The provincial education administrative department shall organize peer experts to comment on the randomly matched sampling papers and put forward their opinions.

Each paper is sent to 3 peer experts, and graduation papers with more than 2 (including 2) experts' comments as "unqualified" are regarded as "problematic graduation papers".

Of the three experts, 1 expert's evaluation is "unqualified", and two experts from the same industry will be sent for re-evaluation.

More than 1 experts (including 1 experts) among the two re-evaluation experts are judged as "unqualified" and will be regarded as "problematic graduation thesis".