Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Graduation thesis - The paper was rejected. What do you mean, it is suggested to transfer to other journals?
The paper was rejected. What do you mean, it is suggested to transfer to other journals?
For some reason, the editor thinks that your manuscript is more suitable for publication in other journals of the publishing house. As for what causes the switching of editorial suggestions, different publishers and periodicals have different requirements, so it is impossible to generalize.

This situation is mostly because the content of the paper does not conform to the direction of periodical reception, or the quality of the content of the paper is poor. If it is a core journal, the rejection is normal, and it is impossible to vote in all aspects. You should find out the reason calmly and don't lose heart. This does not mean that your article is rejected, but only that your article does not conform to this journal. Just re-evaluate your article and then find a suitable journal to contribute.

Reasons for refusal.

There are many reasons for refusing. Everyone's thesis has different problems, and the reasons for rejection are different. The reasons for refusal can be roughly divided into the following categories:

1, the quality of the paper is not up to standard.

The content of the article is empty, there is no innovation, lack of practice and experience, high repetition rate with others, too many mistakes in the article and so on. In short, the quality of the article is not good

If there is a value for revision, the editorial department will generally give suggestions for revision. After revision, it can be sent to the editorial department and may be hired. If the article is really bad and the editorial department just refuses and says nothing, then you should consider whether the article has the value of re-submission and whether to write it again.

2. The research direction of the paper is inconsistent with the journal.

The theme of the paper is inconsistent with the purpose of running a journal, and the difference is too far. For example, if you write a paper on primary education and publish it in a middle school education journal, the result will definitely be rejected. It is suggested that the author find the corresponding journals in advance and don't blindly contribute.

3. Papers involve sensitive topics, so journals dare not be rented easily.

Let's not talk about any sensitive topics here. If the paper involves sensitive topics, some journals dare to use it, and some journals dare not publish it out of safety or their own position.

4. More than one manuscript of the paper is submitted or infringed.

This is a taboo in academic circles. If the paper has been published in other journals or media before, once it is found that the rejection is light, it will be criticized and dismissed. Also, if the paper embezzles other people's achievements and involves infringement, the consequences will be as serious as being discovered.

5. There is an error in reviewing the manuscript.

It is also possible. The editor gave you a refusal because of lack of professional knowledge or expert's prejudice. At this time, you must argue with the editorial department and insist that you are right.

Editors and experts may not be completely correct, especially those involved in unknown fields. If it passes the audit, it can smoothly enter the next audit procedure. However, this situation is relatively rare, and experts are still cautious in judging papers in unknown fields.

6. There is something wrong with the paper data.

If the information is incomplete or defective and rejected, such a paper might as well be put aside first, and then revised and submitted after the information is fully prepared.

7. Innovation is not important enough.

It may be that journals have higher grades and higher requirements, so you can modify your papers and switch to journals with lower impact factors.

8. The paper is unclear and confusing.

This situation is often caused by the author's lack of writing skills. There may be nothing wrong with the author's experiment and conclusion, but the expression is so upside down that people can't understand it at a glance, or the concept of expression is unclear. Such an article is difficult to modify by yourself. After all, it's horizontally there. You can ask your tutor, brothers and sisters or professional paper institutions to help you rearrange and write your papers.