1, distinguished professor Zhou Zhixiong, College of Literature, Anhui University: Zhu Xian is quite similar to Jin Yong's "the duke of mount deer Eternal Dragon Slayer" in the concept of good and evil. Wei Xiaobao in The Duke Of Mount Deer has both good and evil, Zhao Min in "Eternal Dragon Slayer" abandons evil and follows good, Xie Xun turns right, and Zhou Zhiruo goes through the process from right to evil and then to right. Images like Wei Xiaobao, Zhao Min and Zhou Zhiruo are hard to distinguish right from wrong.

In Zhu Xian, Daoxuan, the head of the decent Qingyun Gate, turned out to be an evil figure, while the ghost king, the head of the "Ghost King Sect" of the Magic Sect, has a kind side.

2. Ou Zaojie, Associate Professor, School of Literature and Media, Hechi University: In Zhu Xian, the author created the hero Zhang Xiaofan, an extremely ordinary peasant boy, whose qualification is even far inferior to that of his hometown Lin Jingyu, and he is often ignored by others. But after repeated changes, Zhang Xiaofan's identity has unexpectedly changed.

He changed from an ordinary peasant boy to an ordinary disciple of the Great Everest at Qingyunmen, the leader of the right path, a bloody "blood son" ghost, and finally a hero who combined the three true religions of magic, Taoism and Buddhism and held a sword to urge the sword array to save all beings.

These are the spiritual desires of the author and even young people in modern society. They want to escape from the real material world and live an ideal spiritual desire in the art world.

3. Xu Zhongwei, Associate Professor, School of Tourism Management, Beijing Foreign Studies University: The whole work is ingenious and magnificent, and the unique legend of the Oriental Xianxia is hung on the earth, which makes people feel sad and unbearable, and the writing of love is particularly unique.