At present, Jilin Publishing Bureau has set up a special working group to investigate the magazine Picture Geography that published this article in response to the paper on egg retrogradation that has been circulated wildly on the Internet. This article is not funny at all, it not only violates the basic principles of science, but also violates many common sense problems. It is incredible that such an article can be published in an academic magazine. According to the statistics of Chinese academic circles, there are more than one wonderful paper published in journals, and a considerable number of low-quality academic papers appear in domestic journals every year. There may be several reasons why these papers can pass the exam.

First, the review of periodicals and magazines is not done well. If this wonderful paper can be published in provincial journals, the first thing to be responsible for is the review, proofreading and editing of journals and magazines. If the review and proofreading of journals are very rigorous and responsible, then it is impossible to violate the basic principles and the papers can still be published in journals. Therefore, the person in charge of periodical review needs to bear the most important responsibility.

Second, the author of the paper also has great responsibility. Secondly, the author of the paper also has great responsibility. The quality of a paper depends on how the author writes it, and such another paper completely violates the basic principles of science and some common sense, which is not only irresponsible to himself, but also irresponsible to the masses. Authors also need to bear great responsibility for submitting such articles to provincial journals.

Third, the paper can be published in this journal, and the high probability is to find an intermediary to buy pages for publication. Therefore, the intermediary also needs to be responsible for the intermediary editor who buys and sells papers. Intermediary editors are responsible for contacting the authors of academic papers and the journals that publish them, which is a very common phenomenon in academic circles. The basic content and quality of the previous articles are guaranteed, but it is totally unimaginable that such articles are actually published in provincial journals. Therefore, the intermediary editor also needs to bear a very important responsibility in this incident.