Neither of them.
I personally think so.
After Fan Zhiyi, there are only four outstanding central defenders in China men's soccer team: Zhang, Dewey, Feng Xiaoting and Zhang.
The comparison between others and Fan Zhiyi is an insult to Fan Zhiyi.
Only Feng Xiaoting, Zhang and Feng Xiaoting left Evergrande. The most fundamental reason is ginger. Although this season's Shenhua has stumbled to this day without a major general, Feng Xiaoting's role can not be ignored, but Shenhua's defensive core is Nubia, and it is getting worse and worse. The name is so prominent that it has become a mobile phone brand, but Nubian's success depends more on talent and hard work.
Although Feng Xiaoting plays a huge role in it, it is still far from Fan Zhiyi, and at this age, the upper limit has been set.
Zhang has basically become a full-back at Evergrande, which is a great pity, because Zhang Wu is an excellent central defender. He meets almost all the requirements of a central defender, height, weight, speed, bounce and can hold the ball without opening his feet. This is the top central defender.
However, the existence of ginger made Zhang go to one side, and the biggest reason was physical hardness and emotional control.
In the current Super League, the best two foreign central defenders are mbia of Shenhua and Miranda of Suning, and the two partners are Li Ang that Feng Xiaoting and Li Tie like. There is still a big gap.
Jiang is basically on the same level as mbia and Miranda. The only difference is that Jiang doesn't like to press on, which may be due to style or too many offensive players of Evergrande.
As for Dewey and Zhang, as far as defense is concerned, their skills are similar to those of Fan Zhiyi. The only difference is Fan Zhiyi's performance on the offensive end. Basically, in Shenhua, Fan Zhiyi played all over the central axis from the back to the front, and even in the national team, he was not a central defender in the traditional sense, which virtually elevated Fan Zhiyi's position.
As far as pure centre-back technology is concerned, Jiang is stronger than Fan Zhiyi in physical hardness, and the advantage of mixed blood is too great, even the steel bars like Fan Zhiyi can't match.
Besides, Fan Zhiyi's personality was bursting, and he accidentally got burned with the opposing striker. Of the four listed, who is more reliable in character than Fan Zhiyi?
Therefore, Jiang is not only the best in active service, but also a dimension better than Fan Zhiyi on the defensive end, because Fan Zhiyi's performance on the offensive end is overestimated.
The conclusion may be scolded, but this is the cruel reality.
This is also the gospel of China men's football national team.
What, after Fan Zhiyi, Fan Zhiyi has the skill of ginger, accurate and steady? The only thing Jiang can talk about is the best, that is, don't let the Super League spoil it.
Jiang is really great! I think he is the best central defender in China. After watching the game between Evergrande and Jianye last night, Jiang Gang tried to stop Jianye's foreign aid, and several threatening shots in front of the door were defused. His movements are clean and neat, and he looks very comfortable!
My answer: Jiang is undoubtedly the best "national football central defender" after Fan Zhiyi.
Jiang and Fan Zhiyi are equally capable.
Fan Zhiyi is the iconic figure of China football centre-back. Mr. Asian Footballer, a rare player in domestic football, has participated in the World Cup, won the silver medal and bronze medal in the Asian Games, and won the third place in the Asian Cup. He had a successful experience in studying abroad and was the captain of the Crystal Palace team in League One. Strong style, fierce, competitive sports, competent for multiple positions, leadership style.
Jiang, born in Everton youth training, played in the Premier League. As Sunderland's main defender, he made 27 appearances in the Championship. Selected and represented England U 17, U 19, U2 1 youth team.
About the same height, ginger 1, 8 1 m, Fan Zhiyi 1.83, and about the same weight, 76 kg for ginger and 76 kg for Fan Zhiyi. Speed, strength and explosiveness are similar. Strength, Fan Zhiyi won by leadership.
Jiang's special ability is not inferior to that of Fan Zhiyi, and even slightly better.
Fan Zhiyi is very strong in many aspects, with the temperament of a leader and the demeanor of a general. Ginger is a super group's special ability. Both sides have their own victories.
Jiang is also a rare leader after the central defender, with outstanding ability and better balance, body, technology, vision, strength, defense, spirit, speed and air control. Man-marking, aggression, anticipation and sense of position are better than domestic players, and they are not inferior to South Korean international Park Jisoo.
Especially in the position of central defender dominated by medium and super foreign aid, he ranks fifth in blocking per game, on an equal footing with top foreign aid such as Miranda, danielson and Min Kim. He averaged 56.3 passes per game, ranking fourth in the same position. It can be seen that a central defender has super offensive ability and the ability to create excellent opportunities per game ranks first in the same position. It reflects the important role and value of ginger in the offensive and defensive ends of the team. It shows the strength and level of a completely powerful central defender's foreign aid, far exceeding the level of domestic central defenders.
Jiang is the best "national football centre-back" after Fan Zhiyi in terms of data and performance.
Fan Zhiyi has never been the best central defender!
Ginger is as good as Fan Zhiyi, maybe even a head taller. First, Fan Zhiyi is too JASON ZHANG to concentrate on playing well. Second, Jiang has a strong predictive ability, a good position card and a particularly fast foot. Third, Jiang's one-on-one ability, at present, there are not many forwards at home and abroad who can surpass him. China football needs a central defender like Jiang.
Please don't compare Fan with Jiang.
General Fan's defensive skills were wild, while Jiang played his first ball professionally. Key key: Personality, Fan Zhiyi's fiery temper and rough skills can only harm the team, and Jiang is obvious to all!
The characteristics of ginger are obvious. His steals are fierce but just right, his card position is accurate, his head is calm, his prediction ability is strong, his body is tough and his long pass is very good. As a central defender, it's the hardest thing to defend without getting hurt or getting a card. Jiang and Fan lived in different times. From the central defender's point of view, Jiang is better than Fan Qiang.