Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Graduation thesis - Excellent examples of scientific research project instructors' comments
Excellent examples of scientific research project instructors' comments
The comments of scientific research project instructors are the external reflection and performance of the overall scientific research work. This paper expounds the significance of the evaluation of teachers' educational scientific research papers in higher vocational colleges, and expounds the necessity of the evaluation of scientific research papers in higher vocational colleges. The following are the comments of scientific research project instructors. Please refer to them.

Evaluation of teaching and research section;

1、

_ _ Students actively demand progress and actively study the policies and lines of the CPC Central Committee from the beginning of their enrollment. In the study of specialized courses, I have carefully studied relevant books inside and outside the class, mastered solid basic theoretical knowledge and systematic professional knowledge of this subject, and have strong scientific research ability, innovation ability and practical ability, and successfully completed my master's thesis. In daily life, I am kind and enthusiastic, have a harmonious relationship with my classmates, and actively participate in various group activities. I hope that in my future work and study, I will continue to maintain and carry forward my fine style, work hard and strive for greater achievements. ?

2、

_ _ Since entering the school, students have made progress in thinking, high awareness of party spirit, United with their classmates, studied hard, achieved excellent results and actively participated in college activities. High level of professional knowledge, solid professional theoretical foundation, and strong innovation and practical ability in curriculum practice. In terms of scientific research, the student participated in many scientific research projects, and wrote papers 1 article during his postgraduate period, with a high level of scientific research.

Tutor's opinion: 1. This student has a solid theoretical foundation and rich practical ability. He is earnest and practical, sincere and trustworthy, and has the spirit of unity, cooperation and hard work. Excellent foreign language proficiency and solid professional English reading and writing skills. It is suitable for scientific research and has greater hopes for scientific research ability.

2、

In the postgraduate study stage, the student is diligent in study, earnest and practical, with solid basic theoretical knowledge, in-depth research to find new solutions, and has the ability to engage in scientific research and strong business ability. Good English, with the requirements of working in government, institutions and enterprises.

Opinions of the on-site supervisor of the approval document:

According to the training requirements of his own research direction, the student has systematically studied relevant theoretical courses, and has a certain professional theoretical level and investigation and research ability, and a good foreign language level. In this paper, the security strategy of file output in SAP system based on filter driver is studied. The topic is novel, the thinking is clear, the basic content is informative, the questions can be raised according to the investigation, the analysis of the problems is in-depth, the solutions are feasible, and it has certain application value and reference value, which basically reflects the proficiency of the students in professional knowledge and research methods. To sum up, the student has reached the level of master's degree thesis.

Opinions of school teachers:

Students have solid professional theoretical knowledge, broad vision and certain investigation and research ability. Participate in the development of several scientific research projects, with strong professional ability and good foreign language level. In this paper, the file output security strategy of SAP system is selected as the subject, and the file output security strategy of SAP system is studied in a filter-driven way. The problem analysis is in-depth and the solution is in line with the reality. To sum up, the student has reached the level of master's degree thesis.

Mid-term evaluation:

_ _ Since they entered school, students have actively demanded ideological progress, actively moved closer to Party organizations and studied the Party's basic line. In the study of specialized courses, I have carefully studied relevant books inside and outside the class, mastered solid basic theoretical knowledge and systematic professional knowledge of this subject, and have strong scientific research ability and innovation ability. Participated in a number of scientific research projects and professional practice study, with rich scientific research and practical experience, strong ability to integrate theory with practice, and completed the training plan requirements.

Comprehensive practical activities (including research-based learning, community service and social practice) have different descriptions and evaluations due to different organizational units, activity locations, activities contents, activities time and methods, as well as different activities experiences, psychological experiences and achievements of participants (students). Ask the teacher to analyze and integrate according to the specific situation.

First, the evaluation of research-based learning

Project supervisor's opinion 1:

From topic selection, topic opening, implementation, research to the conclusion of the topic, this group of students actively participate in the research activities of the topic, and can feedback their own activities and keep in touch with the instructor in time. Under the leadership of _ _ _ students, the members of this group can cooperate well, basically achieving the research purpose and achieving good research results.

As the students said, research-based learning pays attention to active participation and input in the learning process, from which learning ability, research ability and innovation ability are cultivated. I am glad to see that the students in our group can get such conclusions and opinions, and hope to make persistent efforts in the follow-up study and achieve greater results. Preliminary evaluation: excellent

Opinion of Project Supervisor 2:

During the implementation of the research project, members of the project team can make full use of various research methods, such as finding information, interviewing experts, experiments, etc., and actively organize and participate in social publicity activities. It embodies the spirit of diligent thinking, hard work, unity and cooperation, rigorous academic attitude, and embodies its own innovation ability. In the results report, team members can make full use of multimedia courseware, demonstration experiments and other means to make the report clear, rigorous and innovative. Reflected their good qualities.

Because it is the first time to participate in research-based learning activities and the team members are inexperienced, there are some shortcomings in the whole process. For example, some problems are not considered comprehensively and carefully, and they lack self-confidence in doing things. I hope I can foster strengths and avoid weaknesses in my future study and make continuous progress!

Preliminary evaluation: excellent

Opinions of Project Supervisor 3:

The research group has clear topics and clear goals. In the process of implementation, we have also actively done a lot of practical things, experienced the basic process of research-based learning, and achieved initial results. The research plan of the research group is more detailed, and the division of labor and cooperation have been achieved, and the research tasks have been basically completed. Because the consciousness and initiative of the team members are not strong enough, they take action after repeated urging and conversation. In the stage of refining and summarizing the results, it is still difficult to improve after many times of supervision and guidance, and the quality of the results research is not high enough.

Preliminary opinion: qualified

The latest comment of scientific research project supervisor is 1. The research goal is accurate, and the research content conforms to the present situation of English learning of secondary vocational school students. At the beginning of the study, the research group conducted a questionnaire survey on students' cognition, attitude, motivation and habits of learning English, and obtained the original data of the study, which improved the pertinence of the study and the effectiveness of solving problems.

2. In the research process, the research group paid attention to theoretical study, dabbled in a variety of educational theory books, made clear the theoretical support and carried out empirical research. Through interviews and classroom observation, the main factors and related factors of vocational high school students' English learning disabilities are preliminarily mastered. In view of these problems, various strategies of classroom teaching reform are explored and implemented, and the effect of strategy application is tested in the study, so as to gradually improve classroom teaching efficiency.

3. The research group carefully planned the research process, often exchanged learning, collided with thinking and accumulated results. Researchers have participated in many research classes inside and outside the school, and have been well received by relevant experts. They have written a number of valuable teaching papers and teaching case studies, and won many awards, which has promoted teachers to be under the guidance of theory.

4. An important research topic in the field of _ _ _ _. The characteristics of the applicant's intention to benefit are meaningful topics. The applicant has a certain research foundation and a certain understanding of related fields. However, the research content of the application is only general, the goal is unclear, and the research scheme does not show novelty. It is suggested that the applicant continue to seriously consider this topic and write an application with more specific and clear work objectives.

5. This project intends to take _ _ _ _ as the research object and explore the possible application of _ _ _ _. This project also intends to study the impact of _ _ _ _. The research content of this project is specific, and the research on _ _ _ _ is innovative. Judging from the preliminary work, the author has a certain research foundation. But the applicant's annual plan is not done well. For example, the applicant plans to spend one year on research, which means that the applicant has no specific and feasible plans to conduct research in this area.

6. The applicant intends to realize the function of _ _ _ based on the function of _ _ _. The research content focuses on the combination of two existing studies, _ _ _ _. Although it has its own characteristics, innovation is not sufficient. The overall research plan is good, which has certain research foundation and conditions for professional growth and classroom teaching level improvement.

Comments of scientific research project supervisor: 1. This topic has strong practical value. This topic aims to solve the practical problems that hinder the development of autonomous management ability. It is of great practical significance to study the cultivation of students' autonomous ability by firmly grasping the way of class collective construction, which is of great practical significance for creating a new moral education model to improve students' autonomous ability under the background of educational reform.

Two, the organization and management of research work is solid and effective. The research group has a reasonable organizational structure, can seriously organize and carry out various training activities, and make overall planning and coordination guidance in combination with the actual situation of our school. It is as standardized and scientific as possible from the proposal of the subject, the formulation of the research plan, the organization and implementation of the research, and the summary and promotion of the research results.

Third, the research method of the subject is appropriate, scientific and operable. This topic mainly adopts the method of educational action research, follows the idea of guiding teachers' practice while studying, and focuses on solving specific problems in educational practice, improving educators' educational behavior and improving educational wisdom. The research of this topic has strong effectiveness and certain innovation.

Fourth, the subject information is comprehensive, detailed and rich. In the process of research, we pay attention to collecting and sorting out all kinds of materials, and record them in various forms such as words, photos and videos, which truly reflects the process and trajectory of the research, is conducive to further reflection and promotion of researchers, and provides practical practices and experiences for similar research.

5. This topic studies and constructs the SOP student training target system, forms the "Growth Trilogy" moral education course, establishes the moral education mechanism of class self-management, carries out the monthly theme education activity of "I grow up with _ _ * * * *", constructs a relatively perfect "_ star" multiple evaluation mechanism, refines the small strategy of "improving the collective construction of primary school students' autonomous ability", and effectively promotes students' autonomous learning.

Teacher's comment template for scientific research projects 1. The application project comes from _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. Draw lessons from _ _ _ _ _ such as _ _. There are _ _ _ contents, _ _ topics and _ _ topics in the application. The content is complex, and the connection transformation between these contents lacks logical comments, which is suspected of simple accumulation. Causing the disconnection between theory and practice. The overall layout of the research scheme proposed in this application project is unreasonable. Although the research group has some experience and foundation in the previous research work, the applicant did not deeply analyze the key technical difficulties when constructing the theoretical model.

2. This project is based on _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Applicants and project team members have a certain foundation of preliminary work, and can complete the application project and achieve the expected results. The researchers are reasonably matched, have the basic conditions needed for research, and the budget is basically reasonable. Therefore, it is recommended to give funding.

3. The innovation of research content in application is not outstanding enough, and its contribution to the whole project content research field is limited.

4. The applicant's preliminary research results related to this project are relatively weak.

5. The description of domestic and foreign research is scattered, which shows that the author has not mastered the research status of this research field well.

Comments on communication review:

Evaluation opinion 1:

On _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Have the foundation to complete this project, meet the funding conditions, and recommend funding. However, in the papers published before, most of the applicants are participants, and there are few papers by the first author or correspondent.

Comment 2:

1. This project intends to realize the new mechanism of _ _ _ _ and provide a new model for _ _ _ _. It has good innovation and important scientific significance.

2. This project is based on _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _, and the research content and overall research scheme are good.

3. The project book and previous research show that the applicant has strong innovation potential and innovative thinking, and the project budget is reasonable, so it is recommended to give priority to funding.

Comment 3:

This project intends to combine the advantages of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

The case is basically feasible and the funds can be considered. But this work lacks a reasonable explanation based on _ _ _ _ _ _ _.

Comments of scientific research project supervisor 1 This research is going to pass ..... This research topic has theoretical value, and the scheme and technical route are basically reasonable and feasible. The author has experience and achievements in developing this group of animal systematics. It is beneficial to finish this research project. Can be funded. However, the content of the study is somewhat unclear.

2. This project will be carried out. This topic is novel, the research route is feasible, the research goal is clear and the research content is reasonable. In addition, the applicant has a good research foundation and a certain research foundation in molecular systematics. If funded, he can finish all the work well. Agree to fund.

The research content and objectives of the application are not clear enough. "International cooperation" is a common way in scientific research, and it is obviously inappropriate for the applicant to regard it as one of the two characteristics and innovations of the project. It is recommended to suspend funding.

IV ... This project is of great scientific significance and good innovation. The research content of the project is appropriate, the key scientific problems to be solved are accurately grasped, and the research technical scheme adopted is advanced and reasonable. However, the research strength of the project applicant cannot be judged from the materials given in the application, and the foundation of the preliminary research work of the project is relatively thin. Considering that innovation is worth encouraging, it is recommended to give funding.

5 ... The research is exploratory, the research content is reasonable, the research goal is clear, the scheme design is reasonable and feasible, and there is a certain foundation for preliminary work. Generally speaking, the application is innovative. Suggest funding.

6 ... Therefore, this project has certain scientific significance and application prospect. However, the project lacks innovation and some new ideas. "

Research project tutor comments on excellent examples related articles:

★ Excellent examples of scientific research project instructors' comments

★ Comments by the instructor at the beginning of the paper

★ Examples of tutors' comments on interns (2)

★ Comments from the practice instructor

★ Instruct teachers to make academic comments on papers.

★ Comments on Tutor's Papers

★ Comments of our school's instructors

★ Tutor's comments on the paper

★ Comments by the Thesis Tutor in Colleges and Universities

★ Practice report guidance teacher's opinion