Professor Sun Jiazhou's practice is obviously inappropriate. Since you are a teacher, you should do your duty; If students don't need teaching or even discipline, why should they learn from teachers? This student can be admitted to a graduate student of the National People's Congress from a provincial college, and he has feelings after studying. Although his words are sharp, it can still be seen that he had the ambition to pursue knowledge when he was young. More importantly, he was not contaminated with the sophistication, smoothness and shrewdness that young people are more likely to have now. If Mr. Sun is more patient and meticulous, he may be able to cultivate a talent; If "no common goal, no common goal" (to quote Mr. Sun), Mr. Sun can also go to the college and quietly ask the official to change a tutor for the students. There is really no need to "publicly publish a dear John letter." After all, these stupid words of young people are just talking in their own WeChat circle of friends. Nowadays, it has caused a lot of trouble in the city. Not only is the young man's future in school worrying, but all the onlookers can't help feeling insecure!
But what moved me the most was talking to this silly young man.
Hao Xianghe, your behavior reminds me of Dostoevsky's novel brothers karamazov. This is a tragedy of patricide. Old Carla Matsov, the father in the novel, really deserved to die. He is described by the author as a representative of the old and decadent Russian lifestyle. He is selfish, has no morality and responsibility, and leads a dissolute and shameless life. The hatred for his sons, who were deeply hurt, secretly and inevitably developed into patricide and was finally put into practice. However, the author reveals a shocking theme to us: it is through patricide that the sons of patricide show that they are tragically continuing the essential connotation of their father's lifestyle! Only the youngest son, Aletha, with firm faith, finally forgave his father and got rid of the crime of patricide. Dostoevsky tells us that Aletha's action is the only way in the era of out of the dark.
Hao Xianghe, I think neither Professor Sun Jiazhou nor Mr. Yan Buke will deny that there are some chronic diseases in China. Or completely ignore, blindly optimistic; Or jump and fight the waves; Still look up to "the rules and dignity of the academic circle" (to quote Teacher Sun) ... Obviously, these can't change the status quo. However, what should arouse our vigilance is your attitude. Whether your criticism or ridicule is appropriate or not, when you do this, according to the logic revealed by Dostoevsky in brothers karamazov, you are also continuing this order, and it is the most dangerous way to continue. Because, in your heart or think you want to change, you want to "revolution" and surpass it; When you are full of worries and praises, you unconsciously put yourself in the position of an impartial judge. But can you really tell from this order? If you have a chance to graduate from the history department of Peking University, will you really give up this opportunity? If you were mediocre, but you had a chance to get an academic position like Professor Yan Buke's, would you refuse? If your thesis (for example, your doctoral thesis) is not up to the level of Mr. Li Ping's "The Times of Pingcheng in the Northern Wei Dynasty", but it can be published and even have a chance to win an award, can you really refuse it?
I believe you probably can't do it. Of course, neither can i. There are still many people who can't do it. Therefore, in fact, when we "talk wildly" and call others "mediocre" and "rubbish", we are showing our "mediocrity", which shows that we are also stepping into various "rubbish departments".
Hao Xianghe, I want to tell you-Dostoevsky has told us in brothers karamazov that our only correct choice is not to kill our father, not to be our enemy and not to judge our father, just like Alexa. What really makes sense is to completely distinguish our way of life from our father. High leads a different life.
It is in this sense that I want to say to you, Mr. Hao Xianghe-we must first let ourselves step down from the position of judge and not judge anyone. As students, we should respect your tutor unconditionally. We have no right to attack your tutor. As students, we shouldn't attack other scholars with words like "traitor", whether he is our teacher or not.
It is in this sense that I want to say to you, Mr. Hao Xianghe-we should live as a modern citizen in a clear relationship of equal rights and obligations; We should not only know our rights, but also fulfill our obligations. Especially in today's society where humanistic construction is still difficult, as intellectuals, we should do our part; A university is a university, and it is necessary to truly show the spirit of the university.
It is in this sense that I want to say to Mr. Hao Xianghe-the most important thing is that in our study, research and academic activities, we should act in a way that we think is really correct. This is the real meaningful change.
Hao Xianghe, I want to tell you-we should re-establish a new relationship between teachers and students in this ethical relationship. As students, we should respect our tutors and have no right to attack them. Because "respecting teachers" is often associated with "emphasizing morality". It is not because the tutor is worthy of respect, but because of "attention" that we unconditionally "respect the teacher".
In any case, when we start from ourselves, we have the confidence to face the future.