That is to say, according to wartime qualifications, 1955 can be rated as a general. However, after the founding of New China, they all left the army and went to work in the central or local government, instead of taking part in the evaluation of professional titles. He Changgong, Wu Xiuquan and Geng Biao later returned to the army and were in the middle of two ranks, so they were called "generals without titles".

In both cases, they can be called "generals without titles".

1952 when the troops were graded, they had already done local work and had no rank. So 1955 didn't decide. When they returned to the army, they were in the "no title period". 1988 When the rank system was restored, they had retired and were "generals without titles" of our army.