Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - University rankings - University of Electronic Science and Technology of China Debate Competition: Who do you want to marry, the Monkey King Pig Bajie?
University of Electronic Science and Technology of China Debate Competition: Who do you want to marry, the Monkey King Pig Bajie?
It is better to marry the Monkey King than to argue about marrying Zhu Bajie. Judges, friends and players: > Hello everyone! & gt After carefully reading the articles of other debaters, our view is that it is better to marry Zhu Bajie than the Monkey King. & gt First of all, let's make it clear that our view is that Pig Bajie is a good husband, rather than simply demonstrating that he is a good man. We don't deny that the Monkey King is also a good man, but they belong to different types. A man like the Monkey King is just not the best person to be a good husband. It's a bit confusing to equate a good man with a good husband. & gt The Journey to the West of Wu Cheng'en described with his rich imagination the journey of Tang Priest, the Monkey King, Pig Bajie, Friar Sand and Master and Apprentice who struggled to enter the barren land on the way to learn the scriptures, and visualized their hardships as the eighty-one difficulties set by the devil. The monsters transformed from animals vividly show the dangers of ruthless mountains and rivers, and praise the spirit of subduing demons and subduing demons to overcome difficulties in Buddhist scriptures. The Monkey King and Zhu Bajie are two important figures in the novel. The Monkey King, in particular, is the soul of this novel. "(The red font is the original text, the same below. It is true that the Monkey King is indeed the protagonist of the novel as another defense friend said, but it is far-fetched to prove that the Monkey King is a good husband. Another debater said, "Wu Cheng'en's Monkey King emphasizes emotion and righteousness, and is bold and artistic. He is loyal to Master, loves his disciples, and is loyal and persistent in the pursuit of his career and ideals. " This just proves our view that "the Monkey King is a person who is absolutely career-oriented and has no concern for his family." If a man puts the burden of his family on a woman and leaves her alone in an empty room, he can still be called a good husband, which will break the hearts of women all over the world. & gt Another debater used a long space and his friend's examples to prove his point of view, and only denied the overall situation with individual examples, which was suspected of generalizing the whole. & gt I will further demonstrate that Pig Bajie is the best candidate for a good husband, and marrying Pig Bajie is better than marrying the Monkey King. & gt We know that marriage is a lifelong event for everyone, especially for women. As the saying goes, "men are afraid to get into the wrong business, and women are afraid to marry the wrong person." Marriage is "from now on", which is a lifetime thing, because marrying a person is not simply choosing that person, but choosing a lifestyle. The other debater repeatedly claimed that "the Monkey King's filial piety to Master, his love for other disciples, and his love for the monkeys in Huaguoshan all show that he is a family-loving person. At the flat peach party on the queen mother's birthday, I was as drunk as a fiddler, and I didn't forget to take more delicious food back for the monkeys. " But another friend forgot the most important point. Other disciples refer to brothers, not the woman they love. The Monkey King is the most capable, full of friendship, and loves to fight against injustice. This kind of person can be a friend of the opposite sex, but it is not appropriate to marry him. When men and women get along, we often hear women complain, coquetry and say, you are a pig. We didn't see anyone, pointing to each other and saying, you monkey king. It can be seen that in women's minds, everyone thinks that Pig Bajie exists in a very lovely image, and this image has been recognized by women. & gt while the other party says that the Monkey King is a man who values affection and righteousness and is filial to his master, then in the 14th Journey to the West, "Can you listen to my teachings this time?" Monkey said, "Listen to me!" "Can you be a little more rude?" "I dare not!" Said the monkey. Although he said yes, he still felt very uncomfortable. He flashed his needle and made the bowl thick and thin, hoping that the Tang Priest would do it. He was so scared that the elder read it two or three times. The monkey fell to the ground, lost his iron bar and couldn't raise his hand. He just taught, "Master! I know! Don't think about it, don't think about it! " As you can see, will a man who doesn't listen to Master's teachings and still has evil thoughts and duplicity be a good husband who loves his wife? On the other hand, Pig Bajie always tugged at his ear and called him an "idiot" on the way to learn the scriptures, but Pig Bajie didn't get angry once and still called him brother affectionately. Comparing the two, it is clear who is superior and who is inferior. & gt In the daily life of husband and wife, when both men and women talk, Pig will naturally bow gently, and the Monkey King is afraid that he will wave it down without saying a word. How can such a man feel safe? Imagine: When two main members of a family are in conflict, according to their personalities, what will the Monkey King and Pig do? There is no doubt that Pig Bajie will be optimistic about the problem, patiently appease us and ease our bad mood. We can blame people like him for twisting their ears and noses, bossing around and coquetry. The Monkey King, on the other hand, is very different, because he has a critical eye, and there is nothing to be spoiled in front of him; Impatience is also a common problem of monkeys, so people often say sour-faced monkeys; You tell him that he will be more anxious than you and will complain that you don't listen to him. In a hurry, you may even throw a golden hoop, or run back to Huaguoshan in a rage. Imagine a husband who is neither gentle nor considerate nor flexible. Who can stand it? & gt On the other hand, the Monkey King is more human and affectionate than Pig Bajie, so please look at the middle paragraph of The Journey to the West: Arnold and Ye Jia show the scriptures to the Tang Priest and say to him, "The holy monk came here from the East. What personnel do you want to send us?" Take it out quickly so that I can pass it on to you. Hearing this, Sanzang said, "Disciple Xuanzang came a long way, but he was unprepared. The second elder smiled and said, "Good, good, good! Handed down from scratch, future generations will starve to death! Seeing him prevaricating and refusing to preach the scriptures, Monkey couldn't help crying, "Master, let's tell the Tathagata to teach him to preach the scriptures to me himself." . "Arnold said," stop shouting! What is this place, you are still wild! Come here and continue. "Friar Sand held his temper, advised Monkey and turned to meet him." This description shows that he knows nothing about the basic ways of the world, so how can he survive in today's society? I am afraid that I am tortured by anger everywhere, and I am afraid that I can no longer be calm. & gt Another debater thinks that pigs are greedy for money, but we disagree. Pig Bajie's "greed for money" should actually cherish money, not the "greed" shown in his bones. This is only the performance of the vulnerable groups when they are forced by life, and it is the need for survival. We can't wait for death quietly on an empty stomach, can we? ! As the saying goes, "No matter how rich the spirit is, people should dress and eat." When life is in danger, great men have taken risks to "steal", not to mention that Pig Bajie is just an ordinary person. In ancient China, there was a saying that "a gentleman loves money". Throughout the ages, it is precisely because of people's love for money that people struggle for themselves and promote economic development, and today they have rich material enjoyment. What's more, "home" must be built on a certain material basis. & gt The opponent's friend said: Pigs fell in love with beautiful goblins when they saw them. When he arrived in his daughter country, he wanted to stay and find a wife to live with. There are countless examples of this. He never forgot Chang 'e, but why did he forget Gao Xiulan? Back in Gaojiazhuang ... Here, we can't help asking each other if they have seen The Journey to the West carefully. Volume 18 of the original book clearly States: Gao: "It's a pity that an old chap like me has never had a son, but he gave birth to three daughters. The first one is called Yulan, the second one is called Cuilan. ..... "Excuse me, another debater, where did Gao Xiulan come from? The other debater said that Pig Bajie was not generous. It has been mentioned many times in the original work that Wukong called Bajie "an ear" and "an idiot". What's more, when the Monkey King was expelled by his master and invited the Monkey King to Huaguoshan, he was deliberately hailed as a "savage" by the Monkey King. Did Bajie care? It can be seen that the other debater didn't read the original carefully and didn't know much about the story in the original. We deeply regret it. & gt In addition, I would like to ask another debater, can we interpret a novel out of the life and cultural background at that time? As we all know, the analysis of any novel can't be divorced from the historical background at that time, and The Journey to the West is no exception. It was out of the background of cultural life at that time that the debater of the other side came to the conclusion that "pigs are eight quit to spend their hearts". At that time, men were allowed to have three wives and four concubines, so whether Chang 'e or Gao's family had three daughters, there was nothing wrong with pigs in the social background at that time. The so-called "everyone has a love for beauty", "My fair lady, a gentleman is good at walking", and Confucius also said "it is also erotic". From the original Journey to the West, we can't read the description of Zhu Bajie's "lust" at all. We don't think Zhu Bajie is greedy for beauty, but expresses his true and simple thoughts without reservation, which is frank and realistic, much better than those hypocritical "hypocrites"! & gt Throughout the Journey to the West, there is no reflection that the Monkey King has a favorite woman, as if he had never had any physical and psychological needs in this respect. We can't help wondering: is he a normal person after all? Can a woman get happiness when she marries her? From the beginning to the end, there is no expression of the Monkey King's passion for women in the original book, he just connects reality with imagination out of thin air. I wonder why the other debater came to the conclusion that he would be kind to women. & gt In the Journey to the West, the Monkey King changed from an orphan with intelligent nature to perseverance and diligence in his studies, but he was willful and reckless. He was crushed by the Tathagata Buddha at the foot of Wuzhishan Mountain for 500 years, and was enlightened by the Buddha before he went to the Western Heaven to learn Buddhist scriptures with Master. He can exorcise demons all the way, which others can't. His principles and rationality, his critical eyes, where is he still an ordinary person? Although he values affection and righteousness, loves master and learns from exorcism, he has never loved a woman alone! Neither banshee nor fairy touched his heart of stone. Excuse me, female compatriots, are we willing to spend our lives with someone who doesn't love us? Do we dare to marry those who are indifferent to ourselves? & gt Another debater said, "Just because he didn't love a woman on his way to the West doesn't mean he will never love a woman." Then, we would like to ask our opponents: At the end of the Buddhist scriptures, the Monkey King was made a god and enshrined in a temple. They call each other "Xianyou" and "Daoyou". Now that the story is over, can you imagine how the Monkey King, who has become a fairy, will live? & gt& gt To sum up, we think it is better to marry Zhu Bajie than the Monkey King.