Blind examination of undergraduate thesis:
Blind review of undergraduate thesis means that the school sends the undergraduate thesis to the experts outside the school for review to ensure the quality and objectivity of the thesis. Generally speaking, the pass rate of blind examination of undergraduate thesis is relatively high, probably above 90%. As long as the paper is not badly written, it can meet the basic requirements such as format, number of words and duplicate checking. And there is no obvious logical error or plagiarism, and there is a high probability of passing.
Distribution by discipline:
The lowest pass rate of blind test is engineering, which is 69.9%, followed by philosophy, which is 73.8%. The subjects below 80% are art, agriculture, education and law, reaching the average level. The highest pass rate is medicine, which is 97%. The passing rate of economics and science is also relatively high.
According to the grading standard:
According to the blind expert scoring standard, this paper mainly investigates the significance, research methods, theoretical basis, data analysis, conclusions and suggestions, innovations and so on. The specific grading standards may vary from school to school. Generally, a grading table or a comment table will be given for experts' reference.
The above data are from Zhihu.
Reasons for blind review of papers:
1 to ensure the quality and objectivity of the paper.
The purpose of blind examination of papers is to ensure the quality and objectivity of papers, and to avoid the subjective prejudice or interests of tutors or schools from affecting the evaluation of papers. Through blind examination of papers, the academic level and value of papers can be improved, and academic exchange and innovation can be promoted.
2. Avoid the influence of the author or tutor on the evaluation experts.
The way of blind review of papers is to send them to experts outside the school for review. The judging experts don't know the author and tutor of the paper, and they won't reveal their identity and achievements. Blind review of papers helps to avoid the influence or pressure of the author or tutor, and also helps to avoid the author or tutor's questioning or dissatisfaction with the experts.
3. Save experts' time and energy.
The rules and procedures of blind examination of papers may vary from school to school and from major to major. Generally speaking, blind evaluation is randomly selected, and not all papers need blind evaluation. Blind review of papers helps to save experts' time and energy and improve the efficiency and fairness of evaluation.