lightning flashed in the dim eyes of his class, fighting for himself and his inner dreams! Education should not be rigid, otherwise, what is the difference between it and the automobile company that carries out assembly line operation?
If education only teaches students exams, then I have reason to believe that this is another one? Eight-part essay seals the heart, and the imperial examination takes the scholar? The age of confusion; Wouldn't it be a great sorrow if our students only learn to take exams in class and forget the importance of thinking and discussion?
Resist adversity and face the enemy with fearless momentum;
Most people live in quiet despair. Don't fall into this situation and rush out. Don't run away like a mouse, look around and dare to open up your own world;
You must try to find your own voice, because the later you start looking, the less likely you are to find it;
Once you think you understand, you must look at it from another angle. This may seem absurd or stupid, but it must be tried. When reading the same book, don't just think about what the author thinks, think about what you think;
Truth is like a blanket that always makes your feet cold/No matter how hard you pull it, it will never be enough/No matter whether you kick it or kick it, it will never cover us/From our crying birth/until our death/It will only cover your face/No matter how painful you are/No matter how painful you are/How screaming.
These original and philosophical words, I believe you can't find them in textbooks. Because the exam content of exam-oriented education does not include these. But Mr. Keating did it. What he values is not exams, but education, real education. He instilled these truths and ideas into students in class, without a trace of utilitarian thoughts. I think in our future education, we should also actively guide students to master this simplest and most valuable truth, so that education can really pay equal attention to intellectual education and moral education.
Just like a revolution, the person who stands up first will always be shot. The school leaders did not tolerate Mr. Keating's educational philosophy, and they forced him to leave his education post with Nell's death. Strictly speaking, Nell's death is the victim of the collision between old and new educational concepts. Nell's parents accepted this staid cramming education, and they took it for granted that Nell would go in the future. How cruel it is!
When you struggle all the way, at the last moment, you find that the direction you have been working hard has deviated from the ideal route, so in the last days, you will definitely regret it and be helpless. As educators, we have an obligation to avoid this situation. Let's open our minds and guide students to explore by themselves with an open teaching concept. Muse? Ok, let education really play a role in promoting the all-round development of students' morality, intelligence, physique, beauty and labor!
Finally, let's drink to Mr. Keating. Virtual educator? Pay tribute to those who have made great efforts for effective education!
Post-reading column seriously recommended:
I recommend it carefully.