Current location - Education and Training Encyclopedia - Graduation thesis - Celebrity comments on Romance of the Three Kingdoms
Celebrity comments on Romance of the Three Kingdoms
Question 1: Ask ten celebrities to evaluate the romance of the Three Kingdoms, not the characters in the story, but the author or source! Lu Xun's evaluation of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms shows that Zhuge Rui is wise and close to the demon.

Question 2: The original comments of famous experts on The Romance of the Three Kingdoms (about 100 words).

Romance of the Three Kingdoms is seven realities and three vacuities. [19]- (Qing) Zhang Xuecheng

Few people in the world have read the History of the Three Kingdoms, but they have got the outline of Luo Guanzhong's romance. [20]-(Qing) Wei Jieke

As for writing people, it is also quite a loss, so that to show Liu Bei's long and thick falsehood, Zhuge's wisdom is close to the demon; It's just that Guan Yu is very kind and brave, and he can always tell. [2 1] ―― Lu Xun's A Brief History of Chinese Novels

It is true that The Romance of the Three Kingdoms and The Water Margin are still very popular in China, but this is because the society still has the spirit of the Three Kingdoms and the spirit of the Water Margin. -Lu Xun's "Two Essays on Cutting Street Pavilion"

Although the current edition of this book (Mao Zonggang edition) is the last revised edition, it can still be regarded as a very powerful lecture on popular history, rather than a book of literary value. ..... On the other hand, The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is an excellent popular history after all. [22]-Hu Shi's preface

Question 3: What do celebrities have to say about the characters in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms? They are capable ministers who rule the world and treacherous people in troubled times. Shu Wei

Chen Shou: "At the end of the Han Dynasty, the world was in chaos, and the heroes rose together, while Yuan Shaohu's four states were extremely powerful. Mao strategized, castigated the magic of Shen and Shang, used the unique tactics of Han and Bai, and granted official materials, each for his own devices, melodramatic, and forgot the old evils. In the end, he was able to conquer the imperial court machine and become a flood maker, but it was only slightly better. I can be described as an extraordinary person and a peerless hero. " Shu Wei

Wang Shen: I have served in the imperial army for more than 30 years, and I don't want to give up my book. The book talks about the art of war and thinks about classics at night. Climbing to the top must be given, and the strings of new poems make a movement. Shu Wei

Zhong Rong: Cao Gong is old and straight, and there is a sad saying. -"Poetry"

Pei Songzhi commented on Cao Cao: "Looking back at ancient and modern books, it is very important to be greedy, ruthless and ruthless." -History of the Three Kingdoms (Note)

Emperor Taizong said to Cao Cao: "In times of crisis, we should control changes and expect the enemy to set up strange tricks. Once we make them smart, we will have more than enough talents. "

Tang Xuanzong often compared himself to "A God".

Yuan Zhen commented on Cao Cao: "Cao Cao's rebellion began." -"Dong Escape"

Liu Zhiji commented on Cao Cao: "The most heinous crime is the disaster of Wang Mang." -"stone? survey

Lu Xun said: "Cao Cao is at least a hero."

Emperor Kangxi of the Qing Dynasty: "Zhuge Liang Yun: Do your best until you die. Only Zhuge Liang can be such a minister. "

Sun Qiao in the Tang Dynasty: "The marquis of Wu has been dead for almost 500 years. Up to now, the people of Liang and Han have a strong legacy, temples and worshippers are all there, and the heart of loving the people has been so long. "

In the Western Jin Dynasty, Mei Tao praised Tao Kan and said, "The machine god is like Wei Wu, and the loyalty is like Kong Ming."

Question 4: What did celebrities say about Zhuge Liang in history? Emperor Kangxi of the Qing Dynasty: "Zhuge Liang Yun: Do your best until you die. Only Zhuge Liang can be such a minister. "

Sun Qiao in the Tang Dynasty: "The marquis of Wu has been dead for almost 500 years. Up to now, the people of Liang and Han have a strong legacy, temples and worshippers are all there, and the heart of loving the people has been so long. "

In the Western Jin Dynasty, Mei Tao praised Tao Kan and said, "The machine god is like Wei Wu, and the loyalty is like Kong Ming."

Changqu in the Eastern Jin Dynasty: "Governing the country is courtesy to the people, no complaints, no lynching, no tears."

Wang Tong of the Sui Dynasty said, "Zhuge Liang will not die, and the rites and music will flourish."

"Tang Cui Wen" recorded what Shangqi said in Preface to the Inscription of Wuhou Temple in Zhuge: "If official books and temples are eaten, they will become a code that will not be published. Every time there is a popular grass movement in Yamanouchi, it looks like a powerful god. In the old days, if there was a drought, people all over the country would pray for clouds and rain, which meant survival without anyone benefiting and sharing life and death. Death is immortal, but it is more expensive than life. " Another article, Lu Wen's Zhuge Wuhou Temple, said: "If you don't gather great glory, Heaven will seize its soul. Sincerely unforgettable, the ice is in the sun and the moon, and the ferocity does not come away. It is a thunderstorm. "

Du Fu, a famous poet in the Tang Dynasty, once praised Zhuge Liang's deeds and wrote several poems about Zhuge Liang, including Shuxiang (including two poems with the same name), Four Monuments of Yonghuai, Zhu Gekongming, Eight Arrays, A Journey to Cooper, Temple of Wuhou, Temple of Zhuge and Ge Ye. In Shuxiang, the third call increased his burden of handling state affairs, and he gave his sincerity to two generations. But before he conquered, he was dead, and the heroes cried on their coats from then on, which became a famous sentence of Zhuge Liang's life.

Other poets also praised Zhuge Liang in many poems, such as Reading Zhuge Wuhou's Book and Giving Chang 'an Uncle Cui Shaofu a Kunji, Zhuge Wuhou by Wang Anshi, a statesman and writer in the Song Dynasty, Wuhou Temple by Yang Shen, a writer in the Ming Dynasty, Shu Dao Qi by Guo Moruo, a modern politician Dong Helu and so on.

* * * commented: "It was a mistake in Longzhong, thousands of miles away, and it was divided into two forces. In the end, Guan Yu, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang were invincible. " The previous sentence means that Zhuge Liang's strategy is inappropriate. Jingzhou and Yizhou are thousands of miles apart, and the practice of dividing the two places will inevitably make Shu Han lose its military advantage. The last sentence "three components" refers to Guan Yu guarding Jingzhou, Liu Bei attacking Wu Dong, and Zhuge Liang northern expedition to the Central Plains. The historical fact of "three components" eventually led to the loss of China's unified foundation. However, some people disagree with * * *' s analysis. Longzhong's northern expedition to Jingzhou Army held the hope of "benefiting the South China Sea", and Yizhou implemented the pincer strategy, but Liu Bei failed to realize it later, and Guan Yu lost his advantage in the battle of Xiangfan because of the loss of Nanjun, not because of separatist forces. On the other hand, regarding the historical events of losing the street pavilion and beheading Ma Su, * * * once commented: "The first battle is bright, and it is appropriate to go to the battlefield." It is believed that Zhuge Liang should have led the army forward at that time, and should not have scattered his troops and entrusted him with heavy responsibilities.

The psychological couplets hung in Zhuge Liang Hall of Wuhou Temple in Chengdu were written by Zhao Fan, a scholar in Qing Dynasty. This couplet has attracted the attention of * * *, and its content is:

"If you can make progress, you will be self-defeating, and you will know that the soldiers are not good at fighting;

It is wrong to combine leniency with severity without judging the situation. You should think hard about governing Shu in the future. "

Sun Yat-sen, the father of the Republic of China, praised Zhuge Liang in "The Three People's Principles of Civil Rights": "Zhuge Liang is very capable, so he can make a good contribution in Xishu, and he can make a northern expedition from six places in Qishan, ranking third with Wu Wei." .

Question 5: Urgent! ! ! Want celebrity's evaluation of the characters in the romance of the Three Kingdoms! ! ! I haven't really paid attention to this, but I still know one.

Lu Xun's evaluation of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms shows that Zhuge Rui is wise and close to the demon.

Question 6: Which celebrities in history have commented on Liu Bei? This evaluation is quite a lot, I will try to say a few more, hehe, I hope it is useful to the landlord.

1, Chen Shou's "Three Kingdoms" "The whole country is lonely in Zhuge Liang, unintentionally. Sincerely, the monarch and the minister are supreme, and the ancient and modern tracks are prosperous. " This evaluation has reached a certain level, saying that Liu Bei's relationship between monarch and minister at this time has reached the most selfless level here, which is the highest model of the relationship between monarch and minister in past dynasties.

2. Pei Songzhi: Shu and Hanzhong are as close as lips and teeth. Liu Zhu's wisdom is not as good as this. The plan hasn't been made yet. It's the first ear. Husband heard Jia said that the business was successful. Who is the overlord? Wei Wu thinks that what people teach is not bad! This is a statement of shame and hatred, which is not correct.

3. Su Zhe's On the Three Kingdoms: Sun is not as good as Cao and Liu is not as good as Sun. Liu Bei is short of wit and courage, so he is confused when he doesn't know that he is not smart enough to win. Gai Liu Bei's talent is similar to that of Gaozu, but he doesn't know how to use it. In the past, Gaozu used it for his own use because there were three ways: one was to show the shape of the world according to the victory; The more letters you receive, the more surprised you will be. Help yourself. There is a spirit of being strong but not using it, which has deeply broken the rampant trend of Ji Xiang. These three things are the kings of the three kingdoms, and none of them can do it. Only Liu Bei didn't arrive, and he was still elated. He wants to be honest, but not pure. He wants to be sharp, but he can't reach it. The two men fought, but there was no conclusion. You did it. No, neither did you want it. Abandoning the world into Bashu, not land; Use Zhu Gekongming's talents to govern the country, but when there are different conquest forces, it is not necessary; If you can't bear to be angry, you will make mistakes, but if you will attack others, you are not angry enough. Hey, honey! Fang Qi ran between two yuan, trapped in Lu Bu and embarrassed in Jingzhou, but his ambition was not broken. It can be said that there is no wind of high ancestors, and I don't know that the party is for its own use. The hero of fugu, only Han is unattainable.

4. Wang Fuzhi's History as a Mirror: Zhuge Yuzi dared not do his brother's private affairs. When he was on the verge of collapse, he said, "You take it for your own use," but he could not use it. He is arrogant because he believes in feathers, so he refuses to blame Cao Zhi's Tianjin. Is it the feathers? My late master made it happen.

5. Lala by Li Zongwu: (This evaluation is absolutely critical, hehe. His specialty lies in his thick skin: he followed Cao Cao, Lu Bu, Liu Biao, Sun Quan and Yuan Shao, running around and relying on others to support him, and he was not ashamed. Moreover, he cried all his life, and the people who wrote the romance of the Three Kingdoms wrote him vividly. When something can't be solved, he cries at people and immediately turns defeat into victory. Therefore, there is a saying: ". This is also a capable hero. He and Cao Cao are the best of both worlds. When they were talking about heroes while cooking wine, one of them had the darkest heart and the thickest skin, and they met at the same time. You are helpless to me, and I am helpless to you. It is despicable to look around all the people in Yuan Benchu, so Cao Cao said, "The only heroes in the world are the monarch and Cao Cao. "

6. Zhang's Biography of the Three Kingdoms: Liu Bei started from scratch, had no dependence on size, and relied entirely on his persistent subjective efforts to become a hero in troubled times. Chen Shou, the author of The Three Kingdoms, was deeply impressed by Liu Bei and called him his great-grandfather. He compared Liu Bei with Cao Cao-obviously praising Liu and restraining Cao. The description of Cao Cao's life in Ji of Emperor Wudi only says that his father "can't judge his life", which is in sharp contrast to the description in Biography of the First Master that Liu Bei was born "after Wang Jingsheng, the son of Han Jing". Writing about two people's actions, Cao Cao "is less alert and has the right to count things, but it is not surprising in the world that wine, color and governance are like this"; Liu Bei talks little, treats people kindly, has invisible feelings, and is good at making friends with heroes, which is attached to teenagers. In fact, "Ren Xia's debauchery" and "making friends with heroes" are the same behavior, but their personalities are different. Cao Cao was dissolute and looked down upon by the world; Liu Bei is generous and shrewd, and is regarded as a hero. When competing for the Central Plains, Cao Cao "killed too much"; And where Liu Bei lived, people returned. Liu Bei sent assassins to assassinate Liu Bei in Ping Liu of Pingyuan County. "The guest couldn't bear to stab him and left." Chen Shou immediately commented: "It's so popular." But Liu Bei's talent is not as good as that of Cao Cao. "I can't catch Wei Wu in my mouth, so the foundation is too narrow." . Chen Shouyi's comparative writing and criticism show that historians in the Western Jin Dynasty attach great importance to the influence of the moral quality of historical figures on the historical process. This is the reason why Liu Bei's tragic ending is embarrassing.

7. Yi Zhongtian: (This is also an evaluation, although a little modern) Liu Bei is a man with heroic ambition, heroism and heroic soul, so he will never be willing, long-term and forever, so his refuge is "difficult to support"; But as a hero, he must recruit talents and unite a group of people to complete his career. & gt

Question 7: When two people are together, does it matter that girls are taller than boys? Hehe, I'm dizzy

No problem.

What age are you still thinking about this? ~~

Besides, you are thinking of the next generation, and you want them to have a good figure.

Bless you! ~