At that time, Song Wu, shot by Shandong TV Station, won numerous applause as soon as it appeared on the TV screen. The image of Song Wu played by Zhu Yanping is deeply rooted in people's hearts. It is no exaggeration to say that it is an insurmountable classic.

With Zhu Yanping's version of Song Wu Zhu Yu in the front, whoever plays Song Wu again will suffer some losses, because the audience will involuntarily compare it with Zhu Yanping. Zhu Yanping's performance itself is good, coupled with the preconceived impression, it is even more difficult to surpass Zhu Yanping.

The CCTV version of Water Margin has done a lot of work in casting. Ding Haifeng's appearance made people shine at the moment, and he was quickly recognized and loved by the audience. Compared with Zhu Yanping, Ding Haifeng is younger and more capable, and his stage modeling is more heroic and handsome, but he is brave and witty. Coupled with computer special effects, such as using a real tiger and editing the later martial arts movements, the Ding Haifeng version of Song Wu is more ornamental.

Bo Huang once said: In this era, you can't stop others from shining, but no one can stop you from shining. Not to mention the Chen Long version (I really haven't seen it), the two versions of Song Wu are classics of different times. It's not a beautiful moment, but they are good at winning the game.

Generally speaking, I prefer Ding Haifeng's version of Song Wu. Personally, don't spray if you don't like it.

Fortunately, I have read all three versions, revealing my age!

1, Shandong Edition, Zhu Yanping Edition Song Wu.

I don't remember other plots in this version, but Zhu Yanping's Song Wu has always been impressed. In particular, I was deeply impressed by the two episodes of Tiger Fighting and Ximen Qing Fighting. This, of course, has a lot to do with Zhu Yanping's characterization, which can also be said to be the earliest successful version of Song Wu. In fact, the later CCTV version and the new water margin also reshaped Song Wu on this basis. It can be said that Zhu Yanping's version is definitely the basis of the characterization of the later two versions of Song Wu. Tommy Tam also has a Hong Kong version of Song Wu, 1982. Zhu Yanping is 1983. Although Tommy Tam was earlier, at that time, firstly, the spread of the Hong Kong version was not so wide, and secondly, Tommy Tam was so handsome that he was a little divorced from the image of Song Wu. Therefore, Zhu Yanping version is definitely the earliest successful version of Song Wu in film and television dramas. The reason why it is the earliest success, not the most successful, is that it is not as extensive as the Ding Haifeng version in terms of dissemination and influence. However, Zhu Yanping's version of Song Wu is the most successful as a classic and foundation. Tall and powerful, handsome and natural and unrestrained, most in line with the imagination of the East for the hero image! In terms of characterization, it can be said that Zhu Yanping is the most successful, which directly affects the image-building of Song Wu in the latter two versions, and even draws lessons from this version in many aspects.

2. CCTV version, Ding Haifeng version of Song Wu.

This version of Song Wu can be said to be the most widely circulated version of Song Wu and a very classic version of Song Wu. No matter in image or martial arts design, there are some places that make your eyes shine, especially martial arts design. With the music, Song Wu simply walked out of the book. Anyway, Ding Haifeng's comprehensive score is definitely the highest so far. Of course, it also made Ding Haifeng an actor. Since he played Song Wu, it has been difficult for him to surpass himself for many years. It was not until director Donglai two years ago that he remembered this actor again, or remembered another role of him again. It is not easy!

3. Chen Long version of the New Water Margin Song Wu.

It's a little hard to say, mainly because the first two editions are too strong. This version of Song Wu is still good if it is cut to the tail. Pinch the head to the tail, refers to the fight after killing Ximen Qing, feeling Chen Long gradually entering the state. Before that, I always felt that Chen Long was a little deliberately trying to interpret Song Wu's innocent and good youth with no regrets. In other words, the traces of the previous episodes are a bit heavy. Of course, it may also be that the previous costume design and deliberate hearty laughter also lowered the score. The second half is absolutely fine. Staged a blood feud and more than 20 life lawsuits. Especially the expression on his face when it broke out, and the way he stared at people later, which made people shudder. Everything is fine. In short, the first half really lowered the comprehensive score. Although I got a lot of points back in the second half. However, there are many criticisms that cannot be suppressed. I have to say, it's not bad to finish the task of playing Song Wu. However, the overall advantages of the new water margin are also many, which will not be discussed here.

So, to sum up. Three versions of Song Wu.

Zhu Yanping laid a classic foundation, Ding Haifeng was indeed better than Blue in shine on you, and Chen Long was also qualified, and accomplished the task of playing Song Wu quite well!

There is no first in literature, and no second in martial arts. In short, it is our audience's greatest blessing not to meet today's small fresh meat to perform! The third edition is not bad!

I'm from Shandong, and I like Zhu Yanping and Ding Haifeng's two versions of Song Wu better emotionally than Zhu Yanping's Song Wu.

Shandong version of Song Wu was produced by Shandong TV Station 1983, with a total of 8 episodes. In the 1980s, China had just implemented reform and opening up, and the development of TV series was in its infancy. At that time, Shandong Satellite TV broadcast "Song Wu", which gave people a refreshing feeling that had never been seen before. It sensationalized the whole country and there was a spectacular situation of watching Song Wu everywhere.

Song Wu is a household name in China. Before Song Wu was broadcast on Shandong Satellite TV, people had an abstract understanding of the image of Song Wu. By watching Zhu Yanping play Song Wu, people naturally realize that the image of Zhu Yanping is the image of Song Wu. This impression is deeply imprinted in their minds, so that when it comes to Song Wu, it is associated with Zhu Yanping, which is hard to change.

The CCTV version of Water Margin was broadcast on 1998 1, in which Tiger Song Wu was played by Ding Haifeng. This TV series is later than Song Wu of Shandong Satellite TV 15 years. After 15, various undertakings in China have made great progress. The conditions for filming Water Margin by CCTV and Song Wu by Shandong TV are different. The artistry and actor level of the later TV series are above the previous Shandong version of Song Wu. Of course, Ding Haifeng's acting is better than Zhu Yanping's, which should be affirmed.

But when I saw Song Wu played by Ding Haifeng in the play, although I admired his acting skills, I always had a strange feeling that Song Wu played by Ding Haifeng seemed more like Song Wu than Zhu Yanping in expression, action and appearance. Perhaps this understanding is one-sided, but preconceived ideas are a habit, and Zhu Yanping's impression of Song Wu is always lingering.

Now there is a story circulating on the Internet about the remake of Liang Jian with small fresh meat. There are three versions of Liang Jian 3, Li Youbin's, Huang Zhizhong's and Wang Yunshan's Zhang (Li) Yunlong. No matter how hard the latter two actors try, they leave different impressions.

Compared with Song Wu in Ding Haifeng, Song Wu in Zhu Yanping is more similar and unforgettable than Song Wu in Zhu Yanping, both in acting and art.

Personally, I like the Ding Haifeng version, which is more classic.

Ding Haifeng is tall and burly, masculine and powerful, and the most important thing is to play Song Wu in both form and spirit. Especially when angry, those cold eyes can really kill people. But he looked at his brother Wu Da with clear eyes full of affection, which made people feel that Song Wu's inner chivalrous tenderness was very moving. Ding Haifeng vividly reproduces Song Wu, which makes people feel that Song Wu is Ding Haifeng and Ding Haifeng is Song Wu. Just like the Monkey King of six-year-old children and Jia Baoyu of Ouyang Fenqiang.

Ding Haifeng version of Water Margin, whether it is props, lines or related cast, is personally considered to be the best version, which can be described as a classic and difficult to surpass. Martial arts design is also the most classic, especially beautiful, but also to portray characters, not to show off their skills. I like classic scenes, Jingyanggang Tiger, Feiyun Spectrum, Drunk Jiang Menshen, Song Wunu Ximen Qing, etc. , are extremely wonderful. When the suona rings, it makes people's blood spurt! It's really beautiful. I can't get tired of hearing it!

Relatively speaking, the Zhu Yanping version, personally feel that the actors are slightly thin, and the martial arts scenes are rough and simple because of the limitations of the times, and the visual effect is not as good as that of the Ding Haifeng version.

But Zhu Yanping also showed the inner charm of Song Wu, with many old audiences, not preconceived audiences. Just limited by the times. Generally speaking, I don't think it's as good as the Ding Haifeng version.

Which is better? Different people have different opinions. I have stopped reading other versions, and it is impossible to surpass the above two versions.

Personally, I think the Zhu Yanping version is the most classic. In the early 1980s, Song Wu, as a local TV station (Shandong), naturally could not be compared with the later CCTV Water Margin in terms of martial arts design, scene layout and post-production, but the most shining highlight of the play was Song Wu played by Zhu Yanping: a bold, brave, free and easy, generous, open-minded but chivalrous and soft-hearted person ... Most importantly, Zhu Yanping's performance was very simple.

Looking at the 98th edition of Water Margin by CCTV, it should be said that it provides a more magnificent space for the hero Song Wu. It is no exaggeration to describe Ding Haifeng's performance of Song Wu with remarkable and almost perfect performance. But only by comparison can we tell. Compared with Zhu, Ding is obviously slightly inferior. ...

Let's compare and analyze from two details:

First, I will face Ms. Pan Jinlian who is still a "sister-in-law" rather than an "adulteress". I wish "Song Wu": Hao Xia, Wu Ying, be frank and sincere ... The audience can deeply feel the deep love and admiration of tiger hero Wu Erlang for his sister-in-law, and can personally feel the iron and blood chivalrous heart of tiger hero Zheng Xia ... Even when going out on business to say goodbye to his brothers, Zhu Wusong will be even more supercilious and generous in the face of her sister-in-law's harsh words.

On the other hand, Ding's performance is unnatural, too formal and a little obscene, and he is a concubine. Moreover, it is not difficult to see more complicated components from his flickering and free eyes ... Perhaps, the director wants to "break through innovation" here, but Song Wu's performance is obviously a failure, which is different from the previous "killing tigers" and the later "revenge".

Second, in the face of "adulterer" Pan Jinlian and Ximen Qing who killed his brother. I wish "Song Wu": the heroic spirit of integrity, anger and hatred is more domineering and free and easy ... And Ding's "Song Wu": it's just that the head is so crooked and the eyes are so exposed, and it's still fierce, but the so-called "integrity, anger and anger" is not only greatly discounted, but also

My humble opinion, don't spray if you don't like it. If you can look at the comparison again, you may be able to review the old and learn the new!

Chen Long's Song Wu is young and beautiful with infinite scenery. But the dragon is also an ant, "Wu Songzhi", really!

Film and television drama, the character of Song Wu in the Water Margin, the film and television drama that shaped the ancient hero image of Water Margin "Song Wu", I like the first one very much, the Water Margin (Song Wu) series, the martial arts actor, "Zhu Yanping". The author thinks that only Zhu Yanping, with his superb acting skills, profound martial arts and magical description, gives a true, lifelike and vivid representation of the characters. Song Wu, an ancient hero, was brave and courageous, distinguished right from wrong, and accumulated evil into enemies. Because more than 30 years ago, there was no electronic synthesis equipment, no stunt imaging machine, no optical effect synthesis technology, and no "body double came to the rescue". So martial arts dramas are generally real kung fu. For example, Jet Li, who starred in the film "Shaolin Temple" more than 30 years ago, became famous at home and abroad because of his high martial arts, which shocked the film and television circles in Hong Kong and Taiwan. Finally, he appeared in the Hollywood studio in America! So what I admire most is Zhu Yanping, who was drunk and beat people-Jiang Menshen, beating people-police officer Ximen Qing, and the warrior went up the mountain "knowing that there are tigers in the mountains, leaning towards the tiger mountains" and "being independent and unconstrained style". Beat the tiger with drunken fists, hug the tiger under the tiger's skin, a heroic feat! All martial arts actors, real kung fu! Become a model of the classic "martial arts film and television drama" in the 1980s!

In fact, before Ding Haifeng starred in Song Wu, when I was a child, I always thought that the Zhu Yanping version of Song Wu was the most classic, especially the opening of the title of Water Margin, which filled people with infinite imagination for the upcoming drama. Moreover, the Song Wu played by Zhu Yanping was almost perfect, and it seemed absolutely impossible to surpass it in image, temperament, skill and acting at that time.

But after watching Ding Haifeng's version of Song Wu, I suddenly realized that although Zhu Yanping's version of Song Wu is close to perfection, his interpretation of Song Wu seems to lack some true temperament, mainly the "tiger spirit" of young Song Wu, and his actions are more like a "mature big brother".

In contrast, Ding Haifeng's interpretation of Song Wu's feelings is more accurate and closer to my impression of Song Wu. What kind of person is Song Wu? Needless to say, he is good at martial arts and kind-hearted, but he hates evil, never rubs sand in his eyes, and lays hands on him even harder. Although he never "calculated" others, as long as he was "calculated", Song Wu would definitely "repay" twice, and he didn't care who the other person was. One more thing, Song Wu seldom slacks off at work. He always says what he wants. This is what I call "tiger strength".

Ding Haifeng's Song Wu naturally shows these characteristics of Song Wu, which is very enjoyable, just like Wu Erlang's wine style. Therefore, I still think Ding Haifeng's version of Song Wu is the most classic.

Zhu Yanping's figure looks good, but he is too straight and a little old-fashioned. He is thirty years old? Forty? Personally, Ding Haifeng's version is more in line with the image of Song Wu. He looks like he is in his twenties. He is young and brave, so he must report his superb martial arts. His martial arts are wonderful and more classic! Compared with bamboo board, it feels better than shine on you and blue, but it is not high enough. Chen Long's eyes are bigger than the first two, others are not a fragment, hehe. Welcome to spray

Of course, I wish the continuation version!

Zhu Yanping, I feel very heroic and classic.