"Qing History Draft": "Qing has been in the army for a long time, and he is over eighty years old. He has a short coat and a head. In the ice and snow, he shared joys and sorrows with the foot soldiers. People think it is difficult to cloud. "

"In the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-1895, the Huai army was repeated, followed by the Xiang army, and only the Yu army was strong. Qing and Yu Kun have lost successively, so they can't be self-motivated. After the three northeastern provinces set up their own armies, they did not become enemies, but Iktangga and Changshun worked hard to protect Liaoyang without loss, which is known at home and abroad. There are too many people who have lost their teachers and humiliated the country. "

Liu Tiren: "In addition to Xiang Huai Army, there are Yi Army and Zhang Army in Song Dynasty in Henan, and Anhui is the following. Guo Min's subordinates, such as Cheng Zhongsheng, Cheng Junmen and Niu Zongzhen, were all famous at that time, and their achievements were still between if and if. The military camp is used to it, and thieves go there to lie about the war. Guo Min was caught twisting bandits, and his whereabouts were erratic. His beating is different from his. Go away. Fortunately, I have not met an enemy, and I have been able to make a fortune. "