All parties responded, "I can only be a mannequin in my father's oil painting, and I can't accept other ways, such as photography." Qin Li told reporters that when she first saw a nude model, she felt very nervous. There are also many students who think that she has a good figure and suggest that she should also be a model. "How can I have the courage?" ! I think that's too insecure. But I don't hesitate to be my father's model, even naked. My father has always been an upright man, which makes me feel safe. I am also engaged in oil painting. It is a very pure thing to devote oneself to art, especially for my father. "
In Li Zhuangping's eyes, his daughter Qin Li is beautiful, kind and pure. Everyone who knows Qin Li won't have evil thoughts, just want to care about her, especially as a father. His works are based on Shan Gui by Qu Yuan and Goddess of Wushan by Guo Moruo. When he found that his daughter was very close to the image of the Oriental Goddess, he wrote it with his daughter after obtaining the consent of his lover and daughter. "Let your daughter be your own nude model, and never consider it ethically." Li Zhuangping said that when he was writing, he and his daughter never felt embarrassed, just like when he was a child, he bathed her. Li Zhuangping's lover said that she often watched when the father and daughter were creating. In fact, she envies her daughter. She can leave her youth in such a beautiful way. It's a pity that she is young and beautiful, but she has no such opportunity. Many netizens think that it sounds strange for their daughters to be nude models, but in fact, the paintings of Li Zhuangping and Qin Li's father and daughter are beautiful, which will not make people feel pornographic or obscene. Wang Wang, a netizen, thinks that when Li Zhuangping paints her daughter, she will intentionally or unintentionally handle some details, such as some hairs on Qin Li's body (ordinary painters will "seduce" people with such details), and there is no elegant gesture. He is very successful in artistic creation and publicity.
Some netizens think that, in any case, I feel uncomfortable at the thought of my daughter undressing in front of her father. Some netizens even think that if the nude model in the painting was not the painter's daughter, the series of Shan Gui, the goddess of the East, would not be so popular.
Lin Mu, a famous art critic and professor of Sichuan University, used the word "very respectable" when evaluating this matter. It is believed that Li's father and daughter broke through the barriers of ethics and made contributions to the development of art. Lin Mu said that it is not uncommon to use nude models in the art world, but it is rare to use their relatives, such as their wives, as nude models, and it is the first time for their daughters to be nude models. "There are still some people who always encourage others to take off their clothes and let them paint, especially without sincerity." In Lin Mu's view, compared with those people, Li Zhuangping's father and daughter are sincere, and they provide a new direction and thinking for the art of mannequin. "Let someone else's daughter be a nude model instead of her own daughter?" In the face of some netizens' accusation that "Li Zhuangping's father and daughter violated morality and ethics, and this group of paintings made people feel uncomfortable", Lin Mu thought it was unfair. Li Yinhe, a famous sociologist, said that this is actually nothing. Why do some people feel uncomfortable? That's because traditional ideas are at work again. Many people immediately think of "incest" when they see their fathers, daughters and nudes. But in fact nothing happened except a group of beautiful paintings. As long as the daughter is willing to be a nude model for her father, why think too much?
Li Yinhe believes that incest is a taboo in the whole human society and a deep-rooted traditional thought that incest is not allowed. This idea is correct in itself, but we can't easily assume that others will commit incest, let alone assume a reality that doesn't exist at all. This is the same reason that many people think of sex as soon as they see nude models. Mannequin is a serious profession, and it is an artistic expression, so it doesn't matter whether the model and the painter have a father-daughter relationship. Yuan Zushe believes that this matter has two sides and cannot be viewed only from an ethical perspective. From an artistic point of view, there is no ethical problem. Because Li Zhuangping is a painter, his daughter is just an aesthetic object. In addition, Qin Li also thinks that he is very sacred in his father's mind. It shows that the father and the daughter have the same understanding, and neither of them thinks this kind of behavior is immoral or immoral. "But from an ethical point of view, this is a question of whether it should be right or wrong. In my opinion, Li Zhuangping's behavior is improper. "
Yuan Zushe said that Li Zhuangping and Qin Li have a father-daughter relationship, not only the relationship between the painter and the model, but also the utilitarian problem of the mannequin. At this time, ethical principles are involved, which some people can't accept. The behavior of Li's father and daughter has broken through the ethical code. If the Li family's father and daughter only enjoy it in their own homes after they are created, then this time belongs to private ethics, and it doesn't matter if it is reasonable or unreasonable. When these works are exhibited, they extend from the private field to the social field, which causes social ethical evaluation and also produces social ethical effects. "Adult daughters are naked in front of their fathers, which does not conform to most people's ethical norms and has a negative impact. This is what I call Li Zhuangping's behavior. "