1. Content quality: check whether the research questions are clear, the research methods are scientific and rigorous, the data are accurate and reliable, and the analysis is thorough. In addition, we should also pay attention to whether the paper has sufficient theoretical basis and empirical support.
2. Structural quality: evaluate whether the structure of the paper is reasonable, including whether the introduction, literature review, methods, results, discussions and conclusions are complete and whether the logic is clear. At the same time, we should also pay attention to whether the hierarchical structure and paragraph division of the paper are reasonable.
3. Language expression: check whether the language of the paper is standardized, accurate and fluent, and whether the words and sentences are appropriate. In addition, we should also pay attention to whether the format and citation of the paper conform to academic norms.
4. Innovation: evaluate whether the research questions of the paper are novel, whether the research methods are innovative, and whether the research results have new insights and inspirations. This can be judged by comparing other related studies.
5. Readability: check whether the paper is easy to read and understand, including whether the text is concise and clear, whether the chart is clear and easy to understand, and whether the references and appendices are complete.
6. Practicality: Evaluate whether the research results of the paper have practical application value and can provide useful reference for research and practice in related fields.
7. Academic influence: Understand the author's academic status and influence in this field, as well as the level and reputation of journals or conferences that publish papers. This is helpful to evaluate the quality and level of the paper.
8. Feedback and evaluation: refer to the opinions and suggestions of experts and scholars in related fields to understand their understanding of the quality and level of papers. This can help us to evaluate the quality and level of the paper more comprehensively.