I think it's Cao Cao.
Read the text first. Don't tell me that Zhuge Liang has an example and is famous for his loyalty and true feelings. His literary talent is not very good, and everyone who knows literature knows it. Cao Cao's poems are magnificent. His eyes are not only a narrow world, but also a natural domineering and heroic spirit, which is reflected in looking at the sea. First of all, their literary realm is much worse.
Secondly, look at Wu and Cao Cao who killed dozens of people and fled with their bare hands. I think it goes without saying that Wen Chou also died at his hands. Yan Liang was beheaded by Guan Yu. Zhuge Liang = = Do you think he can fight?
Then there is ingenuity. Cao Cao started from scratch, ranking second in the world. The failure of reunification is also due to mistakes. Zhuge Liang was in a peaceful corner and didn't fight many wars. Moreover, Cao Cao is the master and Zhuge Liang is the counselor, obviously not in the same class. If you want to compare, compare Cao Cao's ingenuity with him.
Historical contribution: Cao Cao made the greatest contribution in the last three Jin Dynasties. Zhuge Liang split the country and prolonged the war again.
Summary: Cao Cao is much more powerful than Zhuge Liang.
Luo Guanzhong plays it so well that it is invincible. I am helpless about many NC's. Interviewee: Pure water fainting | Level 5 | 20 1 1-6-3 22:02
Throughout the Three Kingdoms period, Cao Cao was the best! No one can match Wen Tao's skill and heart. Responder: Hou Yingzhan | Level II | 201-6-3 22: 06.
Zhuge Liang in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a complete myth. In Chen Shou's Three Kingdoms, Zhuge Liang is unparalleled in both internal affairs and military affairs.
Personally, I think Cao Cao is better. In history, Cao Cao was an awesome politician, strategist and poet. Zhuge Liang is politically awesome, but militarily poor. Respondents: Animal Love Shibao | Level 2 | 201-6-322:11.
You can watch Reflection or Lecture Room.
About borrowing arrows from grass boats.
It was actually Sun Quan, not Zhuge Liang, who borrowed the straw boat to shoot arrows. Sun Quan once inspected the front line and was discovered by Cao Cao because he could only shoot arrows in the fog. Sun Quan only made the hull full of arrows in order to keep the hull balanced.
The following is taken from Yi Zhongtian's The Three Kingdoms.
For the three countries, Zhuge Liang is the most heinous image. Other things, such as burning Wang Bo, burning new fields and empty city plans, are all made up. For example, the story of the empty city plan actually exists, but it did not happen to Zhuge Liang, but to Cao Cao. When Cao Cao and Lu Bu were fighting, once Cao Cao's army went out of the city to harvest wheat, and suddenly Lu Bu's army came. In desperation, Cao Cao took all his family members to stand guard on the wall. When Lu Bu drove over, the city was singing and dancing, and the sound was good. Look, there is a forest outside the city, which is unfathomable. Lu Bu thinks that Cao Cao is a sly thief and must have bought an ambush in the forest. Leave! Think about it after withdrawing it. I'm not reconciled. The next day, he came again. This time, Cao Cao really ambushed in the Woods. Respondents: Diandian _ Happy | Level 6 | 201-6-3 22:12.
Cao Cao is fierce, scheming and starting from scratch. Respondents: enthusiastic users | 2011-6-322:14.
This is an incomparable problem,
For example, Zhuge Liang is a gifted strategist who is good at governing the country, but he is not suitable for leading troops to fight and is in charge of the military, while Zhou Yu is quite suitable for leading troops to fight. Because of the battles fought by Kong Ming's troops, they failed to win many times. For example, they failed to win the "Six Outings from Qishan". But his "spirit" is outstanding: after being invited out of the mountain by Liu Bei, he immediately sent troops to station on the deserted Shu Road, and others were puzzled. It was not until the death of Kong Ming that this unit was withdrawn. At this moment, Sima Yi led his troops and troops to attack Shu directly from that Shu Road and make it perish.
Cao Cao is an excellent politician and strategist. He is also good at managing the country and making people well fed and clothed, but sometimes he will spare people's lives for his own benefit. Didn't he say, "I'd rather lose the world than the world lose me"? It's just that Cao Cao was too suspicious, which made him lose many battles.
Both are worth learning. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages, and cannot be compared unilaterally.
If you really want to compare, feel it with your own heart. After all, everyone has a different opinion.
Maybe these will help you. Please feel for yourself. Respondent: Qiao Zhuchan | Level II | 201-6-3 22:17.
Each has his own strengths, one is a generation of heroes, and the other is a hero who attracts much attention. The two of them are also supporting the world's ambitions. Respondent: Aries 30 14 | 5 | 20 1 1-6-3 22:24
Most supportive of Zhuge Liang. Responder: lrjnb007 | Level 1 | 20 1 1-6-3 22:28.
Aside from supporting Liu's thought of opposing Cao in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, from an official point of view, Cao Cao is more powerful than Zhuge Liang. History defines Cao Cao as a politician, strategist and writer. He started from scratch, successively broke the yellow turban insurrectionary, begged Dong Zhuo, captured Lu Bu, destroyed Yuan Shu, collected Yuan Shao, went deep into Saibei and reached Liaodong, basically pacified the north and stabilized the chaos in the world. Military can also be called utilization. In poetry, he also has his own unique style, and has the reputation of "Three Caos", while Zhuge Liang seems to be much inferior, politically acceptable, governing the country and keeping the people safe, and staying in the rear, but militarily, it seems worse. I was beaten out of the water when I was young, and I didn't get what I wanted when I left Qishan. Liu Bei went to Shu to capture Hanzhong with Pang Tong. Zhuge Liang is just a talent for governing the country, not as good as Cao Cao! Respondent: 9 13873 185 | Level 3 | 20 1 1-6-3 22:35.
They are all very powerful. In fact, it is not all fiction to write Zhuge Liang's superior intelligence in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Not to mention Zhuge running the country. Moreover, Cao Cao is not only military, but also literate, which is not generally strong. As for employing people and mind, not to mention, Cao Cao defeated Zhuge Liang in this respect. After the battle of Guandu, Cao Cao found the letters of his subordinates who had an affair with Yuan Shao before the war, and burned them without reading them. Zhuge Liang's requirements for talents are too harsh and biased. Wei Yan is like this. Besides, he doesn't trust others to do things. The book says that he should personally ask those who punish him with more than 20 military staff officers. Others advised him not to do everything by himself. He said he was afraid that others would not be like me. Imagine how this distrust of your subordinates is conducive to the cultivation of young talents. Finally, Zhuge Liang is to blame for the lack of talents in Shu and Han! Zhuge Liang only found second-and third-rate talents like Fei Yi, Dong Yun and Jiang Wan who didn't have enough courage, because he needed to rest assured that he wouldn't change his decision. For talents like Wei Yan, Zhuge Liang has always been restless and suppressed everywhere. His mind can be seen. Besides, doing everything by hand is also suicidal. At the same time, Zhuge Liang's strategic vision is also problematic. It is ok to defend firmly with the strength of Shu Han. The active attack exhausted the poor financial resources of Shu Han, which eventually led to his demise. It can be said that Zhuge Liang was the chief culprit of the demise of Shu Han.
So on the whole, Cao Cao is better than Zhuge Liang. Interviewee: IX630 | Level 4 | 201-6-3 22: 48
Cao Cao. According to historical facts, the contemporary hero should be Cao Cao. I believe everyone has read Chairman Mao's "Spring and Snow in Qinyuan"! I think only Cao Cao has the general style he described! Respondent: G Geliang | Floor 5 | 201-6-3 22: 49
(I prefer Zhuge Liang) According to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, I think Zhuge Liang is a talented person. According to the rivers and lakes of the Three Kingdoms, there is "Wolong Feng Chu" (Wolong-Zhuge Liang, Feng Chu-Pang Tong). Whoever wins the first place will win the world (but Pang Tong is useless and seldom used), and Liu Bei is also out of the Jianghu because of Zhuge Liang. . . Even the "steamed bread" we eat now was invented by Zhuge Liang.
Zhuge Liang did more than that. How many plans does he have? Burned Wang Po, captured Meng Huo seven times, intellectually humiliated Zhong Da, burned Chibi (Zhou Yu), three Qi Zhou Yu, Longzhong Dui, intelligently calculated Huarong Road, retired Lu Xun's Bagua Array, and intelligently collected Jiang Wei. Those who were determined to show their talents in the army set fire to Qishan six times, burned Xintian to behead Wei Yan, and Wolong mourned. Grass boats borrowed arrows and left empty cities. . .
And Cao Cao! I think it belongs to a traitor. Isn't there a white-faced Cao Cao in Beijing Opera? The white face in Beijing opera means treacherous and cunning.
Everyone has seen the nearest Chibi! In the last scene, Cao Cao was so arrogant. (people who don't know will go and see for themselves)
So I personally think Zhuge Liang is more powerful! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Respondents: enthusiastic users | 2011-6-3 22: 51
In the eighteenth year of Jian 'an, Cao Cao rose up and claimed to be 400,000 yuan, personally conquering Sun Quan. In the first month of the following year, Cao Jun went to ruxu (now southeast of Chao County, Anhui Province), breached Sun Quan's camp in Jiangbei, and captured Sun Quan's general Gongsun Yang alive. Sun led 70,000 troops to ruxu to resist Cao Jun. The two armies were at loggerheads for more than a month, but each got nothing. Cao Cao saw that Sun Quan was strong and hard to win, so he withdrew his troops and returned to the north. -Cao Cao did not defeat Sun Quan.
In the twenty-third year of Jian 'an, Liu Bei led the army into Yangpingguan, and Xia and others confronted Liu Bei. In July, Cao Cao personally led the army to Guanzhong, sitting in Chang 'an, so as to command the Hanzhong war situation at any time. In the first month of the 24th year of Jian 'an, Liu Bei crossed Mianshui (now Hanshui) from Yangpingguan south, advanced along the mountain and settled in Dingjun Mountain (now southeast of Mianxian County, Shaanxi Province). Xia School competed with Liu Bei for terrain and was killed and defeated by Liu Bei. Cao Cao abandoned Hanzhong and all the troops withdrew to Chang 'an. -Cao Cao was defeated by Liu Bei.
In July of the 24th year of Jian 'an, just after Cao Cao withdrew from Hanzhong, Guan Yu, the general of Liu Bei, launched an attack from Jingzhou to his southeast defense line Xiang and Fan. Hearing this, Cao Cao immediately sent a general Yu Jin to lead the troops to save Fan Cheng. In August, Guan Yu took advantage of the flood to break the Forbidden City and unify the seven armies. He took advantage of the situation to March and surrounded Fancheng. There were only a few thousand Cao troops in Fancheng at that time, and the city was flooded. The water was only a few feet away from the tower, and Coss led the army to defend. Cao Cao sent Huang Xu to save Fancheng. In October, Cao Cao rushed to Luoyang from Guanzhong and personally directed the rescue of Fancheng.
Sun Quan didn't want Guan Yu's influence to develop, because Guan Yu was in the upper reaches, and he already had the heart to seize Jingzhou, so he joined forces with Cao Cao and prepared to attack Jiangling, the important place of Jingzhou with General Monroe. After receiving the letter, Cao Cao informed Coss of the news and ordered him to stick to it. He arrived in Mobei (now southeast of jia county, Henan), near the headquarters. He sent the 12th battalion to reinforce Huang Xu and ordered him to fight back against Guan Yu. Soon, Lv Meng successfully captured Jiangling. Guan Yu retired and was captured and killed by Sun Quanjun on the way. -Cao Cao didn't defeat Guan Yu, but Lu Meng defeated Guan Yu.
Cao Cao is not only an outstanding politician and strategist in the history of China, but also an outstanding writer. His Autumn Records, Short Songs, Cold Travel and Jieshi Pian are all immortal literary works.
Since Cao Cao's southern expedition, he has collected 70,000-80,000 land and water troops from Liu Cong and seized a lot of grain and weapons. After occupying Jiangling, he decided to pursue victory along the river, wipe out Liu Bei and Liu Qi in one fell swoop, and then make a plan to cross the river.
————————————————————————————————————
Zhuge Liang wrote a letter to Liu Chan before he died, saying that he had 800 mulberry trees and 15 hectares of wasteland in Chengdu, which could meet the needs of the whole family and children. I work outside all the year round, relying on the country for food and clothing, and I have never had any savings or industry. After his death, after counting, it was as he said. It serves to show that Zhuge Liang has a position, but he can be strict with himself.
Zhuge Liang's life can be roughly divided into three periods. The first period was before joining the Liu Bei Group, which was the growth period of teenagers, ***27 years; The second period was to help Liu Bei establish and consolidate his political power, from 207 to 222, * * *16; The third period, 223-234, *** 12, was the period of assisting Liu Chan to control Shu Han and northern expedition to Cao Wei.
Zhuge Liang's historical activities in the past 28 years have fully demonstrated his outstanding knowledge and talent in politics, military affairs and diplomacy. Chen Shou commented on Zhuge Liang in the History of the Three Kingdoms: Zhuge Liang, as a prime minister, can appease the people, establish laws and regulations, rectify official positions, follow the power system, and be open and honest; Those who are loyal and beneficial to the country will undoubtedly be rewarded even if there is a gap, and those who violate the law and neglect their duties, even their own relatives, will be punished; For those who truly plead guilty and tell the truth, the crime can be released even if it is serious, and for those who quibble and deny the cover-up, the crime should be severely punished even if it is light; Reward good deeds, no matter how small, and condemn evil deeds, no matter how small; Handle political affairs concisely, grasp the essence of things, observe people faithfully, and refuse to hire hypocritical people; Because of his just heart and clear rewards and punishments, people all over the country fear and respect him. Although the criminal law is severe, no one complains. Zhuge Liang, like Guan Zhong and Xiao He, can be regarded as an outstanding talent who knows how to govern the country.
Although Chen Shou's evaluation of Zhuge Liang is inevitably suspected of beautification and exaggeration, it at least reflects Zhuge Liang's personal moral ability and achievements in managing Sichuan to some extent, which is worth learning from.
————————————————————————————————————————
Zhuge Liang had clear rewards and punishments, enlightened policies, and was good at governing the country, wooing ethnic minorities and easing the relationship between Sichuanese and Liu Bei's foreign troops. Qiao Zhou was not convinced, of course. He surrendered.
Zhuge Liang is a true politician with a heart. He is broader-minded than Cao Cao. Of course, Cao Cao also loved talents, but he was cruel and didn't take killing seriously, killing Liucheng and Xuzhou. Zhuge Liang has no selfish thoughts at all, and loves talents wholeheartedly.
Zhuge Liang is slightly superior to Cao Cao in military affairs. I gave an example of Cao Cao. Battle of Red Cliffs inadvertently didn't underestimate his enemies. After Battle of Red Cliffs, Cao Cao fought against Liu Bei and Guan Yu, and failed to fight against Sun Quan. This is Cao Cao's own information. Zhuge Liang didn't fight many wars. The battles he personally commanded were excellent, but Ma Su was misused by Jieting, and several failures in Liuchu Qishan's later period were all subject to logistical problems.
Most people think that Cao Cao is powerful because he sees that Cao Cao has a large territory and strong national strength. That's not because of people, but because of the right time and place. Zhuge Liang made his fortune early and was born early. How can Cao have a big territory?
Zhu Gekongming has the lofty integrity of "doing my best until I die" and the ambition to help people rebuild a peaceful and prosperous world. But he can't escape the "foolish loyalty" thought of the ancients, but he is also understandable.
Cao Mengde is an adulterer. He "would rather teach me to be negative towards the whole world than myself". He is a political careerist and schemer, and we can learn a thing or two from the wrongful murder of the Lv Boshe family.
Throughout the history of the Three Kingdoms, there are many talented people, many of whom are brave and good at fighting. However, not many people have both, let alone their respective destinations. For example, Du Lubu was the best soldier in the world, but he didn't have sincerity and faith, and eventually he died. Sadly, Meng De was wise, but his country was stolen by others.
Rolling the Yangtze River eastward,
The waves washed away the hero.
Right or wrong, success or failure,
Castle peak is still there,
A touch of sunset red.
White-haired fishing fires in Zhu Jiang,
I am used to watching the autumn moon and the spring breeze.
A pot of turbid wine likes to meet,