Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Graduation thesis - How to write the defense team's comments?
How to write the defense team's comments?
Question 1: How to write the opinions of the thesis defense group with a good level of thesis evaluation? How to choose a topic for the bachelor's degree thesis "XXXXXXX" written by XXX? The writing format of the thesis basically meets the requirements of our school's graduation thesis specification. First, make a general introduction to the main points, basic ideas, innovations and shortcomings of the thesis during the defense: (whether the introduction is comprehensive and accurate, how to organize it, and whether the timing is appropriate). Second, students return. ...

Question 2: Will the comments of the graduation thesis defense team be written into the file? What is the topic of the bachelor's degree thesis "XXXXXXX" written by XXX? The writing format of the thesis basically meets the requirements of our school's graduation thesis specification. First, make a general introduction to the main points, basic ideas, innovations and shortcomings of the thesis during the defense: (whether the introduction is comprehensive and accurate, how to organize it, and whether the timing is appropriate). Second, students return.

Question 3: How to write the comments of the graduation thesis defense group? What are the specific topics and requirements?

Question 4: How to fill in the teacher's comments in the graduation thesis defense qualification examination form? Students have a good grasp of the experimental contents and methods. Under the guidance of the tutor, I basically completed the whole graduation experiment research process independently, and I can skillfully consult the literature related to the research content. In the course of the experiment, we bravely faced the complicated testing process and finally completed the whole experiment well. When writing a paper, the topic of the paper has practical significance, the experimental scheme is feasible, the data processing is credible, the analysis is clear, and its conclusion has certain reference value. The writing format of graduation thesis is standardized, the unit is unified and the writing standard is moderate. It shows that the student has the basic theoretical knowledge and experimental research skills of this major and is eligible to participate in the graduation defense.

Question 5: how to write the opinions of the defense Committee after the thesis defense? Cales' thesis topic conforms to the professional training goal and can achieve the comprehensive training goal. The topic is difficult and the workload is heavy. The topic selection has academic reference value. The student has a strong ability to consult documents and materials, and can comprehensively collect personal financial information of commercial banks. In the process of writing, I can comprehensively apply what I have learned, comprehensively analyze personal financial problems, and have a strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge. The length of the article fully meets the requirements of the college, the content is relatively complete, the hierarchical structure is scientific, the main points are prominent, and the logical relationship is clear, but it lacks personal opinions. The topic is consistent, the argument is prominent, and the discussion is closely related to the theme. The language expression is fluent, and the format fully meets the requirements of the specification; It refers to a wealth of literature and has strong timeliness.

Question 6: How to write the main questions raised by the group and the main suggestions for revision before the defense? English titles mainly appear in the form of phrases, especially noun phrases, that is, titles basically consist of one or more nouns plus their prepositions and/or postattributes; The title of phrase type should determine the head word and then modify it before and after. The order of each word is very important, and improper word order will lead to inaccurate expression.

(2) Generally don't use declarative sentences, because the title mainly plays a marking role, and declarative sentences are easy to make the title judgmental, not refined and not eye-catching. In a few cases (critical, comprehensive and refuting), the question can be used as the title, because the question has an exploratory tone and is easy to arouse the reader's interest.

The English title and Chinese title of the same paper should be consistent in content, but it does not mean that the words should correspond to each other. In many cases, individual non-material words can be omitted or changed.

④ Foreign sci-tech journals generally have restrictions on the number of words in titles, and some stipulate that titles should not exceed 2 lines, and each line should not exceed 42 printed symbols and spaces; Some require that the title should not exceed 14 words. These regulations can be used for our reference.

⑤ In the English title of the paper. Anything that can or can't be used is not used.

Question 7: How to write an example of the tutor's review opinion on the revision of the paper after the defense?

Topic: Optimization of VRP problem with mixed demand based on genetic algorithm.

Evaluation content evaluation index

Thesis proposal

Able to independently consult documents and engage in other research; Be able to translate foreign language materials correctly; Be able to present the opening report of the subject well; The correctness of comprehensive analysis and design calculation; Adequacy of argument

Vocational skills

Have solid basic theoretical knowledge and professional knowledge; Be able to design the experimental scheme correctly (or establish the mathematical model and mechanical structure scheme correctly); Conduct experimental work independently; Be able to use the knowledge and skills learned to find and solve practical problems; Can correctly handle experimental data; Be able to analyze the subject theoretically and draw valuable conclusions; Have a good professional foreign language level.

Paper quality

The summary is concise, complete and insightful; The argument is correct, the discussion is sufficient, and the conclusion is rigorous and reasonable; Correct experiment, scientific analysis and treatment; Fluent writing, accurate terminology, unified symbols, complete numbers, neat and standardized handwriting, complete, neat and correct charts; The results of the paper have application value; The calculation and test results are accurate; Have a sense of innovation in work; Improve or break through the previous work, or have original opinions;

Workload and working attitude

It is difficult to complete the specified tasks on schedule due to full workload; Work hard and observe discipline; Work style is rigorous and pragmatic

Tutor's comments

This paper introduces the mixed demand VRP problem of distribution problem and delivery problem, and designs the corresponding genetic algorithm. The experimental results show that the designed genetic algorithm is feasible and effective through C language programming. The topic of this paper has certain theoretical value and practical significance, with reasonable structure, clear logic and standard format.

Example 2

Topic: Research on the formation mechanism and preventive countermeasures of supply chain risks.

Evaluation content evaluation index

Able to independently consult documents and engage in other research; Be able to translate foreign language materials correctly; Be able to present the opening report of the subject well; The correctness of comprehensive analysis and design calculation; Adequacy of argument

Vocational skills

Have solid basic theoretical knowledge and professional knowledge; Be able to design the experimental scheme correctly (or establish the mathematical model and mechanical structure scheme correctly); Conduct experimental work independently; Be able to use the knowledge and skills learned to find and solve practical problems; Can correctly handle experimental data; Be able to analyze the subject theoretically and draw valuable conclusions; Have a good professional foreign language level.

Paper quality

The summary is concise, complete and insightful; The argument is correct, the discussion is sufficient, and the conclusion is rigorous and reasonable; Correct experiment, scientific analysis and treatment; Fluent writing, accurate terminology, unified symbols, complete numbers, neat and standardized handwriting, complete, neat and correct charts; The results of the paper have application value; The calculation and test results are accurate; Have a sense of innovation in work; Improve or break through the previous work, or have original opinions;

Workload and working attitude

It is difficult to complete the specified tasks on schedule due to full workload; Work hard and observe discipline; Work style is rigorous and pragmatic

Tutor's comments

The student's thesis is novel in topic selection, clear in organization, clear in structure and focused. On the basis of reviewing the research status of supply chain risk management at home and abroad, the mechanism of supply chain risk is analyzed and classified, and finally the prevention and control measures of supply chain risk are put forward.

In the process of writing the thesis, the student can seriously abide by the rules and regulations of the college, submit the first draft of the thesis on time, listen to the opinions and suggestions of the tutor with an open mind, and make serious revisions in time. Have a good attitude and behave well.

Question: How to write the graduation thesis "XXXXXXX" written by XXX, and how to choose the topic? The writing format of the thesis basically meets the requirements of our school's graduation thesis specification.

First, make a general introduction to the main points, basic ideas, innovations and shortcomings of the thesis during the defense: (whether the introduction is comprehensive and accurate, how to organize it, and whether the timing is appropriate).

Second, students answer questions:

1, whether the teacher's answer to the question is pertinent and whether the viewpoint is accurate;

2. Whether the answer to the question can be fully demonstrated, whether theory is combined with practice and whether it is convincing;

3. Which questions are answered well and which questions are not answered well (specify),

4. Whether answering questions reflects the perspective and methods of sociology, especially social work;

5. Whether the language expression is smooth, accurate and rigorous;

6. Grasp the time to answer questions;

Student review

Question 9: How to write a comment on the title of the paper 1. The center is prominent, the argument is sufficient, the structure is rigorous, the level is clear, and the expression ability is strong.

2. Rich materials and reliable data can be processed and sorted by scientific methods.

Question 10: how to write a comprehensive evaluation of the defense record of the thesis? Is the research content substantive and innovative?

Whether you have a solid understanding of the research content and can answer the teacher's questions well.