1, the meaning of the topic.

Look at the novelty, uniqueness and practicability of the topic, as well as its theoretical and practical significance.

2. Rationality and scientificity of research methods.

Whether the research methods and means adopted are suitable for the content and tasks of the subject; The design of main methods is scientific and rigorous; Whether there are original advanced methods and means.

3. The scientific nature of this argument

The viewpoint of the paper strives to be correct, distinct, novel and objective; A higher requirement is to have original ideas or innovative theories.

4. The logical level, breadth and depth of argument.

Argument should conform to logical laws, arguments and arguments must be consistent, and the form of reasoning method should be used correctly and reasonably. The center of the argument is prominent and has a certain depth; The scope of demonstration is consistent with that of research.

5, the degree of application of the theory

Be able to fully discuss, elaborate and analyze the research questions and materials obtained by combining the professional theories and basic theories related to this topic, and form opinions and conclusions through high generalization and abstraction.

6. Study the reliability and representativeness of material facts.

All kinds of important facts reported and quoted in the paper must first be true, reliable, accurate and objective, and come from scientific research or production practice; Secondly, the materials should be rich, complete, representative and convincing.

7. The integrity and rationality of the paper structure.

The structure should be complete and the format should be standardized. In particular, the structure of the discussion part should be suitable for expressing the results of the research. The overall structure is reasonable, the level is clear and the logic is strong.

8, the value of the conclusion

From the perspective of research task and specialty, we can see the correctness, comprehensiveness, generality and novelty (or innovation) of the conclusion.

9. Writing level

The basic requirement is fluency, accuracy and appropriateness.

10, chart application skills

Suitable for demonstration needs; Intuition, persuasion and skill; Chart specifications.