The preliminary examination of papers refers to the process of preliminary examination and feedback on the structure, content and format of papers by professionals before they are formally submitted. In the process of preliminary examination, professionals will carefully review the papers and put forward clear suggestions for revision to help the authors further improve the papers and improve their quality. Preliminary examination is also a key link to avoid some serious problems, which helps to improve the pass rate and quality of papers and reduce the number of subsequent revisions.

The specific evaluation criteria for the preliminary examination of papers usually include academic value, research methods, data analysis, argument analysis and argument application. When evaluating the academic value of a paper, professionals will consider whether the research topic is of practical significance, whether the research method is feasible, whether the research results are reliable and whether it is widely applicable. In addition, it is necessary to evaluate the structure, arguments and framework of the paper to ensure its logic and coherence.