In a narrow sense, educational novels are German initiation novels and English initiation novels. The Concise Encyclopedia Britannica defines Bildungsroman as: "A German novel that describes a person's life in the period of character formation. Sometimes it is also called' character-forming novel'. The first educational novel is Goethe's Apprentice of William Meister (1795- 1796). It is still typical of this novel. "
There are two kinds of educational novels in a narrow sense: one is a school education novel or a family education novel, which tells the story of school education or family education. Such as Rousseau's Emile and Pestalozzi's Lianhard and Godud. The authors of this kind of novels can be regarded as "writers of educators"; The second is "Bildungsroman", which describes a character's suffering and confusion in the critical period of growth, and then gradually matures, such as Goethe's The Learning Age of William Meister and Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye. In Bildungsroman, the scene of education turns from school to society. Educators are usually no longer teachers or parents, but life itself. The way of growth is no longer influenced by teachers or parents, but self-education. The authors of such novels can be regarded as "educators among writers".