Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Graduation thesis - Who has higher military capability, Su Yu or Zhang Lingpu?
Who has higher military capability, Su Yu or Zhang Lingpu?
Zhang has no generals. Military strategists have long said that the terrain is the best. Poor Zhang didn't even think about it, trying to rely on it as a place to protect him, trying to lure TG with himself as bait. But in fact? Meng Lianggu's geology and landforms are steep, shaped like a bowl, on which nothing grows. To put it bluntly, it is a bare stone mountain. This kind of rocky mountain is full of big stones, and ordinary individual tools can't build fortifications; "It looks like a bowl", and even there are few gullies that can cover the hidden. You made it very clear that the 74th Division basically has no decent fortifications in Meng Lianggu, so it only has steep terrain, which is difficult to defend but difficult to attack.

Another well-known reason is that there was water on Meng Lianggu Mountain, but it dried up ahead of schedule that year, so the water was cut off. Zhang's American-made equipment is mainly a water-cooled Mark heavy machine gun, which is powerful but often needs water injection to cool it. Therefore, in the case of water shortage, good equipment has actually been unable to carry it.

Finally, although Meng Lianggu looks easy to defend but difficult to attack, there are few places where people can stand in a line, and people are crowded into a pile. After being bombarded by TG, TG basically doesn't even need to aim.

Some people say that General Zhang is unlucky, and I always feel that he seems to be flattered. Throughout the ages, the strategist's first priority has always been to set up camp and deploy, and he just paid no attention to these details at all.

As for the most important point, I even doubt whether he wants to die or not. It can be clearly seen from the battle map at that time that the only rear road in Meng Lianggu was Duozhuang. Zhang stayed in Duozhuang, with a regiment and three battalions under his command. 1 Battalion and Battalion 2 are both material battalions, and only Battalion 3 has several companies. Therefore, General Zhang did not send heavy troops to defend such a major grain and grass position and retreated. Even if Su Yu took Duozhuang, it lost a lot of ammunition, and even the rear roads were blocked. He is a turtle in a jar, and General Zhang is something.

Compared with ordinary Su Yu, the favorite thing to do is to look at the map. The long-term traveling war has made General Su Yu know and pay more attention to the terrain than Zhang, a gifted scholar of Peking University who only knows how to fight with new weapons and equipment. The experience of guerrilla warfare in the south of the Yangtze River made Su Yu know the importance of being good at using terrain, while General Zhang thought that he had advanced equipment and superior geographical position. He will persist for three days and defeat * * *, which is a sign of arrogance. Facts have proved that this is entirely his personal wishful thinking.

In addition, more importantly, Zhang completely disrupted the deployment of the national army at that time, and advocated it without authorization, completely disrupting the strategic intentions of all other troops. Finally, with Meng Lianggu as the core, the strategy was adjusted, forcing the overall plan to change. The national army is 400,000 people, not four, so it is so good. Three days? If it weren't for rescue such as fire fighting, it wouldn't have been coordinated for 30 days. It's great to take advantage of yourself, but does he have the capital to achieve this strategic intention?