The preliminary examination of editors needs to make a preliminary judgment on the quality and academic value from five aspects: whether it is combined with the purpose and orientation of publishing publications, whether it has the basic elements of academic papers (including the format requirements of publications for papers, the standard format of references in Chinese and English papers, font layout, etc. ), whether it meets the publishing standards of academic papers, whether it is plagiarized, whether it has published similar research, and write preliminary opinions, and put forward opinions on whether to recommend publication or submission.

Because the manuscript is comprehensive and involves many disciplines, it must be reviewed by experts. Hiring experts for external audit is the key to ensure the academic quality of periodicals. Expert external audit can make an overall evaluation of the advanced, academic, scientific and practical nature of the manuscript, put forward guiding and specific opinions on the revision of the manuscript, and show a clear attitude towards whether the manuscript can be published.

The editor-in-chief is the last link of the third trial, and is generally responsible for the editor-in-chief or deputy editor-in-chief. The editor-in-chief will conduct spot checks or check manuscripts according to the opinions of experts.