Liu Bei, it is really valuable to have a heart of benevolence and righteousness in troubled times. It is your benevolence and righteousness that attracted such brave ministers as Zhuge Liang, Zhao Yun, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei and Huang Zhong.

During the Three Kingdoms period, the world knew Liu Huangshu's benevolence and righteousness. You have been in charge of Xuzhou for less than a year, and the people live and work in peace and contentment, and all the people return to their hometown. You treat people with kindness and courtesy. Scholars and men of letters compete for scenery. When Changbanpo is in danger, you would rather die than give up the people and flee with 200 thousand people. I have rarely heard of it since ancient times.

In Guan Yu's words, your heart of benevolence and righteousness is "a vast expanse of land", and you let Xuzhou out of your heart of benevolence and righteousness. It should be noted that the heart of benevolence and righteousness should also be used for benevolent people. You gave Xuzhou to Lu Bu, but he made you lose your armor and your home. You can't bear to rob people and property, but you can't bear to see Jingzhou fall into Cao Cao's hands. Later, he had to form an alliance with Sun Quan against Cao Cao. As a result, Jingzhou became the contradiction between Sun and Liu, which was really full of twists and turns. Later, with the cooperation of Qi Xin, a civil servant and military commander, you owned nine counties in Jingxiang, and Hanzhong and Yizhou became the strongest of the three.

Success is also Jingzhou, and defeat is also Jingzhou. You leave Guan Yu stationed in Jingzhou, but he has no intention of Jingzhou. Why? So is arrogance. You treat brothers as brothers and women as clothes. It was decided that dispatch troops would attack Wu with blood and worry about his brother, leaving the important task of "reviving the Han Dynasty and returning its old capital". You don't listen to Zhuge Liang's advice, nor do you accept Zhao Yun's kindness. With an expedition of 700,000 troops, you became more and more arrogant after winning Yizhou. In the process of attacking Wu, your arrogance was carried away by victory. If you didn't listen to the advice, you were burned by Lu Xun for seven hundred miles, which wiped out the strength you had worked so hard to accumulate for more than ten years. Poor Zhuge Liang's painstaking efforts. You left in a slump, leaving a mess for the living. As a result, the situation in the three countries took a turn for the worse, and Shu Han became the weakest party again. Zhuge Liang's three-step plan in Longzhong has to start from scratch again, but time waits for no one. From this point of view, Shu Han will soon be extinct!

I don't know if you have carefully considered your battle against Wu; I don't know if you still remember your original dream; I don't know if you still remember the oath that "two thieves strive, and Wang Ye is impartial". Did you just send troops to be brave or were you carried away by victory and rushed to send troops?

"Rolling said that the east went to the water to die, and the waves scoured out heroes. Success or failure turns empty ... "Everything in you becomes empty because of failure. How many people are happy and sad about your failure?

The wheel of history always follows the rules, leaving deep ruts on the ground for future generations to learn from. I can't say whether your benevolence and righteousness are right or wrong, and I don't know whether dispatch troops's attack on Wu is right or wrong. I can only say, "a pot of turbid wine likes to meet, and everything is a joke."