Case 1: My mother-in-law doesn't want to give her daughter-in-law a new house, and her daughter-in-law won't move.
2065438+In August 2005, the People's Court of Wuyang County, Xinxiang City made a first-instance judgment on the case of emotional dispute caused by trivial matters between plaintiff Zhang Li and defendant Zhang Yu after marriage: 1. Dissolve the relationship between plaintiff Zhang Li and defendant Zhang Yu; 2. Reject the plaintiff Zhang Li's claim that the defendant Zhang Yu should return the bride price, compensation for house demolition and house decoration, totaling 82,044.5 yuan, and reject the plaintiff Zhang Deng (pseudonym)' s other claims; 3. Defendant Zhang Yu should pay the bride price of 40,000 yuan to plaintiff Zhang Deng (pseudonym) within 10 days from the effective date of this judgment; Four, reject the plaintiff Zhang Li's other claims. After the verdict was pronounced, the plaintiff Zhang Li did not appeal, and the verdict became legally effective. During the trial, neither party filed a divorce lawsuit again.
Case 2: Daughter-in-law wants to go back to her mother's house and is rejected.
Wang Li (pseudonym) and Zhang Wei (pseudonym), who live in Minquan County, Shangqiu City, Henan Province, were introduced and lived together in 2007. Zhang Wei has been attached to Wang Li and gave birth to a son and a daughter. Later, because Wang Li didn't like Zhang Wei and didn't want to have children, they registered marriage in 2008 and had a daughter. After the marriage, Wang Li repeatedly proposed to return to her family, but she was rejected. Later, due to the disagreement between the two sides, the contradiction gradually evolved into a disagreement between husband and wife. Zhang Wei sued Wang Li to the court for divorce on 20 15 10. The court held through trial that the defendant and the defendant were husband and wife, and there were certain contradictions and differences in their marriage life. Although Wang Li sued the court for divorce, the court explained that there was no possibility of reconciliation between the two parties, so she decided to dissolve the marriage relationship according to law. Now the two have not reconciled due to trivial matters of life, and the plaintiff goes back to her mother's house every month for 1 day, which is rejected by the defendant.
Case 3: Contradictions between mother-in-law and daughter-in-law, beaten by her husband.
Case 2065438+July 2005, Han, who lives in Biyang County, Zhumadian City, had a little conflict with his daughter-in-law. Under the mediation of both families, the two reached an agreement to jointly undertake Han's one-time compensation for his daughter-in-law Zhang's cash 1 1,000 yuan and a piece of gold jewelry worth 7,000 yuan. 2065438+On September 6th, 2005, Han had an argument with Zhang for trivial matters, and was hospitalized for two days after being beaten by Zhang, and was later diagnosed as scalp laceration and skull fracture. Han sued Zhang to the court for divorce. After trial, the magistrate's court held that both Han and Zhang were remarried women and were introduced to get married. Contradictions arising from trivial matters after marriage failed to properly handle the relationship between husband and wife, which eventually led to the breakdown of the relationship between husband and wife and the separation of the two. In view of the fact that Han and Zhang reached an agreement to actively compensate each other for 1000 yuan after their illness recovered, and that they could live together until the day when the plaintiff Han was discharged from the hospital, it was determined that their husband-wife relationship had not broken down and they were divorced according to law.
Case 4: The relationship between husband and wife broke down and the court granted divorce.
Introduction: Li and Wang are in free love. During their love, Wang got pregnant twice. Li never gave up his married life with Wang, but Wang turned a blind eye to it. After pregnancy, Li Yin's physical reasons were not well treated. After repeated urging, she chose abortion. Results the sex of the fetus did not match and the relationship between husband and wife broke down. Wang appealed to the court for a divorce from Li. The judge said: according to the marriage law, the relationship between husband and wife has indeed broken down, and when there is no possibility of reconciliation, they can sue for divorce in the people's court. In this case, the defendant Wang suffered from breast cancer. Due to their own reasons, they were not treated in time. In addition, due to the comprehensive influence of family environment, work and many other factors, the relationship between husband and wife has completely broken down and divorce should be granted.
Case 5: The wife asked for compensation for mental damage compensation, and the court rejected it.
On 20 13, his wife, Ms. Wang, sued for divorce. She thinks that it is immoral and legal for her husband to divorce her because she lives with others, and demands compensation for mental damages and economic losses totaling 6.5438+0.2 million yuan. The judge believes that Ms. Wang's claim of 6.5438+0.4 million yuan for mental damages is 5,000 yuan/year, and her claim should not be supported. Article 40 of the Marriage Law stipulates: "Husband and wife should be faithful to each other; Caring for each other; Protect the legitimate rights and interests of others' marriage and family, and maintain the harmony and stability of marriage and family. " Husband and wife should be loyal to each other, not slander each other. If their feelings have really broken down, they can't tolerate cheating, concealment, insult, slander and other acts of the other party, or they will bear legal responsibility. Ms. Wang and her husband have been living in proper relationship since June 20 13, so it should be considered that their relationship has really broken down. In this case, there is no basis for claiming compensation for mental damage and economic loss.