1. Whether the structure of the article is reasonable: evaluate whether the overall structure of the article is clear, whether the parts are closely connected, and whether the reporting process is smooth.
2. Is the research question important? Assess whether the research question is closely related to the current hot topics or actual needs, and whether it can make practical contributions to the academic and practical fields.
3. Whether the research method is scientific: evaluate whether the research method adopted has been recognized by experts, whether it conforms to the basic principles of scientific research, whether the logic is strict, and whether the accuracy of experimental data is guaranteed.
4. Whether the conclusion is reasonable: evaluate whether the conclusion of the article is based on convincing experimental data, convincing reasoning process and correct statistical analysis results, and whether there is a basis for referring to other research results.
5. Whether the language expression is standardized: check whether the paper has errors in grammar and vocabulary, whether it meets the requirements of academic writing norms, and whether it is readable and understandable.
6. Adequacy of references: evaluate whether the number of references is sufficient, whether the cited documents are authoritative and reliable, and whether they conform to academic norms.
As follows:
Usually, a scientific paper (express or article) contains 9~ 10 parts. If we regard it as a tiger, then the title, author, abstract and key words are the top of the tiger, the introduction is the head of the tiger, the text is the trunk and limbs, and the conclusions, thanks and references are similar to the tail of the tiger.
The tiger's top flower skin is distinctive, which just meets the requirements of the title and abstract of the paper. A tiger's head is small but powerful, just as a brief introduction must be concise and ambitious. The tiger body is vigorous and powerful, which is a portrayal of the large amount of information and in-depth discussion in the text of the article. Although the tiger's tail is small, it is an indispensable balance organ for the tiger. For example, the conclusions and references of the article need to be well summarized and carefully sorted out.